David Croxford/Civil Beat/2023

About the Author

The Sunshine Blog

The Sunshine Blog is reported and written by Ideas Editor Patti Epler, Deputy Ideas Editor Richard Wiens and Politics Editor Chad Blair.

Short takes, outtakes, our takes and other stuff you should know about public information, government accountability and ethical leadership in Hawai‘i.

Paid family leave: Earlier this year The Blog reported that Maui Rep. Elle Cochran had a poor attendance record at the Capitol because she was caring for a family member.

Her absence pretty much continued throughout the session, which ended May 2, but Cochran still got paid the $225 per diem enjoyed by neighbor island lawmakers. She for sure missed 51 of the 60 floor session days, which totals up to $11,475 of per diem payments. It’s unknown exactly how many of the other days she missed.

Yup it’s legal. Hawaiʻi Revised Statue 24-2 requires non-Oʻahu representatives to get an allowance for every day from the start of the session to the last day, including weekends and holidays. It’s to be used for boarding, lodging and incidental expenses but not travel expenses

Illustration of Hawaii capitol with sun shining in the sky
Civil Beat opinion writers are closely following efforts to bring more transparency and accountability to state and local government — at the Legislature, the county level and in the media. Help us by sending ideas and anecdotes to sunshine@civilbeat.org.

House Communications Director Cathy Lee told The Blog on Friday, “All non-Oʻahu members receive per diem in accordance with HRS 24-2, regardless of whether they are on Oʻahu on a given day. We have not seen any instances of members returning the per diem.”

The Blog called Cochran on Friday to ask about her absence and whether she might consider returning some of the money to taxpayers. But the representative interrupted quickly to ask, “Don’t you have anything better to investigate?”

Then she hung up.

Cochran’s absence did not go unnoticed by her colleagues this session, who grumbled that she was not able to participate in Lahaina- and Maui wildfire-related legislation.

Rep. Elle Cochran, left, at a hearing in 2023. (David Croxford/Civil Beat/2023)

That crazy Diddy Combs lawsuit: The case of the California woman who filed a lawsuit against Sean “Diddy” Combs and a bunch of other people including our very own Maui Police Chief John Pelletier continues to be a weird yet strangely fun read.

The amended complaint that seemingly out of the blue roped in Pelletier as, allegedly, some sort of enforcer for Combs (no evidence of that and of course a very strong denial from the chief) was filed in March in California federal court and created quite the stir on this side of the Pacific. The 87-page complaint told a lurid tale of gang rape, kidnapping and other X-rated accusations that occurred in 2018 when Pelletier was still on the Las Vegas police department.

To recap: Maui Mayor Richard Bissen insisted Pelletier be placed on leave by the Maui Police Commission, his police powers suspended, while the case was proceeding. Pelletier produced documentation showing that he was in Las Vegas when the alleged incident took place. He’s also said he has never met Combs and has no idea why he was suddenly dragged into this mess. The commission refused to put the chief on leave.

Moreover, two of the plaintiffs were only identified as John and Jane Doe, and the federal judge decreed it wrong for plaintiffs to not identify themselves. She ordered them to show why they should be allowed to remain anonymous or the case would be tossed. The judge gave them until June 7 to file their response; they haven’t done that yet and the case went quiet.

Until Friday, when one of the higher-profile defendants in the case filed a motion for sanctions against the plaintiff, Ashley Parham, and her lawyers who have been involved in a number of the Combs lawsuits.

Referee Druski smiles during the Saturday Night Celebrity Flag game, Saturday, Feb. 8, 2025, ahead of the NFL Super Bowl 59 football game between the Philadelphia Eagles and the Kansas City Chiefs in New Orleans. (Dave Shopland/AP Images for the NFL)
Referee Druski smiles during the Saturday Night Celebrity Flag game earlier this year, ahead of the Super Bowl between the Philadelphia Eagles and the Kansas City Chiefs in New Orleans. (Dave Shopland/AP Images for the NFL)

Drew Desbordes, who some of you may better recognize as the comedian named Druski, contends he, too, had nothing to do with anything alleged in the lawsuit and has over the past few months provided the plaintiff and her attorneys plenty of documentation to show he wasn’t. And yet, they still have not let him off the hook.

Druski says that in 2018 he was living in Georgia with his mom and working as a waiter at an Outback Steakhouse. He was not yet a famous entertainer. Employment records, photos, phone bills and other documents bear this out.

An affidavit filed by Druski’s attorney says it has cost the comedian more than $50,000 in legal bills so far. The sanctions, Druski and his lawyers suggest, should include repaying him his attorney fees.

“This lawsuit is entirely lacking in merit. Its allegations are fantastical,” Druski says. (The Blog, having read the whole thing, agrees. It’s like a bad screenplay.)

“The Court should issue the most severe sanctions possible against Plaintiffs’ counsel,” the motion continues. “There is absolutely no credible explanation for Ariel Mitchell and Sean Perez’s (the two plaintiffs’ attorneys) conduct in this lawsuit. They filed a false lawsuit against Mr. Desbordes, they were advised that their claims were fabricated and were contradicted by irrefutable evidence, and they steadfastly refused to withdraw these false claims. Severe sanctions, including dismissal and the cost of the fees incurred in bringing this motion, must be awarded to deter Plaintiffs and counsels’ misconduct.”

Maui Police Chief John Pelletier embraces his attorney Keola Whittaker during a Maui Police Commission recess Wednesday, March 19, 2025, in Kahului. The Police Commission rejected putting Chief Pelletier on administrative leave because of a civil lawsuit alleging his involvement with rapper Sean “Diddy” Combs. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2025)
Maui Police Chief John Pelletier embraces his attorney Keola Whittaker during a Maui Police Commission recess in March. The police commission rejected a recommendation by the mayor that Pelletier be put on administrative leave while the Combs lawsuit plays out. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2025)

Pelletier, who was not accused of sexual assault, has also provided his evidence to the plaintiffs’ attorneys and also hasn’t been removed from the case.

“From the beginning, we have maintained that the allegations against Chief Pelletier in this civil case are frivolous,” Pelletier’s attorney, Keola Whittaker, said in an email on Saturday. “Based on the evidence filed with the court by Mr. Desbordes, it appears that the allegations against him are also frivolous.

“Chief Pelletier provided a mountain of evidence proving that he was nowhere near the alleged incidents, including documentation placing him hundreds of miles away on the dates in question. Despite this evidence, the lawyers for the plaintiffs have failed to dismiss the Chief from the case. I hope Mr. Desbordes’ filing causes those lawyers to take a closer look at the evidence and to dismiss Chief from the case. If not, we will pursue all legal remedies to vindicate Chief, including seeking sanctions as Mr. Desbordes’ has done, for the harm that has been done to Chief, his family and our community.”

Pelletier tells The Blog the case has been tough on him and his family. “I cannot understand why anyone would so recklessly attack and try to ruin another person,” he said in an email. “I’m deeply grateful for the outpouring of support that my family and I have received from our community.”

You can read Druski’s latest filing here but be forewarned this is XX-rated and lengthy if you read the emails and text messages between Ashley Parham and another defendant that resulted in him obtaining a TRO against her.

Show us the money: Speaking of police chiefs, Hawaii News Now has a good little scoop about convicted former Honolulu Police Chief Louis Kealoha finally getting out of prison. He’s back in town although finishing out his seven-year sentence under home monitoring, HNN investigative reporter Lynn Kawano reports. His official release date is set for May 18, 2026.

The story quotes Honolulu attorney Eric Seitz as saying the Kealohas (that would include Louis’ ex-wife Katherine, a former deputy prosecutor) as still owing her uncle, Gerard Puana, more than $500,000 for trying to frame him as a felonious mailbox thief. Yes, that is the whole SMH situation that took down the chief, his wife and at least five other Honolulu cops in a federal corruption case that has gone down many paths.

Former HPD Chief Louis Kealoha and Katherine Kealoha holding hands leaving District Court after jury deliberated.
Retired HPD Chief Louis Kealoha and Katherine Kealoha, a former city prosecutor, leaving federal court during their trial in 2019. (Cory Lum/Civil Beat/2019)

But The Blog wants to know what’s up with the $250,000 in taxpayer money that the Honolulu Police Commission decided to give the chief as a bonus of retiring rather than firing him. He was supposed to pay that back if he was ever convicted of a felony, which of course he was. The city went to court to try to get it and a judge ruled he had to pay it.

The status of that reimbursement is murky.

Off and running: It’s only May 2025, but interest in the August and November 2026 elections is already underway.

Mel Rapozo, a member of the Kauaʻi County Council, told The Blog on Friday that he’s thinking seriously of running to replace Derek Kawakami, who is expected to run for the state Senate next year after serving eight years as mayor.

“There are rumors that I am not running, but as of today, I am running,” Rapozo said.

Rapozo has run twice for mayor unsuccessfully, but he’s now in his 17th year on the council. The Kauaʻi County Charter allows candidates for both mayor and council to run again as long as they take a break after serving consecutive terms — two four-year terms as mayor or four two-year terms on the council.

The buzz on the Garden Island is that another council member, Bernard Carvalho Jr., will soon announce that he too is running for mayor next year, a post he last held in 2018.

Kauai Council Chair Mel Rapozo listens to those being honored with a proclamation Wednesday, Oct. 9, 2024, in Lihue. Council members Bill DeCosta, middle, and Bernard Carvalho, Jr., look on. (Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)
Kauaʻi County Council Chair Mel Rapozo, left, at an October meeting in Līhuʻe with council members Bill DeCosta, middle, and Bernard Carvalho Jr.(Kevin Fujii/Civil Beat/2024)

Let the donations begin: Now that the 2025 Legislature is pau, state and county officials are free to hold political fundraisers. Two state House members have already made plans: Sam Kong and Jackson Sayama, who will ask for contributions at the Old Spaghetti Factory at Aloha Tower on May 20.

As you may recall, a 2022 law restricted fundraising so that lawmakers could not hold organized fundraisers when the Legislature meets, roughly between mid January and early May. And a 2023 law says registered lobbyists — that is, people who are paid to influence policymaking — can’t donate during session at all to elected officials and candidates, as well as five days before session and five days after.

There is still some confusion about the newish laws, however, which were passed in the wake of two former state lawmakers pleading guilty to accepting bribes in order to influence legislation. The Blog received a tip that Honolulu County Councilman Tyler Dos Santos-Tam may have violated the 2022 law because he sent out an email April 28 inviting folks to attend a May 13 fundraiser at Fête Honolulu.

The Blog checked with Dos Santos-Tam, who said he ran the event by the Campaign Spending Commission.

“I asked about the law to make sure I could invite people to the event, which is clearly after session, and they said it was fine,” he said Friday. “But you should check with the CSC.”

The Blog checked with the CSC, and what the councilman said checks out — but with a little twist.

Associate director Tony Baldomero said that, while it’s OK to send out a fundraiser invite, it would be a violation of the law for a lobbyist to promise to donate — or for an official to accept the donation — during the restricted period.

Legislation from the commission this year to ban state and county elected officials from soliciting and accepting campaign contributions during session passed the state House but was never heard by the Senate.

Screenshot
Senate President Ron Kouchi and House Speaker Nadine Nakamura appeared Tuesday on “Spotlight Now.” (Screenshot/2025)

Grade inflation?: What grade would you give the Hawaiʻi Legislature for its just-completed session? Senate President Ron Kouchi gave it an “I” for “incomplete” because more work will likely be needed during a special session later year this to deal with the fallout from upcoming federal budget cuts.

Kouchi appeared on Hawaiʻi News Now’s “Spotlight Now” on Tuesday with House Speaker Nadine Nakamura, who generously suggested her chamber deserved an “A” for performing so well with 11 new members and six new committee chairs.

The Blog has to wonder, though, if the speaker felt that good about how the session unfolded, why did one of the other key House leaders, Rep. Kyle Yamashita, get forced out of his position as Finance Committee chair the very next day?

Kouchi and Nakamura chatted for 45 minutes with “Spotlight Now” host Yungi de Nies, who surprisingly never brought up the Legislator’s spectacular failure to approve major government reform measures.

After the leaders departed during a commercial break, UH political scientist Colin Moore appeared and took care of that omission.

Moore gave the Legislature a “B-plus” for acting on issues such as the green fee, housing and insurance stabilization, but a “D” for its rejection of government reform bills.


Read this next:

Danny De Gracia: Why Hawaiʻi Leaders Must Press Trump For Trade Exemptions


Local reporting when you need it most

Support timely, accurate, independent journalism.

Honolulu Civil Beat is a nonprofit organization, and your donation helps us produce local reporting that serves all of Hawaii.

Contribute

About the Author

The Sunshine Blog

The Sunshine Blog is reported and written by Ideas Editor Patti Epler, Deputy Ideas Editor Richard Wiens and Politics Editor Chad Blair.


Latest Comments (0)

"There were no complaints from my constituents"None of us knew she was on "family leave" and constantly absent until CB discovered it. She should return the money, period.

MauiLolo · 1 year ago

When I spoke to reporter Blair, he repeated questions that already had been addressed in detail weeks earlier by my office, the Speaker of the House, and others at the Legislature. I responded briefly and then ended the call.My absences had been approved by the Speaker of the House. Leadership, committee chairs, vice-chairs were aware that I would fly in as needed. I did so when requested by colleagues. I did not violate any legislative policies.There were no complaints from my constituents. I prioritized their needs and have been attending to pressing issues like water shortages and scams. I committed to assisting agencies such as DCCA to protect my constituents. These critical issues demand focus since there is a lack of personnel and help.Regarding per diem, Mr. Blair was informed that I did not cash the first three checks because I believed they were issued in error. My office notified the Chief Clerk’s Office and Accounting. We were informed that per diem is issued automatically. I defer to the House responsible for such policies.Regarding saving taxpayer's dollars, why not mention that I have returned $21,000 of $32,000 allotted to my office since I was elected in 2022?

repcochran · 1 year ago

"The Blog called Cochran on Friday to ask about her absence and whether she might consider returning some of the money to taxpayers. But the representative interrupted quickly to ask, "Don’t you have anything better to investigate?" Then she hung up."It's time for Elle Cochran's constituents to "Hang up" on Rep. Cochran!Blowing taxpayer money while doing virtually NOTHING for your constituents, is a BIG DEAL & news worthy. Her apathetic response just totally disrepected her constituents & Hawaii Taxpayers. She's gotta go!!!

KeKanaka · 1 year ago

Join the conversation

About IDEAS

Ideas is the place you'll find essays, analysis and opinion on public affairs in Hawaiʻi. We want to showcase smart ideas about the future of Hawaiʻi, from the state's sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea.

Mahalo!

You're officially signed up for our daily newsletter, the Morning Beat. A confirmation email will arrive shortly.

In the meantime, we have other newsletters that you might enjoy. Check the boxes for emails you'd like to receive.

  • What's this? Be the first to hear about important news stories with these occasional emails.
  • What's this? You'll hear from us whenever Civil Beat publishes a major project or investigation.
  • What's this? Get our latest environmental news on a monthly basis, including updates on Nathan Eagle's 'Hawaii 2040' series.
  • What's this? Stay updated with the latest news from Maui.
  • What's this? Weekly coverage of Hawaiʻi Island news and community.

Inbox overcrowded? Don't worry, you can unsubscribe
or update your preferences at any time.