A federal class action lawsuit against the Hawaii Department of Education was filed Thursday by the American Civil Liberties Union of Hawaii over gender inequities for female athletes at the state’s most populous high school.
The 67-page complaint, brought under the federal anti-discrimination law known as Title IX, comes 10 months after the organization sent a demand letter to the DOE requesting the agency address the glaring disparity in locker room availability for boys and girls sports teams at Campbell High School.
That letter was sent to the DOE shortly after a Civil Beat report exposed the lack of girls locker room facilities on the Ewa Beach campus, with female softball team players forced to change for practice on school bleachers, run to an off-campus Burger King to use the restroom and haul heavy athletic gear from class to class because they had no place to store equipment. By contrast, male athletes faced no such hardships.
“We could have filed this 10 months ago when we first found out about the problem, but we’ve been trying to work with the DOE in the interim to see if we could avoid this,” said ACLU Hawaii Executive Director Josh Wisch. “We didn’t get the information we requested and we didn’t get to a result that we requested — more importantly, that students need. That’s what it’s about at the end of the day.”
The Oahu Interscholastic Association, an entity controlled by DOE that schedules games and tournaments at athletic facilities and organizes travel for all secondary schools on the island, is also named in the suit.
In a statement to Civil Beat Thursday morning, the DOE said it was unable to provide comment at this point.
“We have not received nor had a chance to review the lawsuit and are unable to provide information or a comment due to pending litigation,” spokeswoman Lindsay Chambers said.
The complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii, cites potential Title IX violations that go far beyond the lack of a girls locker room at Campbell High.
It alleges preferential treatment of boys sports teams over girls, including access to more qualified, experienced and better-paid coaches and trainers; scheduling of prime-time games at premier venues like Aloha Stadium that draw larger attendance; travel opportunities to compete in games and tournaments on neighbor islands and mainland destinations like Las Vegas and Phoenix; and more visible promotion and marketing, including on the school’s website.
The suit also alleges school administrators failed to secure a practice pool for the girls water polo team until after the 2017-18 season began, forcing the girls to practice either on dry land or in the open ocean and causing their coach to pay roughly $60 a day twice a week to rent out a regulation-sized pool for practices when school funding didn’t come through.
The complaint also alleges Campbell High administrators took retaliatory action against the girls water polo team when team members raised concerns about the conditions, including threatening to cancel the program and refusing to sign a $1,000 outside grant offered to the team.
The two plaintiffs in the lawsuit, identified by initials only, are 17-year-old seniors who are on the Campbell girls varsity water polo and swimming teams. They seek to represent a class of current and future Campbell High female students.
While the suit is specific to Campbell High, which in 2017-18 had an enrollment of 3,123 students, the allegations point to a troubling pattern of athletic gender inequality in Hawaii’s public schools, according to the ACLU.
“It’s larger than just Campbell High School,” said Mateo Caballero, legal director of ACLU Hawaii. “As you see from the history of lack of (Title IX) compliance in Hawaii, our hope is that we’ll get relief that goes beyond Campbell.”
This is not the first time DOE has been sued over purported Title IX violations. It was named in a 2010 lawsuit brought by ACLU Hawaii against Maui’s Baldwin High over use of the school’s athletic practice fields. In that case, U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra granted the plaintiffs a preliminary injunction that required the DOE to build a new girls softball practice field equal in quality to the field used by the boy’s baseball team.
The co-author and outspoken proponent of the 1972 Title IX law was the late Congresswoman Patsy Mink of Hawaii, for whom the act was renamed in 2002 as the “Patsy T. Mink Equal Opportunity in Education Act.”
Thursday afternoon, lawyers with ACLU Hawaii and their co-counsel held a press conference to discuss the suit outside the Hawaii State Library, where a new bronze sculpture of Mink has been installed. The congresswoman faced barriers in her career path due to her gender and race.
“This statue is a good reminder that (Mink’s) work is not done, and that the fight is not over,” Wisch told reporters gathered at the press conference.
Former Hawaii state Rep. Jackie Young had expressed concerns to the DOE as far back as 1994 over gender inequities in DOE’s school facilities, according to Thursday’s complaint.
The Hawaii Legislature passed legislation in 1999 requiring the state DOE to come up with a plan to address gender inequity in K-12 sports, but the bill was vetoed by then-Gov. Ben Cayetano after the DOE falsely assured the state it was compliant with Title IX, according to the complaint.
Through executive action Cayetano ordered the DOE to come up with a timeline for coming into Title IX compliance and a specific plan of how it planned to do so, including submitting mandatory quarterly and annual reports of progress, according to the complaint.
Shortly thereafter, the Legislature passed a law in 2000 known as the “Gender Equity in Athletics Law,” which created an advisory commission that, over the next several years, “played a key role in exposing routine delays in the DOE’s completion of baseline compliance assessments and its piecemeal or misguided approaches to resolving gender equity issues,” the complaint states.
The commission’s evaluations at the time focused on five Hawaii high schools — Hilo, Kahuku, Kaiser, King Kekaulike and Roosevelt. It looked specifically at better locker rooms and facilities, as well as more opportunity for pre-season competition, offered to boys teams.
After the advisory commission issued a final report in 2003 indicating “minimal progress” by the DOE, “progress regarding gender equity in athletics has halted and, in several respects, even regressed,” the complaint states.
In March, the Hawaii DOE sent its response to the ACLU’s demand letter to come up with a specific plan to address the locker room issue by the 2018-19 school year. But the response lacked mention of a specific plan or comprehensive data points, other than several gender inequity projects currently underway.
The facilities branch has maintained that the old age of many DOE schools — many more than 100 years old — makes constructing new facilities or locker rooms no easy thing.
In a recent presentation to the state Board of Education, the DOE said it would isolate “Gender Equity” into a separate category as far as allocation of dollars. Previously, it was folded into a broader bucket known as “Program Support,” which received $27 million in fiscal year 2019.
The DOE has requested $10.7 million for “gender equity” alone for fiscal years 2020 and 2021.
The allegations specific to Campbell High read like a blueprint of what not to do if you’re a public school trying to be compliant with Title IX.
It discusses a boys stand-alone athletic locker room facility equipped with 120 full-size lockers, showers, at least four bathroom stalls, plus air conditioning and an office. It references a boys “baseball house” that has a mini-fridge and couch, plus a large storage container used to store equipment, plus a batting cage. By contrast, the girls softball team has no such dedicated “softball house,” and is offered a container half the size of the boys in need of repair with no access to bathrooms close to their practice field.
It also discusses the wide disparity in the composition of coaching staff, noting how the Campbell’s girls varsity softball and soccer teams currently lack full-time coaches, with coaching vacancies on the boys teams filled far more quickly.
This extends to pay for coaches: the complaint also alleges that in two of the last three years, assistant coaches of the girls water polo team were not compensated in order to boost the salaries of the boys football coaches and hire more assistant coaches for that team.
The consequence is more turnover, according to the complaint: the Campbell girls water polo team had three different head coaches in the last four years, which has been “incredibly disruptive to the water polo athletes,” states the complaint.
The suit also alleges that few athletic trainers are present at girls games, putting those athletes at increased risk of injury.
In a statement Thursday, the two female plaintiffs expressed their frustration over inferior treatment.
“I’m tired of seeing my team’s passion and efforts get pushed aside and unaccounted for just because we’re not boys,” “Plaintiff One” said. “We never get taken seriously, and it feels like nothing we do ever matters and that the DOE doesn’t care about us. We’re not asking for much, just equality.”
“I know so many girls that are passionate and good at what they do but they always get pushed aside,” continued “Plaintiff One.” “There’s also many girls that want to participate in more sports but they decide not to because the school offers us no support.”
The lawsuit seeks a court ruling that the DOE has discriminated against Campbell High female athletes and retaliated against them in violation of Title IX and an injunction that the agency devise some plan to address the concerns.
Elizabeth Kristen, Legal Aid At Work senior attorney who’s co-representing the plaintiffs, said she’s hopeful the suit will cause the DOE to “engage in structured negotiations to come to a binding settlement agreement.”
“The bigger picture point is that this is a systemic issue and monitoring needs to be system-wide,” said ACLU Hawaii staff attorney Wookie Kim. “It’s really hard to single out single schools for being good or bad. Campbell High School happens to be the most egregious example we saw and that’s why we’re focusing on that school now.”
Read the Complaint:
Civil Beat is a small nonprofit newsroom, and we’re committed to a paywall-free website and subscription-free content because we believe in journalism as a public service.
That’s why donations from readers like you are essential to our continued existence.
Help keep our journalism free for all readers by becoming a monthly member of Civil Beat today.