In a rare moment of political candor, the new prime minister of Japan, Yoshihiko Noda, complained to his party: “Running the government is like pushing a snowball up a road covered with snow. The more you push, the bigger the snowball gets. If we fight among ourselves and let our hands slip off the snowball, it starts rolling downward.”

“Japan today,” he lamented, “is like that snowball rolling downhill.”

The view that Japanese politics are mired in turmoil is widely accepted inside and outside Japan. After Mr. Noda was elected last week, a score of politically savvy Japanese and Americans experienced in Japan, in response to an e-mailed query, attested to that disarray.

The Japanese and the “Japan hands” saw several reasons for the chaos. They pointed to Japan’s struggle to digest parliamentary democracy, an alien form of governance. Parties are coalitions of feudal factions held together by personal loyalty to the faction leader who raises campaign funds for his followers.

These knowledgeable observers asserted that the bursting of the “bubble economy” 20 years ago, after years of swift growth, had lessened Japanese confidence in their political leaders. U.S. aid and purchases during the Korean War of 1950-1953 helped Japan recover from World War II but then the Japanese themselves took charge of the economy.

Several contended that Japan’s reliance on the United States for national security during the past sixty years had undermined a sense of sovereignty, national pride, and assurance that their political leaders could meet that basic responsibility. The U.S.-Japan security treaty obliges the United States to defend Japan in return for permitting U.S. bases there.

And they noted cultural characteristics that hampered effective government. Japanese make decisions by a consensus in which everyone affected has a say. “The need for appeasing all the interest groups,” said an American long resident in Japan, “tends to make changing policy like stirring cold molasses.”

Japanese avoid risks and spread responsibility around and seem ambivalent about strong leaders as authoritarian militarists led them into war, devastation, and defeat in World War II.

In vivid contrast to their government’s failures has been the Japanese response to the calamity caused by an earthquake, tsunami, and leakage from nuclear power plants last March. Said a former senior American official: “The Japanese people demonstrated extraordinary stoicism, discipline, cohesiveness, and selflessness in this disaster.”

“America and the world,” he said, “stood in awe.”

For the United States, the flaws in Japan’s politics have raised a critical question: Will Japan be a reliable ally as the United States seeks to retain its power position in Asia and to deter an increasingly assertive China. Not only Americans but Japanese diplomats have already begun to ponder that issue.

After World War II, an establishment of conservative politicians, career government officials, and business executives governed Japan. That establishment led Japan into producing the second strongest economy in the world and the highest standard of living in Asia.

The prime ministers in the establishment included Shigeru Yoshida, who set Japan on the road to economic strength; Hayato Ikeda, who engineered a doubling of the national income; Eisaku Sato, awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for proscribing nuclear arms for Japan; and Yasuhiro Nakasone, who sought to revive Japanese national pride.

Each served for more than four years, enabling them to accomplish at least some of their objectives.
The establishment came apart with the end of the true postwar period between 1989, when Emperor Hirohito, who had reigned since 1926, passed away and 1993 when Prime Minister Kiichi Miyazawa, the last of Mr. Yoshida’s deshi, or protégés, stepped down. The economy also faltered about this time.

In particular, the politicians of the ruling Democratic Party of Japan, most of whom are inexperienced in governing, and the corps of officials who specialize in forging and executing government programs, have been openly hostile to each other for the better part of a decade.

In the last 18 years, Japan has had 13 prime ministers, only one of which, Jun’ichiro Koizumi, revived a sense of hope during the five years (2001-2006) he was in office. The rest of Mr. Noda’s immediate predecessors served for an average of a year, hardly time to do much more than rearrange the furniture in the prime minister’s office.

In this less than inspiring climate, qualified people hesitate to go into politics. “We have no choice of candidates,” said a Japanese editor, “but second or third generation politicians who were born to politicians’ families and have never done anything but be a son or grandson of a politician or are former bureaucrats or TV personalities.”

“Capable, smart men or women with vision,” the editor said, “are not stupid enough to run for public office.”


About the author: Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and U.S. relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and the last third on investigative reporting or general assignment. He did three tours in Asia as a correspondent, for Business Week, The Washington Post, and The New York Times, and was a military correspondent for The New York Times for ten years. He is the author of Japan: Images and Realities and To Arm a Nation: Rebuilding America’s Endangered Defenses, and four other books. As a paratrooper, Halloran served in the U.S., Japan, Korea, Taiwan, and Vietnam. He has been awarded the George Polk Award for National Reporting, the Gerald R. Ford Prize for Distinguished Reporting on National Defense, the U.S. Army’s Outstanding Civilian Service Medal, and Japan’s Order of the Sacred Treasure. He holds an AB from Dartmouth College in government and international relations, an MA from the University of Michigan in East Asian Studies, and had a Ford Foundation Fellowship at Columbia’s East Asia Institute.

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...