Marina Karides is professor of geography and environment at UH Mānoa. She has spent more than two decades researching and publishing on gender equity, diversity, and inclusion in U.S. higher education.
Under Trump, however, University of Hawaiʻi campuses are being asked to modify DEI content and to remove it from websites and programs.
The University of Hawaiʻi belongs to the population of these islands, not the UH’s Office of General Counsel, Office of Vice President of Research, Board of Regents, or its president.
We elect officials and pay taxes to support them to uphold our democratic values and cultural diversity, sustain Native Hawaiian rights, and commit to equal access to public education. As our higher public education system, UH needs to also abide by this ethos.
Hawaiʻi Attorney General Anne Lopez has joined or leads lawsuits against recent White House executive orders (14151, 14173 and 14222) which seek to limit or disappear diversity, equity, and inclusion websites and programs.
In relation to executive orders targeting “illegal DEI and DEIA policies” the “Multi-State Guidance” issued by the Democratic state attorneys general pursuing the lawsuit recommends not altering any DEI content if and until it is legally required, stating, “President Trump is misleading the American people on purpose of diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility initiatives.”
Yet across UH campuses, we are being misled into capitulation and being asked to modify DEI content and to remove it from website and in the structuring of our programs.
A video presentation by the federal contract law firm Roffman Horvitz provides valuable information in relation to higher education and our current legal environment. It outlines our federal laws, the executive orders, and defines DEI that remains “unambiguously legal” or “presumed unlawful” under the Trump administration.
Why is UH acting out of synch with our AG and state and federal legislators and our federal and state legislatures that broadly oppose Trump’s agenda and its challenges to DEI?
UH is also acting contrary to the positions of national professional organizations such as the American Association of University Professors, the American Association of Colleges and Universities, or the American Association of Community Colleges reminding us that “the underlying statutes and case law that govern campus policies have not changed.”
Our state constitution offers further civil protections from the DEI executive orders, should they be recognized as legal by the U.S. Supreme Court. If House Resolution 205 were introduced and passed as a bill, Hawaiʻi could further substantiate its commitment to DEI through legislation.
Those of us on campus who have been working to restore UH digital content (see our petition and participation in the April 17 National Day of Action for higher education) recognize that when DEI words disappear, ideas and opportunities, follow.
We understand that the diversity across UH in 2025 exists not only because of the state’s demographics, but due to DEI programming and websites that seek to attract under-represented groups.
The increase of Native Hawaiians, Pacific Islanders, or Filipino/a/x students is because those who made their way through UH, worked to create spaces of equity and inclusion for the next generation.
When DEI words disappear, ideas and opportunities, follow.
If we apply Trump’s DEI executive orders when they are being legally challenged, rather than stand with U.S. campuses, even those under direct attack, that are resisting them, then we have preemptively capitulated to the logic that many of us have earned our education and position not based on our merit but as a “DEI hire” harming generations of college graduates long into the future.
Until recently the UH system proudly announced holding the most diverse student population and was expanding DEI efforts that broadened access for students, diversified the pool of applicants, and celebrated gender, ethnic, racial, and Indigenous diversity.
Let’s not hand over to the Trump administration the diversity, equity, and inclusion websites and programs that our predecessors worked so hard to attain.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many
topics of
community interest. It’s kind of
a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or
interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800
words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia
formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org. The opinions and
information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
Marina Karides is professor of geography and environment at UH Mānoa. She has spent more than two decades researching and publishing on gender equity, diversity, and inclusion in U.S. higher education.
DEI is based on preference for gender and ethnicity first, not a meritocracy. We have lost what MLK Jr. said anout color of skin and content of character. Meritocracy must be the guide.
SillyState·
1 year ago
This conversation has steered very far from reality.You contributed to it by ignoring the crux of the article which is UH...not DEI in general.The UH system first and foremost exists to educate students. DEI is a wonderful goal in a perfect world but when limited resources exist priorities must defined.Education is always priority #1 for a university.
momof3·
1 year ago
This conversation has steered very far from reality. How is it possible that Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion are being portrayed as bad things? Those are all good things, and necessary things; necessary for progress, necessary for community. Are republicans and anti-dei voices actually expecting us to believe that prejudice doesn't exist? That there is equity in pay and opportunity, amongst all peoples? It really should be unconscionable to be 'anti-dei'.
Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.