Here’s An Affordable Housing Plan That’s Already Working - Honolulu Civil Beat


About the Author

Kenna StormoGipson

Kenna StormoGipson is the director of housing policy for the Hawaii Budget and Policy Center.


Every week newspapers across the country are filled with stories of the crisis in American housing. This week, on Wednesday, in recognition of how great the need is and how large the problem has become, the Biden administration issued a major housing initiative.

Certainly in Hawaii we are feeling it. Average home prices are hitting new record highs — this year Oahu hit the million-dollar mark, and before that it was Kauai and Maui. Since last year, single-family home prices have gone up 23% on Oahu, 24% on the Big Island, 35% on Maui and a staggering 63% on Kauai. Meanwhile, local wages have remained pretty much flat — and in some sectors have been driven down by the pandemic.

So if wages are flat or decreasing, then who is driving up home prices? Many of Hawaii’s homes are sold as investment properties and that trend is increasing. Last year on Maui, for example, 68% of the homes sold were purchased as investment properties; in 2016 that figure was 51%.

Contrast that with the national average in the second quarter of 2021, when across the United States 17% of houses sold were investment properties — a number far lower than Hawaii’s but still one the Biden plan aims to reduce in favor of owner-occupants.

In July of this year the grassroots Maui housing advocacy group Stand Up Maui held a rally in Wailuku to call for more affordable housing. Courtesy Stand Up Maui

In Hawaii the reality is that owners, whether local residents or out-of-state buyers, are willing to pay a premium price for a home they will not live in. The purchase is a type of luxury good, in the sense that it is not essential for a person to own a second home.

In economics, a luxury good is defined as “not essential, but makes life more enjoyable” and “often more expensive and primarily purchased by people with more wealth and income.”

maui locator badge

 

As the state’s homes are increasingly purchased as luxury goods, more residents find themselves unable to even afford a first home.

We live in a society that has normalized the ownership of second homes; millions of Americans have them, including my own family and friends. However, from the standpoint of what is good for the overall community, wouldn’t it make sense to tax investment homes as the luxury goods they are and use the revenue to provide housing that is affordable for all residents?

A community that provides decent housing and prevents people from being houseless benefits everyone, even investment homeowners.

In fact, communities across the country facing housing shortages are taxing themselves to pay for affordable housing to ensure that everyone has at least one home they can afford.

In 2016, voters in Portland, Oregon, passed a measure to increase property taxes by 24 cents per $1,000 of property value to support $254 million worth of investment in housing. This money and other bond measures will produce 8,000 new affordable homes in Portland over the next five years.

Breaking ground for one of Portland’s affordable housing projects, Las Adelitas, a 141-unit multifamily apartment complex scheduled to be completed next summer. Fifty-five units will go to those earning 30% or below area median income and 86 units are for those earning 60% or below area median income. Motoya Nakamura/Multnomah County

That same year the city of Los Angeles asked voters to increase property taxes by 94 cents per $1,000 to support $1.2 billion in affordable housing investment, and 77% of voters approved the measure.

Last year in San Francisco 71% of voters approved a tax of 14 cents per $1,000 of assessed value to support $488 million in housing and homeless services.

In these examples, the tax increase affected all homeowners. But in Hawaii so many properties are second homes or vacation rentals that even a targeted tax on investment properties would make a big difference.

Maui Case Study

Let’s look at Maui as an example. I was part of a team that worked on a comprehensive affordable housing plan for Maui county.

Maui already taxes investment homeowners at a higher rate than owner-occupants. But even that higher rate is still significantly below the average rate elsewhere in the United States. Hawaii has the lowest property taxes in the country, according to a 2021 analysis by WalletHub.

The current tax rate for an investment homeowner on Maui ranges from 0.55% to 0.8%, depending on the value of the home. Short-term rental properties on Maui, which are essentially a substitute for hotels, are taxed at 1.1% to 1.2%. Owners who live in their properties pay a rate that ranges from 0.24% to 0.27%.

In contrast, the average national property tax for homeowners is 1.4%, according to a Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism study from 2017.

For many residents, Maui no ka oi is becoming Maui no can do. The average price of a single-family home on the island tops $1 million, and over two-thirds of the homes now sold are purchased as investment properties. Nathan Eagle/Civil Beat

To keep things simple, let’s say Maui increased the tax on investment homes worth more than $800,000 to 1%, or $1 per $100 of assessed value, and the tax on short-term rentals to 1.44%, or the same rate as timeshare homes.

This change would generate an extra $15.4 million annually from investment homes on Maui and an extra $41.8 million annually from short-term rentals on the island. In total, it would generate approximately $57 million a year that could go towards affordable housing on Maui.

By itself $57 million a year would only support a few hundred additional affordable homes a year. However, this annual stream of revenue could be used to support bonds worth over $1 billion dollars.

Essentially, Maui County could borrow $1 billion today and pay it off over the next 20 to 30 years using the extra property tax revenue. Indeed, this is exactly what Portland, San Francisco and Los Angeles all did to fast track affordable housing.

And given current conditions, all of this money would be borrowed at historically low interest rates, meaning it is cheaper than ever to borrow money for public investments that will make a difference for decades to come.

Costs Vs. Benefits

How much housing would the Maui plan create? Of course it depends on many factors, but estimates suggest it would create 5,000 homes that meet the needs of Maui residents.

At a cost of about $200,000 of public investment per home, if that home stays affordable for 60 years (the current standard for new affordable rentals) and needs an extra $100,000 of repair and maintenance along the way, then it is an investment of $5,000 per household per year to ensure stable and affordable housing.

Research has shown that a stable home is connected to improved health and well-being in ways ranging from fewer doctors’ visits to lower rates of domestic violence and better outcomes in school for children.

South Maui’s Hale O Piikea (Phase I) — an example of affordable housing proposed under the new county plan — would consist of two four-story buildings housing 90 living units, for Maui residents earning 60% or below of the county’s average median income. Courtesy Maui County Comprehensive Affordable Housing Plan

This news is no surprise to those of us who have ever struggled to afford housing or who have friends and family that have lost hope or been demoralized by the cost of housing.

Another advantage to this plan is that unlike federally funded housing, which by law cannot take duration of residency into account when deciding who is eligible for housing, a county-funded program is within its rights to provide preference based on length of residency in an area.

This distinction is significant in an archipelago that has lost many of its long-term residents to economic stress and is another reason counties should embrace their kuleana to create their own robust affordable housing programs.

What are the downsides of an increased property tax on investment homes? Obviously, for the owner of the investment property, it has a cost. For a person who owns a $2 million second home on Maui, it would mean an extra $300 a month.

No doubt that $3,600 a year is a substantial amount of money. However, this is a tax being paid on an investment property that is certainly not an essential item and definitely not connected to all of the health and well-being outcomes associated with having a primary home.

For the typical owner of this investment property, the extra $3,600 a year would likely be a small portion of their income and assets. Assuming their first home is worth at least as much as their second home, they would be earning at least $750,000 a year to afford both mortgages under normal lending standards.

A extra tax of $3,600 would be less than half of 1% of their income. Of course, we don’t know their income — they may have purchased the home with cash and have a lower income but high value assets.

Either way, paying a property tax rate that is still below the national average is unlikely to create the same level of stress as that experienced by someone paying 50% of their wages on rent.

And the funds are actually an investment in the people and county of Maui. Residents of Maui created a safe, beautiful and attractive place where roads, utilities, fire departments and countless other public investments enabled housing to be built in the first place. It makes sense to contribute to the well-being of the community that made the investment possible.


Read this next:

It's Time For The DOE To Take The Lead On Food And Education


Not a subscription

Civil Beat is a small nonprofit newsroom, and we’re committed to a paywall-free website and subscription-free content because we believe in journalism as a public service. That’s why donations from readers like you are essential to our continued existence.

Help keep our journalism free for all readers by becoming a monthly member of Civil Beat today.

Contribute

About the Author

Kenna StormoGipson

Kenna StormoGipson is the director of housing policy for the Hawaii Budget and Policy Center.


Latest Comments (0)

You can build affordable housing (especially modular as in single-wide trailers) but mandating it is a central planners pipe dream that never works out.

pablocruize · 2 weeks ago

Why is it that so many people that admit that they make the minimum wage are mad that they cannot buy an average, $960,000 home in Hawaii?  Home ownership means working hard and sacrificing for it.  It is not just given to you.  The minimum wage in all 50 states does not buy you a home.  Teenagers make minimum wage in their first jobs.  They can't buy a house either.  So what do these people expect?  Minimum wage doesn't buy you a Mercedes either.  Are some people spoiled in here?

REGuru · 2 weeks ago

Hard to believe the author seemed to miss many key points:1. Hawaii property taxes are low because they don’t fund schools unlike nearly every community on the mainland. As a result income taxes are very high2. Is the author proposing taxing only absentee owners whose property remains vacant or also investment properties. If the later rental prices will just go up. 3. Factors really responsible for driving high cost of housing: 1) regulations 2) opposition to new developments 3) unionized labor 4) inflation in general due to loose money supply.  Blaming high housing costs entirely on second home ownership is ridiculous. If that was true costs wouldn’t have rose in places like Kalihi, Kapahulu and Kalama ValleyFolks demand for second home in resort and affluent areas contributes to the economy. It provides tens of thousands of maintenance jobs. These people pay property tax and do not use city servucesIf you want affordable housing follow the model used in HK and Singapore. Incentivize developers to build dense high rises on government land with 99 year leases. Keep the government out as much as possible and stop taxing people so much

deelirious · 2 weeks ago

Join the conversation

About IDEAS

IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on every aspect of life and public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.

Mahalo!

You're officially signed up for our daily newsletter, the Morning Beat. A confirmation email will arrive shortly.

In the meantime, we have other newsletters that you might enjoy. Check the boxes for emails you'd like to receive.

  • What's this? Be the first to hear about important news stories with these occasional emails.
  • What's this? You'll hear from us whenever Civil Beat publishes a major project or investigation.
  • What's this? Get our latest environmental news on a monthly basis, including updates on Nathan Eagle's 'Hawaii 2040' series.
  • What's this? Get occasional emails highlighting essays, analysis and opinion from IDEAS, Civil Beat's commentary section.

Inbox overcrowded? Don't worry, you can unsubscribe
or update your preferences at any time.