Turning The Lights Back On Is Tough In Oahu’s Rugged Terrain

Read the entire “Are We Ready?” series here.

Oahu’s sprawling electrical grid — the 3,000 miles of lines that deliver power to local homes, stores, fuel and water pumps — is in better shape than Puerto Rico’s was when Hurricane Maria pummeled that Caribbean island.

Still, the two islands’ grids share a similar, fragile design, in which most power is generated on one end of the island, then sent across rugged terrain to heavily populated cities and towns on the other side.

That disjointed layout helped leave parts of the Caribbean island without power for nearly a year after Maria struck.

“We’re just like Puerto Rico,” said Kyle Datta, a general partner at the Honolulu-based social investment fund Ulupono Initiative. “We’re not designed yet for turning the lights back on gracefully.”

Hawaiian Electric Powerlines Koolau Palolo Valley Preparedness 3.

The Windward side and much of East Oahu rely on power transmitted over the rugged Koolau mountains. If remote towers or lines go down, experts say thousands could be left without power indefinitely.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

If Oahu suffered a direct hit from a hurricane, it’s hard to say how long the island’s communities would be left in the dark. However, it won’t be comparable to the extended outages that plagued Puerto Rico, HECO officials say.

HECO would draw on its mutual-assistance agreements with mainland utilities, which would send their own crews and equipment to help restore power to Oahu. 

Of course, that plan depends on Honolulu Harbor being open to get the equipment on-island. The roadways need to be accessible to move workers around Oahu. The water system must be working to operate the power plants. And the water system needs electricity for its well pumps to operate.

“All of those pieces work in sync with each other,” says Scott Seu, HECO’s vice president for public affairs. “You can plan for certain scenarios. Guaranteed you probably haven’t thought of all the different twists that will be thrown at you.”

Seu points to a more specific weakness in Oahu’s grid beyond its overall design — one that worries him even more. There’s no electricity generated on the Windward side.

Oahu’s Major Power Transmission Lines

The gap leaves the Windward region and parts of East Oahu especially vulnerable to an extended outage after a major storm.

“You can plan for certain scenarios. Guaranteed you probably haven’t thought of all the different twists that will be thrown at you.” — Scott Seu, HECO vice-president. 

Kailua, Kaneohe and Waimanalo residents get their power from transmission lines that climb over some of the steepest ridges of the Koolau mountains. Then, the transmission lines cross back over the Koolaus from the Windward side to deliver power to thousands of East Oahu residents as far west as Kahala.

If any lines or towers fail along that arduous path, it could leave thousands of people without power, indefinitely.

Reshaping Oahu’s Grid

The issue clearly weighed on HECO President Alan Oshima as Hurricane Lane bore down on Oahu.

“On this island, I’m more concerned about the trans-Koolau transmission lines,” he said during an Aug. 24 briefing at a state emergency bunker inside the Diamond Head crater.

It’s “an area that we really need to think about,” Seu added during a subsequent interview.

Kahe Electric HEI Plant1

HECO wants to build “community generation” centers where back-up power is hooked up in advance so residents could get access to electricity and other service. Pictured here is Kahe Electric Plant on the Leeward side, the island’s largest power plant.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

After hurricanes Maria and Harvey devastated Puerto Rico and parts of Texas, HECO reached out to Windward-side neighborhood boards, Castle Medical Center, the Kailua-based Harold K.L. Castle Foundation, emergency responders and other community groups to discuss the problem.

HECO still needs to make sure all the Windward fire and police stations, the wastewater treatment plants, the clinics and other critical facilities have backup power generation.

HECO President Alan Oshima speaks during Hurricane Lane press conference held at the Diamond Head EOC. 2018

During preparation for Hurricane Lane, HECO President Alan Oshima said he was most concerned about the transmission lines crossing the mountains.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Islandwide, the utility wants to help create “community enclaves” — isolated spots that are specially hooked up in advance for backup power generation. In an outage, nearby residents could head to these spots — say, a shopping plaza — for access to electricity, groceries, fuel and ATMs.

For Hawaii, however, such enclaves are still conceptual. “We are not far” along in identifying where those Oahu enclaves would be, Seu said.

In the long term, fixing Oahu’s grid weaknesses will also require big changes to the grid itself.

The grid will always rely on transmission lines. Still, as the state moves toward its 100 percent renewable energy goal, the grid can simultaneously be made more durable, allowing HECO to restore power more quickly, officials say.

Smaller, renewable energy substations, such as the new 50-megawatt biofuel plant at Schofield Barracks, could replace the larger-coal-fired plants clustered in West Oahu.

These emerging smaller plants and microgrids could pop up in different, strategic parts of Oahu. If the grid fails, they could stand up on their own — like independent cells or islands — and send power to the nearby area.

“You have to have places on the grid that have strong enough back-up power to regenerate,” Ulupono’s Datta said.

But reshaping Oahu’s grid will take decades, officials say.

Further, it would require community buy-in on any new sites, because even the smaller renewable plants will leave their footprint on an area.

Communities “want to see clean, renewable generation,” Seu said. “They don’t want to see, to the extent possible, large power plants.”

Keeping The Water Flowing

Electricity also powers the pumps that supply about 145 million gallons of fresh water every day across Oahu, at 79 well stations.

If the island loses its electrical grid, the Board of Water Supply estimates it could supply about 30 percent of that capacity, using seven mobile generators.

The limited water would only be accessible in several places, however. Residents in St. Louis Heights, for example, would have to venture out of the mountains to the Kalihi pump station. Elderly and residents with disabilities could have trouble reaching the designated water areas without help.

St Louis Heights Water tank Preparedness.

In a hurricane, officials say limited water supplies might be accessible only in certain places. For example, St. Louis Heights residents might have to go down to a pump station in Kalihi.

Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Hawaii’s emergency officials recommend households keep a 14-day supply of water, with at least one gallon of water a day per person, in case a hurricane strikes.

“This is the reason why — because we depend entirely on Hawaiian Electric power,” BWS Manager and Chief Engineer Ernie Lau told Civil Beat. “And we know the Hawaiian Electric grid is going to suffer damage, either at the transmission-distribution system or the generation facilities, which are in vulnerable areas along the coastline.”

Oahu’s Major Water Supply Sites

Haleiwa, Waialua and Waianae would be especially isolated, with no BWS generators set to immediately deploy near there. The agency would likely send water tankers to the region, but their capacity is limited.

Currently, the agency’s mobile generators only have fuel to last about a day, but BWS officials say they’re working with the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency on a refueling plan to keep those generators going.

Oahu’s water officials are also counting on parts of the grid to be eventually restored so it can re-deploy their generators to other sites, namely the North Shore.

They aim to buy an eighth generator soon and eventually more after that, but the costs are a challenge. Each of these large generators costs from $200,000 to $300,000. The agency already has its hands full repairing the island’s water pipes, which are nearly a century old.

Thoughts on this or any other story? Write a Letter to the Editor. Send to news@civilbeat.org and put Letter in the subject line. 200 words max. You need to use your name and city and include a contact phone for verification purposes.

You can also comment directly on this story by scrolling down a little further. Comments are subject to approval and we may not publish every one.

About the Author