Several American military officers in mufti and carrying civilian passports slipped into Taiwan some days ago to watch 20,000 Taiwanese soldiers, sailors, marines, and airmen charge through Han Kuang maneuvers to prepare them to repel a possible Communist Chinese invasion.
Those officers were among the 1,500 American military and defense officials a year who travel to the self-governing island off the coast of China. In addition, the U.S. sells large quantities of arms and provides training at bases in the U.S. even though the U.S. lacks diplomatic relations and a security treaty with Taiwan.
Most of these American military contacts are done out of the public eye as the U.S. seeks to avoid provoking the wrath of China, which claims sovereignty over the island and rages against all U.S. ties with Taiwan. “None of this is covert,” said one officer, “but we do try to keep it discreet.”
From Taiwan’s standpoint, said a former Taiwanese diplomat, “We need to strengthen our defenses to hold off an invader long enough to make it easier for the Americans to come in.”
U.S. dealings with Taiwan are governed by the Taiwan Relations Act (TRA) of 1979, passed by Congress after President Jimmy Carter switched U.S diplomatic recognition from Taiwan to the Peoples Republic of China and abrogated the security treaty with Taiwan. The TRA requires the U.S. to “make available to Taiwan such defense articles and defense services” as needed to “maintain a sufficient self-defense capability.”
Among the quiet Americans who have served in Taiwan recently have been six U.S. Marine marksmen fresh from Afghanistan who went there last summer from a Scout Sniper Platoon at Camp Pendleton in California. They trained alongside Taiwanese Marines, special operations forces, and police teams.
Retired American admirals and generals make frequent visits, then report to the Pacific Command (PACOM) in Hawaii. Middle-grade officers and senior non-commissioned officers go there to consult with Taiwan’s officers and civilian leaders. In turn, Taiwan’s officers visit Hawaii, Washington, and U.S. bases on the mainland.
Taiwan’s military leaders have asked for American advice on organizing a recruiting service because Taiwan plans to end conscription in favor of a volunteer force—and no one in Taiwan has experience in recruiting young men and women into military service. The Americans have also emphasized the merits of strong non-commissioned officers.
U.S. arms sales to Taiwan, which have been visible, have jumped from $153 million in 1990 to $6.48 billion in 2010. The most recent package, worth $5.58 billion, was announced last fall. Over time, the quality of the items sold has been upgraded so today they are much the same as those in U.S. forces.
Included have been 150 F-16 fighters, four old but serviceable destroyers, 1,300 Stinger missiles, 30 Apache and 60 Blackhawk helicopters, and 330 Patriot Advanced Capability (PAC-3) anti-missile missiles. As one officer said: “The F-16’s get all the public attention but it’s not just airplanes we send them.”
Moreover, Taiwan’s F-16 pilots have been training at Luke AFB in Arizona since 1997. Helicopter pilots are trained at Fort Rucker in Alabama. Officers attend the Army, Navy, Marine, and Air Force war colleges and the Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies in Honolulu. Younger officers go to U.S. artillery, armor, and signal schools.
The U.S. observers at the Han Kuang (China’s Glory) maneuvers saw command post exercises for leaders and field training for troops. Pentagon officials have been meeting with Taiwan’s officials since 1997 in Monterey, California. The U.S.-Taiwan Business Council has promoted arms sales.
A hotline was set up between the Pentagon and Taiwan’s Ministry of National Defense in 2002. And when an American company sells equipment to Taiwan, technicians go there to train the Taiwanese in maintenance. “They need to know more,” said a U.S. official, “than how the on/off switch works.”
The political sensitivities surrounding almost every aspect of U.S. relations with Taiwan have led to a strange façade. The U.S. is represented in Taipei by the American Institute in Taiwan (AIT), a quasi-embassy staffed by 500 State Department diplomats and employees who have non-diplomatic titles such as director instead of ambassador.
Military attaches posted to AIT wear civilian clothes and have innocuous titles. American warships do not make port calls in Taiwan and military aircraft do not land there except on humanitarian missions. Unlike U.S. embassies everywhere else, AIT does not fly an American flag, which irritates some visiting Americans.
Sometimes this gets to be almost comical as American military people in Hawaii scramble to make sure visitors from Taiwan and China don’t bump into each other when they are in Honolulu at the same time.
