Skeptics can be pardoned if they regard with jaded eye the Bangsamoro peace agreement signed last week in the Philippines between the government in Manila and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), insurgents who have been fighting in the southern island of Mindanao and nearby islands.

As might be expected, President Benigno Aquino III was optimistic in the flowery language often favored by Filipino politicians: “In full view of the Filipino people, and witnessed even by our friends from different parts of the world, we commit to peace.”

He asserted that it would be “a peace that will be sustained through democratic ideals; a peace that heals and empowers; a peace that recognizes the many narratives of the Filipino people, and weaves them into a single, national aspiration for equitable progress.”

Prime Minister Najib Razak of Malaysia, who helped forge the pact, was a bit more cautious. He said the agreement “will protect the rights of the Bangsamoro people and preserve the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Philippines.” But he said it “does not solve all the problems, rather it sets the parameters in which peace can be found.”

This agreement is but the first step in establishing an autonomous region, called Bangsamoro, in Mindanao. The agreement further calls for deciding how power and wealth generated from natural resources will be shared between Bangsamoro and Manila. Negotiations to reach those decisions are due to begin next month.

Bangsamoro is an ancient word comprising “bangsa,” from the Malay meaning nation, and “moro,” from the Spanish meaning the Moors or Muslims, who occupied Spain for 700 years until just before Spain colonized the Philippines. Spanish memories of the Muslims were still strong.

Of critical importance, the agreement calls on the MILF to accept a “graduated program for the decommissioning of its forces so that they are put beyond use,” which means completely disarmed. This has been a stumbling block for insurgencies in almost every place and time. Insurgents just don’t want to give up their guns.

The U.S. has a direct interest in the outcome of this process. Some American troops, mostly Special Operations Forces such as the Army’s Green Berets, have been advising the Armed Forces of the Philippines on counter-insurgency for a dozen years, with only moderate success.

On a wider scale, the Obama Administration has begun its “pivot” to the Pacific in which American diplomatic and military leaders have been urged to pay greater attention to security issues in the western Pacific and Asia. The South China Sea, along the eastern flank of which sits the Philippine archipelago, has become a focal point.

Political stability in the Philippines has therefore become a critical issue for the security posture of the U.S. in Asia. A weak government in Manila that is further distracted by insurgencies could hamper U.S. operations.

Among the elements drawing skepticism is that only the MILF is party to the agreement. Other insurgents such as the communist New People’s Army and the National Democratic Front not having been included. Nor have the Abu Sayeff, the terrorists who are allied with al Qaida and other Islamic terrorists in Southeast Asia.

Nor has a splinter group, the Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Movement. Indeed, the Philippines have been racked with insurgencies ever since the Moros and others fought first against the Spaniards until the Spanish-American War and then against the U.S., which acquired the Philippines from Spain after that war.

The Huks, or Hukbalahaps, fought a guerrilla war against the Japanese invaders in World War II and then against the newly independent Philippine government until they were put down under the leadership of Secretary of National Defense and then President Ramon Magsaysay in 1954.

Finally, the Moro insurgency has its roots deep in the turbulent history of the Philippines. Islam came to the southern Philippines in the 14th Century as it spread eastward from Arabia to India, Malaysia, and Indonesia. After getting a foothold in the southern Philippines, Islam spread north into the Visayas and ultimately Luzon.

Christianity came with the Spaniards in the 16th Century and the two have been in conflict off and on ever since. The Christians drove the Muslims out of northern and central Philippines back to Mindanao where they were to have an autonomous homeland. Muslims complain that Manila has never lived up to that promise.

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...