Chris Marvin is a retired Army officer and combat-wounded veteran of the war in Afghanistan. He lives in Honolulu.
A proposed state Senate bill would — and should — close the assault rifle loophole.
Prepare yourself, because this will shock almost no one: the gun lobby is blatantly lying to Hawaii legislators.
People who make money off the sales of firearms are trying to sell our elected leaders on the idea that hunters in the state need military-style assault weapons to hunt and control the feral pig population. They might be selling, but as a combat veteran, I am not buying, and neither should our lawmakers.
In Hawaii, we have banned assault pistols for decades, a law pre-dating the 1994 federal ban on assault weapons. However, our law stopped short of banning assault rifles.
Perhaps that was because when the law was made, mass shootings were rare. This was before the shooting at Columbine, which was one of the first to garner national headlines. Perhaps it has remained on the books in this way because the last major mass shooting in Hawaii was the infamous Xerox shooting in 1999.
But things are changing.
An AR-15 is a weapon of mass destruction. (Flickr: Mitch Barrie)
Hawaii experienced a mass shooting last year when two people were killed and three more injured at an illegal rooster fight. And this year, so far, the U.S. is averaging more than one mass shooting per day.
The most deadly mass shootings in history have been perpetrated by military-style assault rifles like the Daniel Defense DDM4 (Uvalde), SIG MCX (Orlando), Colt M4 Carbine AR-15 (Las Vegas), Bushmaster XM-15 (Newtown), Ruger AR-556 (Sutherland Springs), and Smith & Wesson M&P15 (Parkland). These weapons of war placed into civilian hands killed 200 people in these six locations alone.
What makes us think that a school, theater, or public gathering in Hawaii can’t be next?
‘Tools Of War’
We do have strong gun laws. The Legislature took action last year to strengthen the rules for concealed carry licenses and designated sensitive places to help keep dangerous people from accessing and carrying guns.
But then again, more than 80% of mass shooters who attacked K-12 schools acquired their guns by stealing them from family members who purchased them legally.
Thus, with more of these tools of war in our islands — even if the purchaser passes a background check and follows most laws — it is much more likely that someone dangerous could access and use an assault weapon to wreak havoc on our community.
A typical AR-15 fires a 5.5-millimeter metal projectile at 1,000 meters per second (three times faster than a pistol). At a gun range, it leaves a small clean hole in the target. In flesh, it does something very different.
As it enters a body, a high rate of spin causes the round to tumble, ricocheting off bones, cavitating organs, and exiting through a gaping hole. This destruction of the innards is meant to kill.
In the military, we are trained to use M4s to kill the enemy. In the civilian world, similar weapons are still the best guns for killing humans. Use this gun on a pig or an axis deer, and it will destroy good, edible meat.
Semi-automatic weapons also have a high cyclic rate, meaning that multiple rounds can be fired in rapid succession. In the Army, I learned to use this technique to suppress the enemy; for example, shooting over and over at a bunker, so that my squad mates could move without being shot at. (It’s like in the movies when they say “cover me.”)
It’s past time to update our laws to cover all assault weapons.
That rate of fire is only required if the thing you are shooting at is shooting back. So, unless the game being hunted learns to use a gun, a hunter doesn’t need a semi-automatic assault rifle. In fact, putting more than one round into an animal risks ruining good meat.
We all know hunters, and we know they prefer to eat what they kill. They also often refer to themselves as sportsmen. If they are using AR-15s, they are no such thing.
And this is where the lies come in.
The NRA and other mainland-based organizations have mobilized a small, vocal group of gun lovers — who may or may not live in Hawaii and who may or may not hunt — to email state legislators and insist that they need semi-automatic military-style assault weapons to kill animals.
I say: false, deceptive, reprehensible.
Why would we put the wellbeing of our children and our community at risk to satisfy the whims of people who simply love guns as a hobby and are willing to go to extreme measures to reduce restrictions?
If you can’t kill a feral pig with a bolt-action in .243 Winchester, 6mm Creedmoor, or the vast majority of hunting rifles that will not be banned, then you should be ashamed to call yourself a hunter, and perhaps look into marksmanship classes.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many
topics of
community interest. It’s kind of
a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or
interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Column lengths should be no more than 800
words and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia
formats. Send to news@civilbeat.org. The opinions and
information expressed in Community Voices are solely those of the authors and not Civil Beat.
What happened in Cuba, Germany, USSR, Cambodia, Venezuela and the list goes on, once they confiscated guns????
Tdouble·
2 years ago
We can argue the need for dangerous weapons in the hands of our population but the fact remains: Hawaii doesnât have mass shootings because we have stricter gun laws then most other states. You like scrap, throw down like a man, shake hands after. Why are we raising our children to be cowards hiding behind guns?
Wisehaole22·
2 years ago
I can't stand undedicated opinions and circumventing stats on either side of the political spectrum. First the "assualt rifle" is a non-sense term along with "weapons of war" The M1 is a weapon of war, shoots a way bigger bullet, and yet there are no cries for its destruction. The ruger mini-14 rarely is brought up probably for the same reason and shoots the 5.56/.223. Maybe because it has wood instead of a black skin tone. Your comments on the bullet are nonsensical at best. The AR-15 bullet is based off .223 Rem which was a hunting cartridge, it is one of the most common hunting round and doesn't ruin the meat. You obviously don't hunt, nor have even been educated on any of this.As for murders the FBI stats expose your issue. 2019 6368 handgun 364 rifles(to include hunting and assault rifles)1476 Knives600 hands feetYou cry about AR's but they do less killing then bare hands. Your argument seems political not factual. Sadly I could go on but there aren't enough characters allowed in a reply. Do better with your research instead of reciting talking points like a conservative.
Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.