Denby Fawcett: Hostile Design Won't Stop Homelessness. It Just Makes Us All Uncomfortable - Honolulu Civil Beat


About the Author

Denby Fawcett

Denby Fawcett is a longtime Hawaii television and newspaper journalist, who grew up in Honolulu. Her book, Secrets of Diamond Head: A History and Trail Guide is available on Amazon. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.

Hostile architecture, sometimes called defensive urban design or exclusionary design, is the name for uncomfortable elements built into public features such as park benches or added to building door fronts to prevent homeless sleepers from commandeering the spaces.

Opinion article badge

This type of hostile design is increasingly showing up on Oahu at bus stops, in Chinatown doorways and in city parks where homeless people tend to congregate.

Uncomfortable, off-putting features are incorporated into private and public structures more and more to discourage other behaviors such as urinating in public, skateboarding and graffiti.

Recently many of the regular park benches along the Ala Wai Canal were replaced with uncomfortable green metal seats capable of holding only two people, tightly packed side by side. Not exactly welcoming places for older pedestrians to rest. And definitely impossible for homeless campers to turn into beds.

The metal seats ignited a firestorm of criticism on the social media site NextDoor, with contributors criticizing the city for being heartless and inhumane to vulnerable homeless people who have nowhere else to sleep. Others complained that the effort to keep homeless people away unfairly adds inconveniences for everybody else.

“I walk along the canal every day. It frustrates me that the city did not consider how uncomfortable the new seats would for the elderly, those with disabilities, and even families with small children,” said Amy Parsons, an Ala Wai Boulevard apartment dweller.

Waikiki resident John Eckels wrote to me in an email Sunday that installing the uncomfortable new seats ignores the deeper problem of homelessness.

“Until the real issue is addressed, nothing gets fixed. Taking away benches from the general public who enjoy sitting along the Ala Wai Canal is most certainly not the answer, but the easy button to quickly address an issue that homelessness has caused,” he said.

Chinatown Homelessness Homeless hostile architecture barriers
Some properties in Chinatown have installed barriers to prevent homeless people from camping out on their doorsteps. Denby Fawcett/Civil Beat/2022

Others thought the new seats along the Ala Wai might serve their intended purpose.

“The new seats are OK. They prevent people from sleeping yet at the same time they are big enough for someone out on a walk to sit down and enjoy a cup of coffee,” said Robert Boyd.

Boyd was fishing for Samoan crabs along the Ala Wai when I spoke with him on Sunday.

Just a few blocks down from where Boyd was crabbing I saw a homeless man who already had found a way to transform one of the small green seats into his own residence. He packed belongings into the perforated metal seat made for two people, standing beside it to guard his bicycle, hiking boots, bedding and other possessions.

In 2014, the city began putting dividers on the benches at some of Oahu’s nearly 4,000 bus stops to keep homeless sleepers from stretching out on them.

But many homeless people then began to sleep instead on the ground around the benches.

The city also replaced benches at some bus stops with concrete stools that can accommodate only a single person.

Oahu Transit Services general manager Roger Morton in an interview described such anti-homeless features at bus stops as “lie-down-unfriendly-furniture.”

The problem is the backless, hard concrete “furniture” is unfriendly not only to homeless sleepers but also to non-homeless bus riders, including some older people with health problems.

Hostile architecture also can be created by entirely taking away places to sit like Mayor Jeremy Harris did in 2002 when his administration removed all the public benches on the Fort Street Mall.

The goal was to get rid of homeless people and drug dealers who were starting to dominate the downtown shopping area.

Old-fashioned park bench homelessness Ala Wai Canal
There are still some regular benches on the Ala Wai Canal. Denby Fawcett/Civil Beat/2022

Chinatown community advocate Lynne Matusow, then the president of the Downtown Neighborhood Board, criticized the action in a 2004 interview: “We are not going to get rid of the homeless people. You just get rid of all the amenities for all the law-abiding people.”

Matusow said Sunday in a phone conservation that 18 years later, homeless people and criminals are still frightening pedestrians in the area.

“The bench removal actions were aimed at druggies, drunks and the homeless people, but they found other places to sleep nearby and law-abiding citizens still are left with no benches to sit on to eat their lunches, relax, talk and enjoy themselves,” she said.

The city also removed benches and tables in the Waikiki beach pavilions fronting Kuhio Beach to curtail homeless people who started turning the pavilions into their oceanfront bedrooms.

Some of the pavilions have since been rented out to commercial businesses and only one is open to the public just for sitting, but it has no tables and only a few benches.

Hostile architecture has been around for a long time. According to an entry in Wikipedia, anti-urination devices were incorporated into the walls in cities in 19th century England.

In Honolulu’s Chinatown, exclusionary design is evident in the fenced off doorways designed to deter homeless people from using the private doorsteps as urinals or sleeping areas.

Chinatown homeless homelessness barriers hostile architecture
Homeless people sometimes sleep on the sidewalk despite barriers and spikes installed at building entries. Denby Fawcett/Civil Beat/2022

Also, in Chinatown I saw a doorstep with cones placed on it hoping to prevent anyone from seeing it as a resting place.

British artist Stuart Semple created a website to launch an international movement hoping to end what he calls such “designs against humanity.”

The website says its goal is to raise awareness about hostile design, get people to openly decry it and encourage urban planners to create more rather than less welcoming public space for everyone.

Public benches and tables now removed need to be reinstalled for the public to enjoy once again.

The answer to homelessness is more complicated than removing potential sleeping places — the answer is doing a better job of addressing the reasons people are unsheltered in the first place and enforcing laws and ordinances that make it unlawful for them to turn public property into their bedrooms.


Read this next:

Chad Blair: The Hawaii Legislature’s New And (Mostly) Improved Website


Not a subscription

Civil Beat is a small nonprofit newsroom, and we’re committed to a paywall-free website and subscription-free content because we believe in journalism as a public service. That’s why donations from readers like you are essential to our continued existence.

Help keep our journalism free for all readers by becoming a monthly member of Civil Beat today.

Contribute

About the Author

Denby Fawcett

Denby Fawcett is a longtime Hawaii television and newspaper journalist, who grew up in Honolulu. Her book, Secrets of Diamond Head: A History and Trail Guide is available on Amazon. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.


Latest Comments (0)

This is what the public gets when there's no enforcement of laws on loitering, sleeping in parks, or public facilities. Homeless know there is little to no bite, or consequence to breaking laws. Even sweeps are in effective because they return in hours without consequence. Our chronic homeless who refuse help and housing are extremely resourceful and knowledgable at getting away with what they do, it's a shame they won't use that resourcefulness to better their lives and doing something for society and themselves. Current strategies will continue to fail because there is no enforcement and consequence to flouting laws.

wailani1961 · 1 month ago

Homeless people and the inclusion of "drug dealers" and " drug users" in that reference as written here is purely discriminatory. They are not necessarily conjoined as a group. The latter being a consequence of failed drug policy popularly supported by the public. The drug war has been around since the 80s, it's old but has become so ingrained it now supports several industries. Our war on drugs made those people who they are. The responsibility is in part ours .Altho it's comfortable isn't it, to sit in our homes judging the lives of people whose lives we know nothing of, other than that they are dirty and criminal and unfit to look at. Maybe we should hide them but it's easier and more cruel to remove the spots they can sleep. Sleep being a basic human need but not a human right.One day the city tells you you can't sleep, there's no place for you to sleep. How long before that park bench starts looking good or that sidewalk? How long?Where does the problem start? It starts when we, set and having what we can less and less afford, start de-humanizing others and making that ok.

youknowyouknow · 1 month ago

It is time for the city to test these metal seats on their employees and visitors, from the mayor on down. I suggest that every chair in Honolulu Hale and the Municpal Building be replaced, starting with those that are appurtenant to desks, with these seats. First stop, mayor's and councilmembers offices plus council chambers and committee meeting room. Bet the on site audience and testifiers will go for remote. If nothing else, they might get the Department of Planning and Permitting staff to get off their okole and do the work they are paid for.

lynnematusow · 1 month ago

Join the conversation

About IDEAS

IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on every aspect of life and public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.

Mahalo!

You're officially signed up for our daily newsletter, the Morning Beat. A confirmation email will arrive shortly.

In the meantime, we have other newsletters that you might enjoy. Check the boxes for emails you'd like to receive.

  • What's this? Be the first to hear about important news stories with these occasional emails.
  • What's this? You'll hear from us whenever Civil Beat publishes a major project or investigation.
  • What's this? Get our latest environmental news on a monthly basis, including updates on Nathan Eagle's 'Hawaii 2040' series.
  • What's this? Get occasional emails highlighting essays, analysis and opinion from IDEAS, Civil Beat's commentary section.

Inbox overcrowded? Don't worry, you can unsubscribe
or update your preferences at any time.