Kala‘e Kong is a student at Saint Louis School and a staff reporter for the school newspaper.
A balanced budget is the only way to maintain fiscal discipline.
Out of the many issues facing the United States, it is easy to be disillusioned with the state of our national affairs. In spite of this general disillusionment, one issue stands out most conspicuously: the national debt.
As of right now, the debt stands at a harrowing $37 trillion. In fact, according to the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, that is equivalent to the economies of China, India, Germany, Japan, and the United Kingdom combined.
Shocking as it is, it raises the necessary question: What is to be done?
This is where the role of Hawaiʻi becomes crucial — the United States must adopt a balanced budget amendment modeled on Hawaiʻi’s fiscal safeguards.
Before one can tackle the issue of the national debt, it must first be understood why it poses a special threat. As explained by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, high levels of government debt can lead to a decline in economic growth and a diminution of fiscal flexibility.
This stems from the upward pressure put on interest rates — borrowing rates — which is induced by heightened levels of government borrowing. In other words, as spending increases along with the debt, the government is forced to borrow money, which crowds out private investment and drives up interest rates. As a result, the cost of business loans and mortgages increase, thereby hindering economic growth.
Now what does Hawaiʻi have to do with this?
The U.S. Capitol Building, where the national debt keeps growing. Hawaiʻi might have a solution. (Cory Lum/Civil Beat/2021)
Notwithstanding our state’s financial vulnerability in the event of a fiscal crisis, the Hawaiʻi State Constitution offers some potential solutions to this predicament.
According to Article VII, Section 5 of the state constitution, “General fund expenditures for any fiscal year shall not exceed the state’s current general fund revenues and unencumbered cash balances, except when the governor publicly declares the public health, safety, or welfare is threatened as provided by law.”
What this means, in effect, is that the state must pass a balanced budget every year. If the state were to have a budget deficit, then it must either increase taxes or enact spending reductions.
It must be emphasized, however, that Hawaiʻi’s fiscal management is by no means perfect. Like any other state, Hawaiʻi runs the risk of running a deficit and constantly faces the omnipresent temptation of overspending. What deserves merit though is the fact that there are explicit restrictions on spending in our state constitution that seek to prevent a fiscal crisis from occurring.
This is exactly what’s missing from the federal government — a deliberate system to maintain fiscal discipline, or at least a semblance of it. In other words, a balanced budget requirement.
Unlike Hawaiʻi, the federal budget poses a much more difficult challenge. Its vast size and many complexities make it hard to reform. What’s particularly challenging is that the majority of the budget lies in entitlement programs — Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid — which are virtually untouchable.
It is these very programs, however, that contribute the most to the national debt. Furthermore, in what is indicative of this colossal problem, the interest on the debt surpassed defense spending at $1.1 trillion in fiscal year 2024, according to the Government Accountability Office. In total, for the same fiscal year, the federal budget cost a whopping $6.8 trillion.
One need not be dismayed at such intimidating numbers. By implementing an approach similar to the one found in the Hawaiʻi State Constitution via a balanced budget amendment, the United States may find its way back to fiscal responsibility.
Although such an endeavor is simple in theory, one would be reasonable to characterize the initiative as nothing more than fanciful. That may be the case, but there is simply no alternative. At some point, the federal government will be forced to confront the national debt and find a way to live within its means.
This is no time for partisan bickering.
So the question isn’t if the endeavor is feasible; rather, it is whether our elected officials will have the political courage to do what needs to be done.
This is no time for partisan bickering. When taken into account, both the Democratic and Republican parties are responsible for the continuous accumulation of the national debt. Not since President Calvin Coolidge has the debt been reduced. This fact ought to alarm all members of Congress and propel them to take joint action to meaningfully address this tremendous problem.
As President Ronald Reagan once quipped, “Balancing the budget is a little like protecting your virtue. You just have to learn to say no.” If only it were that easy.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many
topics of
community interest. It’s kind of
a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or
interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800
words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia
formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org. The opinions and
information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
"the US must adopt a balanced budget amendment modeled on HawaiÊ»iâs fiscal safeguards - the fact that there are explicit restrictions on spending in our state constitution that seek to prevent a fiscal crisis from occurring"Despite Hawaii Article VII and section 5, how exactly did the Hawaii State Gov. rack up the status as being one of the states with the most debt?"Hawaii is the most indebted state, with government debt at $13,681.67 per capita. The total state debt balance of $19.7 billion represents 19.49% of the stateâs GDP" ForbesKalaâe Kong is so right to focus on a Government running on debt that in time becomes a debt trap, with greater expenditures needed to servicing the debt and leaving less money to fund Government services. Unfortunately, Hawaii is hardly a paragon of financial virtue, and the proof is a state with high taxation and a stagnant economy.I would bet that kicking the proverbial can will continue because no politician has the intestinal fortitude to stop the Government from spending money it doesn't have, and borrowing is so easy.
Joseppi·
8 months ago
A federal balanced budget amendment is a terrible idea. States cannot run deficits and thus rely on the federal government to step in during recessions to deficit spend to mitigate the damage from a recession and stimulate the economy back to health.A balanced budget amendment strips the federal government from being able to do this and causes a death spiral as reduction in tax revenues then force spending cuts which then reduces net demand, reducing activity and then tax revenues. Which then forces even more spending cuts. The federal government could attempt to raise taxes but that's generally a failing idea during a recession. Eventually, the federal government will default on the debt as revenues fall below debt servicing. States will eventually follow in default on their debt all while cutting services.While our debt is a huge problem, a balanced budget amendment will make a default and a depression a near certainty. What we need to do is cut spend and raise taxes during boom times. We've raised spending and cut taxes instead.
Nova·
8 months ago
Good write up. National Debt is $37 trillion and growing. Yes Social Security and Medicare are expensive but very necessary. There should be no cut off point for Social Security payroll deductions. For 2024 it was $168,600. For 2025 it is $176,000.
Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.