Critics of American spending for military power often make three arguments:

  • The U.S. spends more than a combination of the military budgets of the next 12 or 15 or 17 nations, depending on who is counting and what is included;
  • Military spending drains funds from welfare, health care, education, and other domestic programs and thus should be a prime target for cuts;
  • Military spending is rife with fraud, waste, and abuse and therefore should be rigorously scrutinized and scrubbed.

Despite their political appeal, the first and second arguments are simplistic and should be rejected as misleading. The third is pertinent and has been so for at least 30 years under Presidents Reagan, Bush the elder, Clinton, Bush the younger, and Obama.

Two senior members of the House Armed Services Committee, one Republican and the other Democrat, underscored that third point last week in calling for reform in the way weapons are acquired.

Rep. Mac Thornberry, (R-TX), asserted that despite repeated attempts at reform “it’s worse now than it’s ever been.” Rep. Loretta Sanchez, (D-CA) was critical of efforts by members of Congress to add items not requested by the Pentagon, such as additional sites for missile defenses.

On the wider issue, a more rational way to compare national military expenditures is see what share of national wealth, a standard measure of which is gross domestic product (GDP), is allocated to military spending.

For the U.S., 4.7 percent of GDP is given to military spending, according to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), which is widely reputed to be fair. That is more than most other nations because the U.S., for better or worse, has been the world’s policeman since World War II.

Because the U.S. has taken on that responsibility, allies and friends have been able to allot much smaller shares of their GDP to military spending. In Asia, SIPRI reports, treaty allies South Korea, Australia, Thailand, Japan, and the Philippines spend between 2.7 percent to 0.8 percent of GDP on military power.

The city-state of Singapore, which often encourages the U.S. to maintain a strong military presence in Southeast Asia, spends 3.7 percent of GDP on its forces. India, with which the U.S. has been cultivating new military relations, assigns 2.7 percent of GDP to defense.

Similarly, U.S. allies in Europe allot far less of their national wealth to military forces. One group that includes Italy, Germany, Belgium, Denmark, and the Netherlands spends between only 1.7 to 1.0 percent of GDP. Another group, including Britain, Turkey, Greece, France, and Portugal, spends between 2.6 and 2.1 percent of GDP.

Russia, the adversary during the Cold War, assigns 3.9 percent of GDP to military spending but drafts people who are paid a pittance instead of relying, as in the U.S., on volunteers who are paid a living wage. China, with the world’s second largest and fastest growing economy, allots 2.1 percent of GDP to military power.

North Korea, which was not covered in the SIPRI study, is estimated by Western intelligence to spend about 25 percent of its national wealth on military power, thus allowing people to starve while the armed forces develop and fire ballistic missiles, as it did last week.

The relatively big spenders on military power are Middle Eastern nations. Oil-rich Saudi Arabia allocates 10.1 percent of GDP to its military budget. Next door Oman assigns 9.7 percent, the United Arab Emirates 6.9 percent while Jordan allots 6.1 percent of GDP to the armed forces. Iraq assigns 5.4 percent. Even though Iran is developing nuclear arms, it spends only 1.8 percent of GDP on its forces. Israel, to defend itself and preserve its existence, allocates 6.5 percent of GDP to its armed forces.

In the U.S. itself, the federal Bureau of Economic Analysis, using a somewhat different set of numbers, says that consumption of durable goods, non-durables, and services takes 70.9 percent of America’s GDP while defense spending gets just 5.5 percent. Only government non-defense spending, at 2.6 percent, is smaller.

Conclusion: The U.S. can clearly afford to spend about 5 percent of its wealth on military power. Are those funds well-spent? Equally clearly, no. But no administration in the last 30 years has shown the political will to eliminate Congressional pork, insist on Pentagon reform, and get allies to pick up a larger share of the burden.

It is to those slices of military spending that the critics might better put their attention.

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...