After 200 years of bitter hostility, the French and Germans have been seeking to escape the demons of their history by forming an army brigade of 5,000 soldiers drawn equally from each nation.
Soldiers of the Franco-German Brigade, stationed on both sides of the border between France and Germany, told visiting Americans recently that “the past is past and that is one thing the brigade has learned to accept.” The soldiers, said one officer, think “it is important to ignore the protests of older generations and to move into the present day.”
The brigade raises an intriguing question: If the French and Germans can put the past behind them, could Asians do the same? Imagine a Japanese-Korean brigade or an Indian-Pakistani regiment or an ASEAN Legion of troops from Vietnam, Cambodia, Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines.
From an American point of view, any such formations would be welcomed with drums rolling and banners flying. They could lessen frictions that hamper the U.S. security posture in Asia every day and that threaten to heat up into violent conflict at almost any time.
Such combined military formations could also serve as part of a counter-balance to a China that is swiftly modernizing its armed forces and making its neighbors visibly nervous. And joint efforts in Asia would ease the strain on a U.S. that is cutting back on defense spending and operations.
The Franco-German Brigade grew out of a summit meeting between President Francois Mitterand of France and Chancellor Helmut Kohl of Germany in 1987. Two years later, the brigade became operational and later came under the command of the multinational EuroCorps. Elements of the brigade have served in Kosovo, Bosnia, and Afghanistan.
French and German are equal official languages in the Deutsch-Französische Brigade or Brigade franco-allemande. At higher levels, many educated officers speak the other’s language, plus some English. Soldiers in the ranks, however, struggle to communicate in their day-to-day duties.
The American visitors were told that “thousands of years of history do not matter once the brigade steps onto the field.” An officer said: “If the guy next to you — someone you lived and worked with — is in trouble, you’re not going to think about what nationality he is, you’re going to fight for him.” (Soldiers have held that to be true since the days of Alexander the Great, the Macedonian general in the 3rd Century BC.)
In Asia, Japanese disdain Koreans and Koreans despise Japanese despite some similarities in culture and language. Japanese have held that Korea is “a dagger pointed at the heart of Japan” and was the base from which the Mongols tried to invade Japan. In turn, the Japanese have invaded Korea several times and occupied Korea from 1910 to 1945, leaving behind a cultivated, nurtured hatred of Japan.
The U.S. has a security treaty with each nation but has minimal trilateral contacts or operations. “We have to be careful what we tell the Koreans about what we’re doing with the Japanese,” said a senior American officer, “and we have to be just as careful what we tell the Japanese about what we’re doing with the Koreans.”
India and Pakistan share similarities in culture and language and their armed forces are descendants of the Indian Army formed during a century of the British Raj. But Muslim Pakistan and Hindu India have fought four wars since partition in 1947, during which perhaps a million people died in riots. Both have also acquired nuclear arms.
U.S. security relations with Pakistan today are at perhaps their lowest point ever given acrimonious disputes over Afghanistan, the Taliban, governance, and other issues. With India, security relations are lukewarm at best even though the U.S. in recent years has diligently sought to expand them at every level.
In ASEAN, the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, the U.S. has security treaties with the Philippines and Thailand, good working relations with Singapore, quiet dealings with Malaysia, and gradually improving military ties with Indonesia and the former adversary in Vietnam. Multinational contacts, however, are skimpy.
Moreover, most nations in Southeast Asia have skirmished with a neighbor at one time or another and each is jealous of its post-colonial sovereignty. Even so, many have quietly told American officers they are interested in closer with ties with the U.S. — and their neighbors — because they fear an aggressive and expanding China.
