Kimo Field has one piece of advice for snorkelers in Hilo Bay: Go past the breakwater.
Just outside the 2-mile stretch of rock barrier in Hilo Bay, that’s where aquatic life bustles, offering tourists ample opportunity to swim with schools of fish every bit worthy of a Hawaiian vacation.
But as far as what’s inside the wall itself?
Marine life is sparse, says Field, captain and managing director of operations for Hilo Ocean Adventures.
“If people want to snorkel, they have to go outside the wall,” he said. “They have to swim all the way to the end and all the way to the back.”
That’s because the bay’s century-old breakwater, while protecting the harbor, has been inhibiting the water’s beneficial circulation, leaving the downtown pool in East Hawaii stagnant and full of silt.
Though hammerhead sharks hunker down in the bay during spawning season, and rays and some brackish fish swim there as well, the reef beneath the surface has long been dead and ocean life is far from abundant.
Recreationally, Hilo Bay is under-utilized, Field said, and aesthetically, it looks unhealthy at times.
“That’s going to have to be a top priority,” Field said of fixing the problem.
For Field, whose business is steps away from the bay’s shore, healthier water would mean more habitat for fish as well as more options for recreationists. The bay will be put to better use.
“It’ll be beneficial to just about everything,” he said.
Hawaii County agrees. It’s identified improving water quality in the bay as a high priority.
While improvements have been on the radar for more than a decade, the county Planning Department recently wrote a letter of support to the Army Corps of Engineers for a new study that could pave the way for improved water quality and circulation in Hilo Bay.
The study — which would be led by the Corps and is a follow-up to one the department conducted in 2009 — will analyze the benefits of breaching portions of the breakwater and other measures to improve water circulation, a press release issued by the county stated.
It will also identify sources of runoff into the bay, and provide plans, recommendations and measures to improve its water quality and circulation.
While the state Department of Health Clean Water Branch said bacteria levels in the bay haven’t raised concerns about contaminated water in some time, the county Department of Environmental Management office said it’s not uncommon for bacteria levels to increase after rainy days.
Hawaii County Planning Director Michael Yee agreed with that assessment.
“Over the past years, water quality has continued to be degraded by both upland water runoff and water circulation issues, which we believe are caused by the breakwater inhibiting the circulation within the Bay,” Yee wrote Aug. 12 in the letter of support to the Army Corps of Engineers.
Construction of the breakwater began between 1908 and 1930 in order to shield ships in the bay from rough swells, but the structure has also captured sediment flowing out of the Wailuku and Wailoa rivers, leading to poor water quality there.
Hawaii County Mayor Harry Kim said he has wanted for years to modify the breakwater to allow water to flow through portions of the wall, which would foster the return of marine life to Hilo Bay.
“Imagine how great it would be to be able to swim, paddle and fish with no fear of contamination,” Kim said in the press release. “By modifying the breakwater to clean up the water, you’ll see all kinds of fish and shellfish come back. This will transform Bayfront.”
Bayfront Highway is the main street that hugs the bay in downtown Hilo that passes by hotels, restaurants and the town’s famous farmers market.
The mayor, who lost his bid for reelection earlier this month and leaves office Dec. 7, raised the idea for further study last year with the state Department of Transportation’s Harbors Division, which agreed to a technical study to develop the scope of the project.
The budget for the new study is estimated at $100,000, with the state and county paying $25,000 each, and the federal government providing $50,000. The Hawaii County Council approved its share of the funds in January.
Once the federal money has been secured, the study can start, the press release stated. The first two phases of the three-phase study are slated to be conducted from October through April, with the third phase based on the outcome.
Field said he took the Army Corps of Engineers team out to the breakwater for four days to study it back in September 2018. He said a possible remedy discussed at the time was staggering openings in the wall.
What the study recommends is yet to be determined, as is the size and cost of any potential project or whether any recommended solutions are even worth doing, said Derek Chow, deputy director for the state Harbors Division.
But if the remedy involves breaking out portions of the wall, that’s a major undertaking regardless of how few pieces need removing or adjusting.
“Any work in the water is a major endeavor,” he said.
Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed.
Not a subscription
Civil Beat is a small nonprofit newsroom, and we’re committed to a paywall-free website and subscription-free content because we believe in journalism as a public service.
That’s why donations from readers like you are essential to our continued existence.
Help keep our journalism free for all readers by becoming a monthly member of Civil Beat today.