First lady Michelle Obama is going to visit a farm in Waianae next week.
Between hobnobbing with foreign dignitaries at the APEC summit, she is going to be rubbing elbows with working class locals.
On a visit to MA‘O Farms, the first lady will be promoting her Let’s Move! campaign to reduce childhood obesity.
This is how the White House characterized the visit in a press release:
First Lady Michelle Obama will kick off her trip with a visit to MA’O Organic Farms located in the Waianae area, the largest Native Hawaiian community in the world and one of the most economically challenged communities in the state.1
It’s cool that the first lady is going out of her way to highlight for the world issues facing the Native Hawaiian community and the positive steps being taken at places like MA‘O Farms.
But is the White House’s description of Waianae accurate? Is it the world’s largest Native Hawaiian community? (In a separate Fact Check, we’re evaluating whether it’s among Hawaii’s most economically challenged communities.)
Civil Beat looked at 2010 Census data — in particular, Table QT-P9, titled “Race Reporting for the Native Hawaiian and Other Pacific Islander Population by Selected Categories.” (It should be noted that there’s controversy over whether Census data accurately reflects the Native Hawaiian population.)
We analyzed both the total number and percentage of residents who self-identify as at least part-Native Hawaiian in all of the 151 Census Designated Places (CDPs) in Hawaii.
The Census data shows that the five CDPs found within the greater Waianae area — the towns of Maili, Makaha, Makaha Valley, Nanakuli and Waianae — all have significant Native Hawaiian populations.
The most literal, and accurate, definition of “largest Native Hawaiian community” would be the one with the highest total number of Native Hawaiians. And by that metric, Nanakuli and Waianae each rank in the top six in Hawaii. But neither comes first.
Town | Total population (all races) | Native Hawaiian alone or in any combination | Rank | Percent Native Hawaiian | Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Urban Honolulu | 337,256 | 41,781 | 1 | 12.4% | 128 |
Hilo | 43,263 | 14,694 | 2 | 34.0% | 38 |
Kaneohe | 34,597 | 10,685 | 3 | 30.9% | 47 |
Nanakuli | 12,666 | 9,051 | 4 | 71.5% | 3 |
Kailua (Honolulu County) | 38,635 | 9,028 | 5 | 23.4% | 78 |
Waianae | 13,177 | 8,018 | 6 | 60.8% | 8 |
Pearl City | 47,698 | 7,464 | 7 | 15.6% | 119 |
East Honolulu | 49,914 | 6,117 | 8 | 12.3% | 131 |
Kapolei | 15,186 | 5,673 | 9 | 37.4% | 35 |
Kahului | 26,337 | 5,634 | 10 | 21.4% | 90 |
Mililani Town | 27,629 | 5,400 | 11 | 19.5% | 101 |
Wahiawa | 17,821 | 4,771 | 12 | 26.8% | 62 |
Maili | 9,488 | 4,616 | 13 | 48.7% | 17 |
Makakilo | 18,248 | 4,616 | 13 | 25.3% | 71 |
Wailuku | 15,313 | 4,465 | 15 | 29.2% | 54 |
Makaha | 8,278 | 4,393 | 16 | 53.1% | 12 |
… | … | … | … | … | … |
Makaha Valley | 1,341 | 582 | 88 | 43.4% | 21 |
Source: Civil Beat analysis of U.S. Census data
In fact, the town in Hawaii with the most Native Hawaiians is Honolulu. Of course, Honolulu has far more total residents than Waianae or the other Leeward Coast towns.
But there are mainland cities with even larger populations that one might think could have even more Native Hawaiian residents. So we examined a few of those, including Las Vegas, sometimes called the ninth island. Clark County, Nevada, which contains Las Vegas, is home to 14,071 Native Hawaiians. Even bigger Los Angeles County is home to 13,257 residents who self-identify as at least part-Native Hawaiian.
Las Vegas and Los Angeles don’t beat out Honolulu, but they’re both above Waianae.
Maybe Waianae will fare beter using another measure: percentage of total population?
Town | Total population (all races) | Native Hawaiian alone or in any combination | Rank | Percent Native Hawaiian | Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Waimanalo Beach | 4,481 | 3,644 | 21 | 81.3% | 1 |
Kualapuu | 2,027 | 1,458 | 47 | 71.9% | 2 |
Nanakuli | 12,666 | 9,051 | 4 | 71.5% | 3 |
Ualapu’e | 425 | 300 | 110 | 70.6% | 4 |
Anahola | 2,223 | 1,558 | 44 | 70.1% | 5 |
Maunaloa | 376 | 253 | 116 | 67.3% | 6 |
Hana | 1,235 | 814 | 71 | 65.9% | 7 |
Waianae | 13,177 | 8,018 | 6 | 60.8% | 8 |
Keokea | 1,612 | 890 | 64 | 55.2% | 9 |
Kaunakakai | 3,425 | 1,887 | 40 | 55.1% | 10 |
Waikane | 778 | 417 | 101 | 53.6% | 11 |
Makaha | 8,278 | 4,393 | 16 | 53.1% | 12 |
Hauula | 4,148 | 2,188 | 34 | 52.7% | 13 |
Waiohinu | 213 | 110 | 132 | 51.6% | 14 |
Waimanalo | 5,451 | 2,791 | 28 | 51.2% | 15 |
Hawi | 1,081 | 535 | 93 | 49.5% | 16 |
Maili | 9,488 | 4,616 | 13 | 48.7% | 17 |
Kaaawa | 1,379 | 629 | 80 | 45.6% | 18 |
Pakala Village | 294 | 130 | 129 | 44.2% | 19 |
Kahaluu | 4,738 | 2,066 | 37 | 43.6% | 20 |
Makaha Valley | 1,341 | 582 | 88 | 43.4% | 21 |
Source: Civil Beat analysis of U.S. Census data
The five Waianae Coast towns all ranked in the top 21 of 151 towns statewide in terms of percentage of residents who self-identify as at least part-Native Hawaiian. But again, Waianae itself is not No. 1.
Both by total population and by percentage, the town of Waianae doesn’t top the list.
But so far Civil Beat’s analysis has been based on towns, without looking at the bigger picture. What happens if we include all five towns and the rural areas around them?
The entire Waianae Coast would be a more fair representation of the White House’s “Waianae area.” We can do that using other data from the Census.
Census County Divisions (CCDs) are chunks of islands. In all, there are 44 in the state, including seven on Oahu: Ewa, Honolulu, Koolauloa, Koolaupoko, Wahiawa, Waialua and Waianae.
The Waianae Census County Division includes both the town and the greater community.
Let’s take another look at those total and percentage rankings now that we’re talking about the full Waianae area.
County Division | Total population (all races) | Native Hawaiian alone or in any combination | Rank | Percent Native Hawaiian | Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ewa | 323,118 | 56,828 | 1 | 17.6% | 37 |
Honolulu | 390,738 | 48,024 | 2 | 12.3% | 40 |
Koolaupoko | 115,164 | 33,761 | 3 | 29.3% | 17 |
Waianae | 48,519 | 28,404 | 4 | 58.5% | 3 |
Hilo | 45,714 | 15,357 | 5 | 33.6% | 10 |
Keaau-Mountain View | 34,266 | 11,362 | 6 | 33.2% | 11 |
North Kona | 37,875 | 8,821 | 7 | 23.3% | 25 |
Koolauloa | 21,406 | 6,709 | 8 | 31.3% | 12 |
Wailuku | 20,729 | 6,271 | 9 | 30.3% | 14 |
Wahiawa | 41,216 | 6,018 | 10 | 14.6% | 38 |
Source: Civil Beat analysis of U.S. Census data
By this metric, Waianae comes in fourth in Hawaii, and the top three all have far larger total populations. The Ewa CCD that comes in first contains not only the Ewa plain but also a large swath of Central Oahu. Honolulu includes the downtown area and all that lies east of it. The Koolaupoko region includes Waimanalo and Waimanalo Beach, which we saw earlier is home to many Native Hawaiians.
Waianae makes a much stronger case when the measure is percentage of the total population of a CCD.
County Division | Total population (all races) | Native Hawaiian alone or in any combination | Rank | Percent Native Hawaiian | Rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Niihau | 170 | 149 | 41 | 87.6% | 1 |
West Molokai | 2,752 | 1,865 | 28 | 67.8% | 2 |
Waianae | 48,519 | 28,404 | 4 | 58.5% | 3 |
East Molokai | 4,503 | 2,616 | 20 | 58.1% | 4 |
Hana | 2,291 | 1,314 | 31 | 57.4% | 5 |
Kalawao | 90 | 46 | 42 | 51.1% | 6 |
Waihee-Waikapu | 6,907 | 2,757 | 18 | 39.9% | 7 |
Kekaha-Waimea | 5,561 | 2,069 | 26 | 37.2% | 8 |
North Kohala | 6,322 | 2,284 | 23 | 36.1% | 9 |
Source: Civil Beat analysis of U.S. Census data
Waianae ranks third in the state, but you’ll notice that all the rest of the leaders are small communities. In particular, Niihau at No. 1 has just 170 residents, 149 of whom self-identify as at least part-Native Hawaiian. That’s not surprising, considering that Niihau, part of Kauai County, is known as the “Forbidden Isle” because the family that owns it allows only Native Hawaiians to live or visit there.
Bottom line: It’s fair to say that Waianae has the highest percentage of Native Hawaiian residents. The two communities ahead of it are too small to be considered for that title. But the White House said Waianae is the “largest” Native Hawaiian community in the world — and largest is generally measured by a total number, not by percentage. Clearly, Honolulu and Ewa have far more Native Hawaiian residents than Waianae. Our grade is “Half True.”
Reporter-host Chad Blair contributed to this report.