Beth Fukumoto: I've Seen How Ranked Choice Voting Can Help Overcome Political Tribalism - Honolulu Civil Beat


About the Author

Beth Fukumoto

Beth Fukumoto served three terms in the Hawaii House of Representatives. She was the youngest woman in the U.S. to lead a major party in a legislature, the first elected Republican to switch parties after Donald Trump’s election, and a Democratic congressional candidate. Currently, she works as a political commentator and teaches leadership and ethics at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views. You can reach her by email at bfukumoto@civilbeat.org.

When voters see alternative parties or candidates as viable options, many of them will choose change.

Throughout Belfast, security gates separating unionist and nationalist communities loom nearly 25 years after the Good Friday Agreement, a deal which marked the end to a period of political violence known as the Troubles. Many of the gates still close at night and some rarely open at all. Their presence reminds passersby that despite a significant reduction in violence, conflict persists.

On April 18, 2019, that conflict spilled into our global consciousness with the fatal shooting of 29-year-old journalist Lyra McKee by a paramilitary group known as the New IRA. This murder of a ceasefire baby, a member of the promising generation who came of age after the Troubles, is a tragic reminder that progress is fragile. In itself, that’s a lesson for Hawaii and our country.

But, there are more lessons for us here — just stick with me.

Lyra McKee
Lyra McKee, a journalist from Northern Ireland, murdered in 2019. (Screenshot/Wikimedia Commons)

My trip to Belfast took place in the shadow of Lyra’s death when the country’s grief was palpable. Seeking to understand, I took a black cab tour through once-warring neighborhoods, saw their differences expressed on wall murals, and signed a peace wall that still divides their communities. But I knew there must be more.

After falling down a Google rabbit hole, I found the best essay on voting I’ve ever read. Claire Mitchell’s “Can Northern Ireland Change?” records her country’s despair yet offers a way forward. She writes, “(Northern Ireland’s potential) will only be realized if we do something different. And keep doing it, over and over. Hope has to be deliberately chosen.”

For Mitchell, that choice starts with a vote.

“Listen to the children of the ceasefire,” she pleads, arguing that Lyra’s generation is focused more on whether they will have homes, jobs and a livable planet than they are on a united Ireland. “I don’t care if you vote for the big parties or small,” Mitchell concludes. “Vote in a way that you can look these kids in the eye – whether they are Irish or British or both or gay or straight or brown or white – and know that you have voted for someone with a vision of a better future than this.”

Inspired by her call to action, I asked a newfound friend to connect me to a party focused on Belfast’s shared future. Hours later, I skipped out on my conference to go canvassing with Green Party candidate Brian Smyth.

With his City Council election less than 48 hours away, Brian had the familiar glow of a candidate on the rise, feeling ecstatic, exhausted, and ready to burst into laughter, tears, or both simultaneously. Clare Bailey, then-chair of the Green Party and a member of Northern Ireland’s Legislative Assembly, took me under her wing, commiserating with me over vitriolic partisanship, double standards for women and leadership fatigue. I found a kindred spirit on the other side of the world.

Peace Wall Gates, Belfast, 2019. (Ajay Suresh/Wikimedia Commons)

And, finally, this brings me to my point. Northern Ireland is one of the most polarized places in the world, but politicians like Clare and Brian are forging a way through. New parties that aren’t burdened with the politics of the past are finding their place in the arena, and Northern Ireland will benefit from that diversity.

We would too.

Let me state at the outset that I’m not starting a third party. I’m happy where I am. However, I do believe that competition breeds progress. Any party without viable opponents is vulnerable to powerful influencers that predetermine outcomes.

In our current system, fledgling parties that could increase voters’ options don’t have a chance. One solution that would improve those odds is facing a key deadline in the Senate Judiciary committee next week. Senate Bill 401 would authorize ranked choice voting in all partisan primaries, special elections, and nonpartisan general elections.

Last year, the Legislature established RCV in special elections held for federal and vacant county council seats. This bill seeks to expand that innovation and, if amended to include partisan general elections, it would be a gamechanger.

How does Ranked Choice Voting work? (Campaign Legal Center)

Ranked choice voting allows voters to rank candidates in order of preference. If their first choice doesn’t get enough votes to win, their vote automatically goes to their next choice.

According to reform advocates FairVote, RCV “frees voters from worrying about how others will vote and which candidates are more or less likely to win” and allows candidates to “compete without fear of ‘splitting the vote’ with like-minded individuals.” Voters are more willing to take a chance on new candidates or parties because they know their vote won’t be wasted if the newcomers don’t garner enough support.

Northern Ireland’s elections use proportional ranked choice voting, a form of RCV. In 2022, FairVote found that PRCV “helped to bridge sectarian differences between nationalist and unionist parties” in Northern Ireland and “could help solve the polarization and governance challenges facing the United States.”

Walking with Clare in East Belfast, I saw how it works.

In many ways, the experience was just like canvassing in my Mililani house district. Some residents were out, and some hid when we knocked. The rustling of curtains at the window gave them away. However, most voters were willing to listen.

“I like her, but she can’t win” could be the epitaph for my political career. I’ve spent a lot of time at voters’ doors begging them to give me a chance. Claire had to do the same, but her pitch was a more logical proposition – choose us first, and if we fail, your vote goes to your second choice. Taking a chance on something new isn’t much of a gamble in an RCV system. You vote for what you want not what you think you can get.

Brian Smyth won that election. The Green Party and the Alliance Party, which is Northern Ireland’s largest “cross-community” party, saw monumental gains. Following the election, Alliance Party Leader Naomi Long reportedly said it was “a breakthrough election … with many voters choosing to reject the ‘tribal politics’ of unionism and nationalism.”

When voters see alternative parties or candidates as viable options, many of them will choose change.

In Hawaii, ranked choice voting might simply add a wider range of candidates in the Democratic primary or additional left-leaning parties on the general election ballot. Either way, it will open the field to new ideas and visions for progress. And, while I know systems don’t change overnight, the Legislature can move us forward now.


Read this next:

Hawaii Companies May Be Required To Disclose Pay In Job Ads


Local reporting when you need it most

Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.

Honolulu Civil Beat is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.

Contribute

About the Author

Beth Fukumoto

Beth Fukumoto served three terms in the Hawaii House of Representatives. She was the youngest woman in the U.S. to lead a major party in a legislature, the first elected Republican to switch parties after Donald Trump’s election, and a Democratic congressional candidate. Currently, she works as a political commentator and teaches leadership and ethics at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views. You can reach her by email at bfukumoto@civilbeat.org.


Latest Comments (0)

As a reminder, much of Europe including the Northern Ireland example used here, has a parliamentary system of government. In Northern Ireland it's called the Northern Ireland Assembly. Members of the Legislative Assembly "are elected under the single transferable vote form of proportional representation." The US (and with it Hawaii) does not have a parliamentary system and therefore the example used in the article is irrelevant.

Downhill_From_Here · 7 months ago

Mahalo Beth Fukumoto! I agree that Hawaiʻi needs a new election process such as the RCV, to give us the ability to vote for the underdog candidates we believe understands the history of this place, values its cultural roots (pre-contact through pre-overthrow) and will use this ʻike to malama this Pae 'Āina and its Poʻe (kānaka, kamaʻāina, and settler aloha ʻāina (Goodyear-Kaʻōpua, Noelani). I can only hope an RCV election system will allow us voters to delegitimize the wealthy oligarchs' power over our government. Again, mahalo for educating your readers through real experience vice another "arm-chair wanna-be scholar" opinionates. You give me a glimmer of hope.

No.ono.o · 7 months ago

Perhaps, a conservative candidate can run as a Democrat or represent a left-leaning party and win in Hawaii via a Ranked Choice Voting system.

elrod · 7 months ago

Join the conversation

About IDEAS

IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on every aspect of life and public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.

Mahalo!

You're officially signed up for our daily newsletter, the Morning Beat. A confirmation email will arrive shortly.

In the meantime, we have other newsletters that you might enjoy. Check the boxes for emails you'd like to receive.

  • What's this? Be the first to hear about important news stories with these occasional emails.
  • What's this? You'll hear from us whenever Civil Beat publishes a major project or investigation.
  • What's this? Get our latest environmental news on a monthly basis, including updates on Nathan Eagle's 'Hawaii 2040' series.
  • What's this? Get occasional emails highlighting essays, analysis and opinion from IDEAS, Civil Beat's commentary section.

Inbox overcrowded? Don't worry, you can unsubscribe
or update your preferences at any time.