As anti-American eruptions, many of them violent, swept east from Libya and Egypt through the Middle East and South Asia to Indonesia and the Philippines last week, Muslim protestors demanded to know why America had not suppressed a film they said insulted their Prophet Mohammed.
In response, U.S. leaders condemned the producers of the film but were notoriously inept in explaining the freedom of speech that is rooted in the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. They failed to communicate the principles under which Americans are free to express themselves—even at the risk of angering other people.
The prime minister of Pakistan, Raja Pervez Ashraf, reflected a wide Muslim view when he asserted that defaming religion should not be excused by freedom of expression. He was quoted by Xinhua, China’s official news agency, as saying: “”Let me make it absolutely clear: this is not about freedom of expression, this is more about hatred.”
He said the President of Pakistan, Asif Ali Zardari, would address this issue before the UN General Assembly this week. “Our demand is simple,” the prime minister contended: “Blasphemy of the kind witnessed in this case is nothing short of hate speech, equal to the worst kind of anti- Semitism or other kinds of bigotry.”
In its essence, this conflict is what the late Samuel Huntington, a scholar at Harvard, predicted: He argued in 1993 that henceforth a “clash of civilizations will dominate global politics.” This particular clash is between the Judeo-Christian culture of America and the Islamic culture of 1.5 billion Muslims in North Africa, the Middle East, and Asia.
In America, the concepts of the First Amendment have been debated ever since Thomas Jefferson put pen to paper to help incite the Revolution of 1776. Not until 1919, however, did Americans define an acceptable limit to free speech despite the absolute wording of the First Amendment.
The amendment says Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech but Oliver Wendell Holmes, a Supreme Court justice, laid down the doctrine of “clear and present danger” to set boundaries. He wrote:
“The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger.” Freedom of speech, he declared, did not give anyone the right to shout “fire” in a crowded theater, causing a panic in which people were trampled to death.
That was reinforced in 1931 by Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes, who wrote that in wartime: “No one would question but that a government might prevent actual obstruction to its recruiting service or the publication of the sailing dates of transports or the number and location of troops.”
Today, the clash of civilizations poses troubling questions about the freedom of speech.
- Does the pervasive flow of information through the internet, television, radio, the press, and cell phones constitute a virtual crowded theater into which no one should be permitted to toss an incendiary verbal bomb?
- Is the conflict between cultures tantamount to a state of war that warrants the imposition of restrictions on free speech as it might in an old-fashioned shooting war?
- Or, should Muslims or anyone else be permitted to dictate what Americans think, believe, and say in their own country? If a movie made in the U.S.A. is not to the liking of other people, shouldn’t they just ignore it? That’s what an “off” switch is for.
In all this turmoil, perhaps the saddest aspect is that the video that allegedly caused the explosion is garbage that most people wouldn’t pay a dime to go see. The acting is amateurish, the script and dialogue boring, and the plot almost non-existent. If some Muslims had not made an issue of it, it would have fallen unnoticed into a dust bin.
Indeed, how many Muslims actually saw the film entitled “Innocence of Muslims” and understood it, particularly if its language was not translated into a local tongue and was broadcast only in English that is not spoken in much of the swath of the Islamic world?
Or were the mobs that ran amok goaded into violence by clever men with a hidden agenda?
