About the Authors
Travis Idol is president of Hawaii Forest Institute and a professor of tropical forestry and agroforestry at the University of Hawaii at Manoa.
Heather Simmons has been executive director of Hawaii Forest Institute and of the Hawaii Forest Industry Association since 2007.
Paul is an experienced project manager, outreach professional and grant writer who manages the Go Native and Honolulu Zoo Children’s Discovery Forest projects.
Hilary Parkinson has professional experience in restoration, invasive weed ecology and community gardens, and has also published research on various horticultural and ecological topics.
There was a time in Hawaii when nature stretched uninterrupted from mauka to makai. That pristine natural beauty is now largely gone from our densely populated urban areas — a harsh reality that has led some to view urban areas as a lost cause separate from upland forests and other protected natural areas.
The human impact on the forest has been extreme: Up to 95% of Hawaii’s dryland forest has been destroyed, and only 40% of our mesic forest remains.
Yet nature in our urban areas is important. As Hawaii’s official Forest Action Plan states: “Our islands’ ecosystems are more dramatically and intricately connected than those on continents. Because of these tight connections, integrating urban forest issues into landscape and island-wide management efforts is necessary.”
Last year, with help from the Kaulunani Urban and Community Forestry Program of the DLNR Division of Forestry and Wildlife, we at the Hawaii Forest Institute launched the “Go Native: Growing a Native Hawaii Urban Forest” project to promote the growing of native Hawaiian and Polynesian-introduced canoe plants.
The goal of this long-term effort is to create a series of kipuka, or micro-forests, within the urban and suburban core. Once we convince enough homeowners, renters, businesses and landscape architects to use more native Hawaiian and canoe plants in their landscaping, these native gardens can collectively become a human-made surrogate for the natural forests that once existed in abundance, particularly in dryland and mesic areas.
Within a generation, we can create a native Hawaiian urban forest network.
The native Hawaiian urban forest network would offer innumerable benefits to Hawaii’s people and to the land: a refuge for native animals; wildlife corridors for native invertebrates, birds and bats; the preservation of genetic variation within plant and animal species; the enhancement of cultural and spiritual links with the past.
Creating the native Hawaiian urban forest network could also help to increase the redundancy, representation and resilience of existing natural forests. If we build a native Hawaiian urban forest network of sufficient size and density, native birds and insects may even be able to extend their current ranges.
In addition to benefiting wildlife, forests and the environment as a whole, growing native plants also requires less water, fewer fertilizers and pesticides and reduces air pollution. According to Heidi Leianuenue Bornhorst, author of “Growing Native Hawaiian Plants: A How-To Guide for the Gardener,” “many natives, especially those native to coastal and dry forest areas will help reach Hawaii’s goal of reducing wasteful watering practices (xeriphitic or drought-tolerant landscaping).”
Contrary to common perception, there are native Hawaiian plants that are very hardy and can survive in harsh conditions. They may have a role to play as climate change impacts the state.
While we know where we want to go, the road to getting there is not always clear, and there will be bumps along the way. One major challenge we have discovered is the existing landscaping aesthetic. Many homeowners and businesses seem to prefer a well-manicured, highly controlled landscape. They may pay landscape architects to design and install “instant” landscaping that is relatively fixed in time. In contrast, creating a series of native Hawaiian kipuka really involves a degree of re-wilding.
Native Hawaiian gardens, such as the one planted and managed by local landscape architect Rick Quinn near the Shidler College of Business on the University of Hawaii Manoa campus, have evolved over time as the conditions in the garden — such as tree shade and the soil biota — have changed, and some plants have flourished while others have died off.
The homeowner planting a native Hawaiian garden needs to be open to change and to letting ecological succession play out. In this sense, gardening becomes a journey of experimentation and discovery rather than a one-time installation.
At the same time, we have seen examples of flourishing gardens that use native Hawaiian plants, are well-manicured and do not change greatly over time. There is a continuum from highly controlled to wild, and where one lies on the continuum depends to a degree upon personal tastes and plant selection.
To some, the discussion of garden aesthetics may seem esoteric, but it has economic implications. Numerous experts with whom we have spoken have noted that the version of tropical or sub-tropical landscaping presented to tourists is often a generic one. A tourist can travel all over the world and see the same artificial version of “tropical paradise” that uses non-native plants such as monstera.
There is nothing unique or special about this homogenized version of nature. We believe that at a time when Hawaii is searching for a new model of tourism – and tourists are looking for authentic experiences – native Hawaiian and canoe plants have an important role to play.
While native Hawaiian landscaping may not look like a tourist’s imagined picture of tropical paradise, it is authentic and appropriate to this place. Our native flora and fauna can play an important role in marking Hawaii as a truly unique destination.
We are now creating a series of videos and a reference guide. The videos, designed for a lay audience, will walk through the stages of creating or converting a landscape to native and canoe plants.
The guide, which we are tentatively calling the #GoNativeHawaii Growing Guide, will enable gardeners, landscape architects and others to identify the different native plants most suitable to their climate zone, personal tastes, gardening or landscaping experience and other factors. The guide will enable users to look up their growing zone to find recommended combinations of plants that they can grow, that fit the zone and are thus more likely to flourish. It will also recommend plants based on other considerations, such as the type of space and landscape function, and it will provide actual sample garden plans with plant combinations, architectural drawings, etc. — providing detailed schema rather than simply a list of ingredients.
Both will provide clear guidance and take the guesswork out of planning and realizing a native urban landscape.
Diving into the details, we’ve discovered that this project requires making tradeoffs. Should we be strictly faithful to the original natural history of the particular area or include some plants that may only survive with human intervention (for example, through regular watering and fertilizing)?
Should we include plants that are endemic only to one island or only those found on all islands?
Should we focus primarily on a limited palette of native plants that are easy to grow or suggest spectacular native plants that are more difficult to grow?
While our aim is a re-wilding of urban landscapes and the restoration and interconnection of ecosystems, we recognize that many people still prefer landscaping that is well-manicured and controlled. We are trying to appeal to these tastes, while hoping that in the long-term people may become more open to a different garden aesthetic.
Seeing is believing so we have started a sub-project to document sites around the state where people are already growing native Hawaiian plants, sometimes in combination with canoe plants. We are also planning to launch a contest so that homeowners can show off their native Hawaiian landscaping and inspire others.
To submit an essay or if you just want to talk over an idea, contact:
IDEAS Editor Julia Steele
Several experts in the community such as Sam Gon, Jonathan Price, Noa Lincoln, Carl Evensen, and well-known landscape architect Rick Quinn have provided invaluable feedback and advice.
Creating a native Hawaiian urban forest network will take time, but we believe it will be a positive development for Hawaii’s economy, people and aina.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Join the conversation
IDEAS is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on every aspect of life and public affairs in Hawaii. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaii, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email email@example.com to submit an idea.