A slew of so-called good government bills cleared a critical legislative hurdle this week and are poised for final approval next week.

But the measure that arguably would have had the most significant impact on Hawaii’s democracy did not make it across Friday’s deadline for bills to advance.

House Bill 1401 would have enacted voting by mail uniformly across all counties for all elections in 2020.

Legislature joint conference committee Taneda. 27 april 2017

Janet Mason of the League of Women Voters and Corie Tanida of Common Cause wait for the conference committee decision on the vote-by-mail bill.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Rep. Scott Nishimoto, the lead House conferee on the bill as well as its author, told his counterpart, Sen. Gil Keith-Agaran, shortly after 5 p.m. that both lawmakers agreed on many aspects of the bill.

But Nishimoto did not get clearance from House leadership, and so HB 1401 will have to wait until next year.

It’s the third year in a row that a vote-by-mail measure has failed to make it out of conference committee.

Hawaii’s voter turnout is mired at the bottom compared with other states, and lawmakers and good-government advocates have been embarrassed by the distinction.

Testimony in support of HB 1401 came from the state Office of Elections, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and the clerks’ offices for all four counties.

Lawmakers themselves also recognize that the trend among local voters is to increasingly vote by mail rather than trudge to polling sites.

Corie Tanida of Common Cause Hawaii and Janet Mason of the League of Women Voters of Hawaii, two prominent good-government groups, were the lead proponents of the vote-by-mail bill.

Like political candidates, they had prepared separate press releases in advance depending on the outcome of the bill’s fate.

“Our Legislature missed another opportunity to improve voter turnout, ignored the advice of election officials and most importantly ignored the wishes of voters — the majority of whom are already voting this way,” said Mason.

Said Tanida: “We should be reducing barriers to voting by seeking proven solutions like vote by mail in order to make voting more convenient and accessible.”

Here’s What Survived

Other bills were approved to address things like enforcing ethics laws that regulate lobbyists, and providing more information about who is spending money in political campaigns.

House Bill 508 calls for updating and streamlining administration and enforcement of the state Code of Ethics and lobbying laws by increasing possible penalties should the law or code be violated.

The State Ethics Commission, which backed the bill, would also be authorized to settle such cases.

Nishimoto also authored the ethics bill, and a related piece of legislation, House Bill 511, which does several things.

It clarifies the laws governing lobbyists by amending the definitions of “expenditure,” “lobbyist” and “lobbying.” It also allows a former employer of a lobbyist to file a notice of termination of employment.

House Finance Chair Scott NIshimoto during meetings held at the Capitol, Room 305. 5 april 2016.

Rep. Scott Nishimoto is chairman of House Judiciary Committee and the author of the good government bills.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Lobbyists registration statements would also have to be posted on the Ethics Commission’s webpage “within a reasonable time” after they are filed, and the posting will remain on the website for at least four years.

Any violation could results in penalties, which under the bill could be as much as $1,000 per violation, a doubling of the current fine.

Nishimoto, who is chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, also introduced House Bill 852.

The bill, once law, is expected to save the Ethics Commission money by allowing it to notify individuals that fail to file their financial disclosure statements by in-person service, email, or first class mail, rather than by the “registered mail, return receipt requested” method.

Failure to file on time could also result in a fine, which would be increased from $50 to $75 and an additional $10 for each day the delinquent filing continues — “a stronger incentive” to do the paperwork on time, lawmakers concluded in a committee report on HB 852.

Dan Gluck, the Ethics Commission executive director, said he was “very pleased” with the Legislature’s “thoughtful consideration” of the bills.

“We have seen some disturbing trends on the mainland regarding government officials’ cavalier attitude towards governmental ethics,” he said Thursday. “Here in Hawaii, however, we take pride in having more than 50,000 state officials and employees who do their jobs with integrity every day.”

Dan Gluck joint conference committee. Chad story. 27 april 2017

Dan Gluck of the Ethics Commission at Thursday’s conference committee deliberations on ethics bills.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Gluck added, “If passed by the Legislature and signed into law by the governor, these bills send a strong message that the people of Hawaii remain committed to ensuring high ethical standards for state officials and employees.”

Two measures that are part of the state Campaign Spending Commission’s legislative package also made the cut.

House Bill 279 would make clear that someone who distributes or republishes certain types of campaign materials — such as fliers or advertisements — would not be considered to have contributed to a campaign.

Another measure in the package, House Bill 281, requires the commission to post on its website the names of all non-candidate committees that fail to file a report or to correct a report within two weeks of receiving a notice.

“Non-candidate committees” refers to a wide range of organizations involved in political campaigns, including labor unions and political action committees.

The prompt online posting, lawmakers reason, will “increase transparency and allow the public access to that information.”

About the Author