We’re more than half way to our campaign goal of $100,000! Give now and your donation will be DOUBLED thanks to the George Mason Fund of the Hawaiʻi Community Foundation.

Mahalo your continued support!

Double my donation

We’re more than half way to our campaign goal of $100,000! Give now and your donation will be DOUBLED thanks to the George Mason Fund of the Hawaiʻi Community Foundation.

Mahalo your continued support!

Double my donation

Historic Lahaina Photos - Ingalls Collection/Lahaina Restoration Foundation

About the Author

Kirstin Downey

Kirstin Downey, a former Civil Beat reporter, is a regular contributing columnist specializing in history, culture and the arts, and the occasional political issue. A former Washington Post reporter and author of several books, she splits her time between Hawaiʻi and Washington, D.C. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views.


The digitized records will provide a window into Lahaina’s past at a time the town’s future remains in question.

Paradise has a price: Hurricanes, tsunamis, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, floods and wildfires are not only risks to our lives but also to the cherished objects we own.

This truth swept the islands with all its finality in Lahaina one year ago.

These threats underscore the value of taking steps to preserve important things. One good piece of news recently emerged when it was reported that, remarkably, about a 10th of the documents held by the Lahaina Restoration Foundation, a historic preservation group, had survived the fire, electronically at least.

Thanks to fortunate happenstance, and through the combined efforts of the Lahaina Restoration Foundation, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and the Hawaii Tourism Authority, thousands of documents that had been housed at the foundation’s office have been scanned, digitized and are now being made available to the public.

The need to preserve precious things is high on my own mind now. My vivacious and outgoing mother, Melinda Hoppe Young, died recently. A mother of four and grandmother of eight, she had become a complete invalid. She finally slipped away on May 25 after three years of wonderful care at Leahi Hospital. That left me, her only family member still living in Hawaii, in charge of handling the possessions she left behind. After years of bad health, Mother didn’t leave much, except for some old family papers and a jumbled collection of photographs.

The Lahaina Restoration Foundation’s collection of documents and antique objects, on the other hand, numbered in the tens of thousands on Aug. 7, 2023, the day before the fire torched almost all of it. Nearly 90% of its collection was destroyed in the blaze.

But early this month, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs announced that a substantial part of Lahaina Restoration Foundation’s remaining records are being posted and made available to the public on its Papakilo database website, an increasingly comprehensive central repository of documents related to Hawaii. This will include 298 historic pictures of Lahaina from 1900 to 1992, correspondence to and from Maui’s influential Baldwin family and housing records of Lahaina’s Pioneer Mill, which employed thousands of immigrant workers over its 130 years of existence.

Papakilo will be providing a window into Lahaina’s past at a time the town’s future remains in question.

Black and white photograph of exterior of the Pioneer Mill Co. plantation hospital. Nine people can be seen on the lanai and one sitting on the steps of the building. One man is on crutches. One man is inside the door of the building. Two palm trees stand in front of the building.
The Pioneer Mill Co. Hospital, shown here in 1908, is part of the digitized collection. (Historic Lahaina Photos – Ingalls Collection/Lahaina Restoration Foundation)

Lahaina Restoration Foundation was founded in 1962 as Maui’s sugarcane industry succumbed to foreign imports, and civic leaders began to look to tourism for economic survival. Community residents rallied to defend and preserve Lahaina’s historic core from what they feared would be an onslaught of new development. Capitalizing on the burgeoning historic preservation movement nationwide, they succeeded in preserving many of Lahaina’s iconic buildings, transforming the town into a favorite tourist destination for millions of people.

Over the years, the daily pressures of greeting hordes of tourists and visitors while managing 14 historic sites and six museums in Lahaina left the Restoration Foundation’s leaders with very little time for organizing and cataloging the mountain of historic relics and archival materials that had passed into their hands.

In February 2020, Kale Hannahs, Papakilo’s database systems administrator and the driving force behind the expansion of the information clearinghouse, contacted the foundation and asked officials there to begin contributing their information electronically on the Papakilo site so more people could access the unique documents directly. Hannahs had reached out to the foundation as part of a statewide campaign he was spearheading to gather information held in dispersed and far-flung archival locations on different islands.

For more than 16 years, Hannahs has been building and expanding the Papakilo site, which started as a one-stop shop to share things like environmental assessment reports and has grown to include documents from 19 participating organizations. It is probably most famous for housing an ever-expanding Hawaiian language newspaper collection that is believed to be one of the largest collections of Indigenous newspapers in the United States.

Gathering this information is “not just a passion, but also a kuleana,” Hannahs said recently.

Theo Morrison and Kimberly Flook, the Lahaina Restoration Foundation’s directors, were immediately interested in getting involved but were intimidated by how much would need to be done with their limited staff. They weren’t even exactly sure how to go about the task of digitizing so much information.

“We didn’t have the equipment in the early days or the money wasn’t available,” Morrison recalled.

Black and white image of Lahaina Front Street at the seawall. Buildings can be seen along the left and in the background of the image.
Front Street in Lahaina is seen in this black and white image. (Historic Lahaina Photos; McConkey Collection/Lahaina Restoration Foundation)

They had had one important early foray on this front in producing what is called the Windley collection, named for one of the group’s earliest and most passionate supporters. In the 1960s, Larry Windley, a charismatic daredevil in Lahaina who had suffered a spinal cord injury while diving and had become disabled, had turned his energies into traveling the state to gather historic information about Maui’s history, creating an extensive chronological record of events on the island.

In 1969, Windley was lost at sea on a sailboat. Barbara Sharp, a foundation volunteer, was inspired to begin laboriously typing Windley’s notes into a computer database. It took four years. It was a monumental project for its day. In 1997, the foundation began making the information available to researchers who were studying Maui history, according to news reports.

But moving those efforts into the modern era, in the context of the entire collection, was a daunting prospect. They would need to learn how to scan documents, organize them electronically and make them digitally searchable.

The next month, soon after Hannahs’ visit, Covid struck. The pandemic induced a government shutdown. Museum visitors and their tourist dollars disappeared.

That created a crisis for the foundation, which faced the prospect of laying off its staff. But government funding came through in the form of the Payroll Protection Program, which allowed it to keep some staff.

Morrison and Flook used the opportunity to modernize their archival methods. Staff members who normally guided tours instead studied up on best practices in maintaining archival collections. They began pulling boxes out of closets, attics and basements, cataloging what they found and scanning the documents.

“It was the silver lining of Covid,” Flook said.

The letter is in good condition with some minor damage at the top and bottom. This is one letter of over 100 letters to, from, and between the Baldwin family. The Baldwin family was a missionary family, who lived in the Hawaiian islands, particularly Hawaii, Maui and Oahu. Physical copies were destroyed in August 2023 Lahaina wildfire disaster; There is no return or recipient's address.
The Baldwin family letters, part of the digitized collection, cover over 50 years of correspondence, focusing on life in the Hawaiian islands and in the United States.(Baldwin Family Letters/Lahaina Restoration Foundation)

As it turned out, these precise records proved invaluable to the foundation in documenting the value of its holdings for insurance claims following the fire.

More help appeared as the pandemic wore on. In June 2021, the Hawaii Tourism Authority rolled out its Malama Hawaii campaign, which rewarded tourists for participating in volunteer activities while they were visiting the islands.

The Lahaina Restoration Foundation created a hands-on history program to take advantage of this opportunity. Groups of tourists began showing up at the foundation’s museums four times a week to help with the work. Local residents pitched in, too. In all, more than 300 people assisted with the project, Flook recalled. Some people particularly liked scanning old documents.

By the end of the month, Hannahs expects that about 1,500 photos and documents about Lahaina will be posted on the Papakilo website.

That will allow people from Lahaina, including those who have lost everything and those who loved the memory of Lahaina, to search out and discover things that many people thought had disappeared forever.

OHA Board Chair Carmen “Hulu” Lindsey called the Lahaina project a “timely example of the importance of digitizing historic documents.”

Researching this column has affected me as well. I’ve begun scanning all my mother’s photographs. It’s allowing me to relive the family of my childhood and see how many of our happiest memories happened when people were wearing bathing suits, smiling and playing by the water.

We live with risks but also co-exist with so much natural beauty here in Hawaii. Saving those old pictures is reminding me of that.


Read this next:

Denby Fawcett: I No Like Talk Stink About Tulsi Gabbard


Local reporting when you need it most

Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.

Honolulu Civil Beat is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.

Contribute

About the Author

Kirstin Downey

Kirstin Downey, a former Civil Beat reporter, is a regular contributing columnist specializing in history, culture and the arts, and the occasional political issue. A former Washington Post reporter and author of several books, she splits her time between Hawaiʻi and Washington, D.C. Opinions are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat’s views.


Latest Comments (0)

Having gone through Hurricanes Iwa and Iniki brought home how precious and precarious our history is. I learned that hoarding things in paper is pointless in our environment and that if you share and things happen to your collection, you have those you passed things on to for copies. My dad lost his songbook to the ocean surge in Iwa. It was a treasure of Hawaiian and Hapa Haole songs of the early to mid 20th century. All the songs of the war era are rarely heard anymore. His cousin was able to copy his for my dad and later I discovered my mother, who typed it up in the first place, had a copy of the original including the cover my dad drew. She was able to provide the entire family with song books. In this digital age, it is easy to lose everything up there in the cloud, so the physical materials still have value as the back up of the back up. Please support digitization and respect and support those that maintain the physical collections. It is costly. Don't take for granted our precious's history.

Elepaio · 1 year ago

Recovery from trauma has many dimensions. Hope this contributes to the healing of those who experienced loss due to the Lāhaina wildfire. I find myself sharing the emotions that Gus Walz must have felt as he watched his dad, VP candidate Tim Walt, address the Democratic National Convention...."Thatʻs my son!!!!" Kaleʻs achievements in music are well known, but he has also humbly built the Papakilo Database into one of OHAʻs signature contributions to our community. Right on son! Proud of you.

Kahookele · 1 year ago

Thanks for this update on the status of restoration, Kirstin. Quite a labor of love going on with this project. I recently digitized all of my family photos and sent them to family members on thumb drives. Condolences on the loss of your mom.

Carbonius1 · 1 year ago

Join the conversation

About IDEAS

Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.

Mahalo!

You're officially signed up for our daily newsletter, the Morning Beat. A confirmation email will arrive shortly.

In the meantime, we have other newsletters that you might enjoy. Check the boxes for emails you'd like to receive.

  • What's this? Be the first to hear about important news stories with these occasional emails.
  • What's this? You'll hear from us whenever Civil Beat publishes a major project or investigation.
  • What's this? Get our latest environmental news on a monthly basis, including updates on Nathan Eagle's 'Hawaii 2040' series.
  • What's this? Stay updated with the latest news from Maui.
  • What's this? Weekly coverage of Hawaiʻi Island news and community.

Inbox overcrowded? Don't worry, you can unsubscribe
or update your preferences at any time.