To kick-off our spring campaign, all donations will be matched up to $10,000 thanks to a generous gift from the Ninneweb Foundation.
Help us raise $100,000 from 250+ donors!
Neal Milner: Want To Be More Politically Engaged? Join A Group
You can be the most passionate, educated activist in the world, but you may still need company to succeed.
By Neal Milner
January 2, 2026 · 7 min read
About the Author
You can be the most passionate, educated activist in the world, but you may still need company to succeed.
Last Sunday Civil Beat published a valuable “Voter’s Guide to the 2026 Legislative Session and Beyond.”
I’m going to supplement that by adding something broader — citizen political engagement and the need to be part of groups to make this engagement possible. Kind of a missing link.
The best and easiest way to be politically engaged is by being part of groups and social networks.
Typically, the big concern is voter turnout, but we also need to be concerned with engagement turnout. That’s where groups come in.
Here are four ways that being involved this way makes it easier to be politically engaged. Don’t think of engagement as an obligation or chore. Think of it as a gift.
Take Encouragement From Others
The mechanics of voting are not complicated. Yet many eligible voters, sometimes close to a majority, don’t vote. Something keeps non-voters from carrying out this simple act.
Shaming non-voters generates lots of emotion, but that’s about all it does. Much anger, little insight.
Instead, see non-voters as disengaged. But the biggest problem is not lack of voter engagement but the lack of citizen engagement that in turn makes people likely to vote. How do you get more citizen engagement? By getting people to be part of groups.
Being around people who talk about the broader world makes a person more aware and engaged.
There is lots of research showing this. For example, knowing that people who you are connected to are voting makes it more likely that you will vote too. If your neighbor votes, you are more likely to vote.

The Power Of Groups
Voting may be the essence of democracy, but voting itself is fragmented and isolating. It involves millions of individuals acting alone in the privacy of their home or voting booth.
The theory is that the sum total of votes has a direct effect on how elected officials act. I’ll summarize the decades of research on whether things work that way: not necessarily. Other forces are involved, passion and access being two important ones.
Politics is much more than a public opinion contest. Groups of all kinds — not just formal but also social networks, move things forward and build coalitions. They have resources and get access that individuals don’t have.
Sure, you can pick up your phone and call your legislator. But many people, even those with strong opinions, are reluctant to do that. Besides, articulate and passionate as you may be, you’re just one person.
The Legislature may be known to some as the “People’s Palace,” but for most people, access seems so formidable.
Lobbyists are professional locksmiths with keys to this palace. The problem is that they are privileged. They can get in and know how to do things once they’re inside.
That’s their job. That’s not you.
The kinds of groups and social networks you are engaged with can balance the scales. There is safety in numbers, from big numbers like labor unions to a group of angry friends and neighbors. This safety gives you a better chance of exercising your passions and overcoming the density and confusion of legislative business as usual.
New Ways Of Politicking
Here is a great example. In the late-1990s our legislators were considering a bill that many Hawaiians thought would reduce Hawaiian gathering rights. So they organized protests at the Capitol, including hundreds of hula dancers, cultural practitioners as well as many others.
The Senate killed the bill.
A solitary person obviously can’t do this alone. It’s hard to disrupt if you are marching around and through the Capitol accomplanied only by a homemade sign.
Disruption, interruption — whatever you want to call it — can be a great tool. It is time honored, legitimate and constitutionally protected.
Protests like this can be a useful tool for giving individuals a chance to combine with others, an outsider’s weapon to overcome the power of insiders: moving your feet, feeling the energy, picking up some of the passion and insights of others around you.

There are very dramatic ways to do this, like the successful protest on the Mauna Kea that stopped the Thirty Meter Telescope. That was true civil disobedience, and it worked.
It succeeded because of a combination of organization, passion and discipline.
Just one kupuna, no matter how cherished, standing alone on the road to the telescope site would have had no impact. Besides, no matter how strong you feel about an issue, going at it alone is scary. Again, safety in numbers.
Protest is your First Amendment right. Unfortunately, that right does not include a place to park near the Capitol. So take a bus, or in the spirit of group engagement, carpool.
It Takes Numbers To Monitor Issues
Passing a law is just a tiny part of the full story. None of that matters unless the law is implemented.
Good luck. In fact, the road to getting a law to work is long and winding, a pathway may never get cleared at all.
Sometimes circumstances change. Sometimes the people who are supposed to make laws work don’t want to, or they don’t have the resources.
It’s incredibly hard for an individual to monitor all this. It’s even hard for investigative reporters to do it.
Sometimes, like with the Department of Education air conditioning misadventure, there is no available information at all, or in the case of Child Protective Services and foster children, the agency may conceal information.
At least networking is a way to keep individuals involved and to be healthy skeptics wanting more information.
Individuals need help on this. You are not going to go down to say, the Legislative Reference Library, talk to the official in charge, or ask a legislator who in fact may not know any more about it than you do.
Groups vary in their ability to watch and monitor, but overall, they can find out things you can’t.
In a less systematic way, so might the people in your social network who pay more attention than you do. Maybe that information is flawed, maybe not. At least networking is a way to keep individuals involved and to be healthy skeptics wanting more information.
Don’t think of my guide as a series of directives, civics teacher-style. Think of it as a way to receive benefits — a way of cushioning the blows of political life.
It’s tempting to think that isolation from politics is splendid isolation. Really, though, it’s impossible isolation.
You might as well bite the bullet. Realize that the link between you and the outside world, including politics, is inescapable.
So take advantage of the knowledge, safety and support of others to get through.
It’s a little work with lots of rewards.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Read this next:
Hawaiʻi's Transparency Problem Isn't Just About Secrecy
By Kenneth Peck · January 4, 2026 · 4 min read
Local reporting when you need it most
Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.
Honolulu Civil Beat is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.
ContributeAbout the Author
Neal Milner is a former political science professor at the University of Hawaiʻi where he taught for 40 years. He is a political analyst for KITV and is a regular contributor to Hawaii Public Radio's "The Conversation." His most recent book is The Gift of Underpants. Opinions are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Civil Beat's views.
Latest Comments (0)
The elephant in the room: municipal government. If you want to join a group for political influence, how about the legislature authorizing people to vote to incorporate as a municipality? We're the only one of 50 states lacking this 'join an organization for political effectiveness' power. Since HI legislators leave us with only 'advisory' and 'protests' and 'lobbying' to influence what happens lawfully, we are pushed into extreme 'against' or extreme 'for' positions to get the signal heard through the noise. And most times, quiet lobbying in the background, or just simple waiting us out, defeats our politically active groups. Or the loudest, most persistent group gets what it wants at the expense of what most people want. Let's have what Prince Kuhio fought for ever since 1902: home rule! No more shibai called 'town meetings' at which the assembled citizens have no vote, may only advise. How about a town council meeting with an annual all-citizens assembly? Political influence without power leads to our current condition: a few active, the rest apathetic. Instead of 'Keep the Country Country,' give 'the country' the vote!
Haleiwa_Dad · 4 months ago
Ah. Be like Mamdani Said. "We will replace the frigidity of rugged individualism with the warmth of collectivism" I would say NOT!
SillyState · 4 months ago
There is more to the idea of just joining a group and making a change through it. There are a beavy of examples of which ad-hoc groups got together at the spur of the moment, jammed up the legislative process to try and get their idea to be the winner of the debate, only for the legislature at the end to agree to, among other things, legalize same sex marriage and do absolutely nothing about the social and professional restrictions that were placed on the people during the COVID lockdowns. In other words, you can join a group advocating for something. Still, to be successful, the participant would need to "read the room" and make sure that what they are advocating for is in the overall benefit, rather than just sitting and making noise, signifying nothing.
Kana_Hawaii · 4 months ago
About IDEAS
Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.
