What's Your Story?
Readers often have more to offer than a quick comment. This is the place to share your thoughts, anecdotes or even column-length submissions. If you prefer, you may also e-mail your story to connections@civilbeat.com.

TMT Misinforms with Assumptions
About the Author
The Corporations and individuals who support the Thirty Meter Telescope have built their justification on assumptions. Twisting and bending history and truth in an attempt to win support from those unfamiliar with the facts or unwilling to do their own research.
Astronomer George Lyon Tupman, leader of an 1874 project in Honolulu to document the transit of Venus, is pictured here with the telescope that King Kalakaua referred to favorably in a passage now being used by TMT project leaders.
Courtesy of The Hawaiian Journal of History
A prime example of this can be found on the front page of the TMT propaganda website www.maunakeaandtmt.org in this quote from King Kalakaua in 1874: “It will afford me unfeigned satisfaction if my kingdom can add its quota toward the successful accomplishment of the most important astronomical observation of the present century and assist, however humbly, the enlightened nations of the earth in these costly enterprises…”
What they don’t tell you is that the Telescope Kalakaua was referring to was only a few feet long mounted on a tripod in a small yard. The images and the full story, “Astronomy in the Sandwich Islands: The 1874 Transit of Venus” by Michael E. Chauvin, can be found online in The Hawaiian Journal of History here.
TMT makes an assumption that Kalakaua’s statement should be held in perpetuity and implies approval of any telescope regardless. In this same document, the expedition leader refers to Hawaiians as savages, but this is also not mentioned by TMT. They simply chose one statement from a historical record and twisted it to suit their needs.
The TMT is operating on the age-old assumption of “We know what you need better than you.” They are using Hawaiian history, social issues and half-truths to create a story that simply does not exist. Some believe it. Many do not. Resorting to selling their monstrosity to the Hawaiian people with dollar signs and assumed approval of a beloved Monarch is deplorable and shady.
The truth is the truth no matter how you try to twist it, and a little bit of research can easily dispel the myths TMT is spouting.
More Stories

Being Mindful and Respectful in Our Use of Mauna Kea

Participating in Nai Aupuni: Legalizing the Illegal

The Supreme Court is the Court of Last Resort

Mauna Kea: Not A Sacred Place, But A Precious Resource

Restore McKinley’s Rightful Name: Honolulu High School

Justice in the Air: TMT at the Supreme Court

Protests Aren’t Only About Religious Practice

Making Mauna Kea Sacred

Speaking Past Each Other on Mauna Kea

The Heart of a Hawaiian: We Are Mauna Kea

Giving Back: An Appeal to DLNR

In Defense of the Protectors of Mauna Kea

Legally Permitted, TMT Construction Should Start Now

Hawaii’s Technology Crossroads and the TMT

Human Rights, Oppression and Mauna Kea

‘Anti-Science Resistance?’ Let’s Examine the Facts

Hawaii Patriotism vs. U.S. Patriotism: Why is One Valued Over the Other?

How TMT Has Given Rise to What it Means to be Hawaiian

Kanaka Maoli Health Does Not Matter, Kanaka Maoli Do Not Matter

Tutu Mauna and the Meaning of Kapu Aloha

Kapu Aloha: A Positive Way Forward

Are Mauna Kea Observatories Getting a Free Ride?

Indigenous People: Endangered Species in Face of Western Development

The Complicated Classification of Earthlings in Hawaii

The Pale Blue Dot and Our Drive to Understand What Lies Beyond

Enlightening Hawaii’s Economy

Bring Back the Peace Beneath the Stars

Host Culture in Hawaii Is Just a Myth

Respecting the Host Culture: Why Are Guests’ Values More Important?

Advancing Science: Is TMT the Answer?

Space Telescopes Can’t Do What TMT Would

A Simple Alternative to the TMT

Let Honesty, Learning and Decency Guide Mauna Kea Debate

Mauna Kea Equals Beauty, Love and Family

If Most Kanaka Maoli Oppose TMT, It Should Go Elsewhere

View from Mauna Kea: Looking Forward or Looking Back?

Solution to TMT Conflict: Aloha Aina

Why I Declined the TMT THINK Scholarship

Science Is Not White, It’s Color Blind

Westerners Feel at Home, Hawaiians Feel Lost

Revoking the TMT Permits Would Be a Huge Mistake
Have a response?
Share Your Story