Last year, just before the start of the Hawaii Legislature’s 2016 session, I blogged about which lawmakers were already holding campaign fundraisers.
It included a post on a well-known representative who later pulled me aside in a State Capitol stairwell to complain that he had scheduled his fundraiser just before session began that January, and not during the session.
His point was that I was being unfair, since no bills had been heard nor funds allocated for projects and programs at the time he was asking for political contributions.
Maybe. But bills and capital improvement projects and other initiatives were certainly already being crafted.
My point was — and is — that it is important for citizens to know that many (though not all) of their state senators and representatives raise money during the 60-day session that runs roughly from mid January to early May.
While a good number of everyday individuals give money to lawmakers, big bucks flow heavily from interest groups.
They include local labor groups, construction and building trades and business organizations, and mainland associations advocating for (and sometimes against) tobacco, alcohol, firearms, gambling, health care, insurance, agriculture and many other issues and industries.
To give you a feel for just how many groups are trying to sway Hawaii politics and policy, here’s a few of the 841 organizations currently represented by lobbyists in our state:
That’s just from the first page of the lobbyists registered with the Hawaii State Ethics Commission.
Not every lobbyist gives money to candidates, but quite a few do.
Why is this important?
Because it helps citizens understand the myriad alliances at play at the Legislature, and why some bills die mysterious deaths in spite of broad support while others advance in spite of tremendous opposition.
Few incumbents will tell you that campaign contributions actually influence how they ultimately vote, but the reality is that money talks. It also explains why former lawmakers and government officials often become lobbyists.
That’s why you’ll see former state Rep. Blake Oshiro (deputy chief of staff under Gov. Neil Abercrombie and an attorney at Alston Hunt Floyd & Ing) spending so much time at the Capitol. Same goes for Bruce Coppa, Abercrombie’s former chief of staff and a former state comptroller who did previous work with a major PR firm and the pro-rail hui Pacific Resource Partnership.
As part of Capitol Consultants of Hawaii (self-billed as “Hawaii’s top government affairs and consulting firm … Hawaii wins when we do”), Coppa and Oshiro’s clients include Airbnb and Monsanto. Perhaps their skilled representation helps explain why bills to allow travel companies to collect state taxes on rental units continue to move forward this session while legislation to require more disclosure on pesticide use has hit a speed bump.
Civil Beat contributor Ian Lind wrote that four of the top 10 contributors to campaigns in the first six months of last year were associated with Capitol Consultants, “the state’s top lobbyist firm, who combined to give nearly $60,000 to candidates during the six-month period.”
Not that Capitol Consultants always wins. Medical aid-in-dying legislation was given a lethal dose by the House Health Committee last week, even though Capitol Consultants’ co-founder and president emeritus is John Radcliffe.
This year I decided to take a different approach in publicizing who raised money during the 2017 session. I wanted to illustrate just how common the practice is, and to point out relationships and preferences.
The chart below shows who raised money, when and where, and with whom through March 21.
Lawmakers like to raise money together. Not coincidentally, those same lawmakers often partner on legislation and are part of political factions.
For example, Majority Leader Scott Saiki, Finance Chairwoman Sylvia Luke and Judiciary Chairman Scott are top House leaders.
Location is important, too. Mandalay Restaurant and Cafe Julia are just a short stroll from the Capitol.
Note as well that a number of neighbor island lawmakers hold fundraisers in Honolulu.
Some legislators raise money even when it seems they don’t need more. Luke, for example, reported having $165,000 in cash at the end of 2016 — even though she was unopposed for re-election.
In fact, Luke spent more than any other House candidate —$118,360 — in the 2016 election cycle. By comparison, the average expenditure for winning House candidates typically ranges from about $30,000 to around $60,000.
But Luke also contributes money from her campaign to that of others, usually by purchasing fundraising tickets.
(Click on a name then use arrow key to move right to see all fundraiser info.)
Last year Luke supported Reps. Tom Brower, Cedric Gates, Matt LoPresti, Aaron Ling Johanson, Karl Rhoads, Mark Nakashima, Richard Onishi, Jarrett Keohokalole, Joy San Buenaventura, Lynn DeCoite, Takashi Ohno and Della Au Belatti. All won election last year.
None of this is illegal. And governors, mayors and county council members also raise money even as they are doing the peoples’ business.
But unlike those office holders, the Legislature does the bulk of its important work during a period that spans only a few months. It’s no coincidence, then, that that is also when many lawmakers seek campaign cash.
After this article runs, I’ll no doubt get complaints from some lawmakers. I also don’t expect them to pass a law anytime soon prohibiting fundraising during session.
But maybe they should.
|Sen. Kai Kahele||Lola’s Grill and Pupu Bar (Hilo)||Jan. 16||$50|
|Sen. Jill Tokuda||Pacific Club||Jan. 17||$250|
|Sen. Donovan Dela Cruz||725 Kapiolani Blvd.||Jan. 17||$250|
|Sen. Gil Keith-Agaran||725 Kapiolani Blvd.||Jan. 17||$250|
|Sen. Lorraine Inouye||Mandalay Restaurant||Feb. 7||$150|
|Sen. Donovan Dela Cruz||Mandalay Restaurant||Feb. 7||$150|
|Sen. Michelle Kidani||Mandalay Restaurant||Feb. 7||$150|
|Rep. Daniel Holt||Mandalay Restaurant||Feb. 15||$100 – $1,000|
|Rep. Bob McDermott||Zippy’s Ewa Beach||Feb. 18||$200|
|Rep. Richard Onishi||Ground Zero||Mar. 7||$50 – $1,000|
|Sen. Stanley Chang||Square Barrels||Mar. 8||$50 – $1,000|
|Sen. Kai Kahele||725 Kapiolani Blvd.||Mar. 14||$75|
|Rep. Christopher Todd||725 Kapiolani Blvd.||Mar. 14||$75|
|Rep. Scott Nishimoto||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 15||$100|
|Rep. Tom Brower||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 15||$50 – $500|
|Rep. Aaron Ling Johanson||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 15||$100|
|Rep. Mark Nakashima||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 15||$100|
|Rep. Joy San Buenaventura||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. Cindy Evans||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. John Mizuno||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. Dee Morikawa||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. Roy Takumi||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. Della Au Belatti||Cafe Julia||Mar. 16||$100|
|Rep. Scott Nishimoto||Ruth’s Chris||Mar. 16||$150|
|Rep. Scott Saiki||Ruth’s Chris||Mar. 16||$150|
|Rep. Mark Nakashima||Ruth’s Chris||Mar. 16||$150|
|Rep. Sylvia Luke||Ruth’s Chris||Mar. 16||$150|
|Rep. Aaron Ling Johanson||Ruth’s Chris||Mar. 16||$150|
|Rep. Takashi Ohno||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 21||$50 – $1,000|
|Rep. Richard Creagan||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 21||$50 – $1,000|
|Rep. Nicole Lowen||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 21||$50 – $1,000|
|Rep. Bert Kobayashi||Mandalay Restaurant||Mar. 21||$50 – $1,000|