Like a couple of kids flinging mud balls, the U.S. State Department and China’s State Council Information Office have gotten into an intense quarrel over human rights. Foggy Bottom has accused China of coercion and torture while Beijing has contended that the U.S. has “turned a blind eye to its own woeful human rights situation.”
First, the State Department published its annual review of human rights around the world, which included a denunciation of China for “severe official repression of the freedoms of speech, religion, association, and harsh restrictions” on ethnic minorities in Xinjiang and Tibet.
Two days later, the Chinese shot back, contending that “firearms-related crimes posed serious threat to the lives” of American citizens. Political contributions, the Chinese argued, “had, to a great extent, influenced electoral procedures.” Further, the U.S. government has expanded eavesdropping and censoring personal communications.
So it went, in sharp contrast to the diplomatic platitudes uttered by State Councilor and, in effect, foreign minister Yang Jiechi and Secretary of State John Kerry during Kerry’s visit to Beijing earlier this month.
In statements to the press, Yang reaffirmed “the agreement on building a cooperative partnership and exploring a new type of major country relations between China and the United States.” Kerry applauded Chinese leaders who had “articulated a vision of a stronger relationship with the United States.”
This jabbing over human rights raised a question for both governments: What right did it have to judge the record on human rights in another sovereign nation? Who authorized the State Department and the State Council Information Office to criticize the human rights on the other side of the Pacific Ocean?
To put it more bluntly, maybe someone should tell the State Department and the State Council Information Office to ”mind your own business.” On the other hand, Kerry asserted: “These reports send a very clear message that all governments have a responsibility to protect universal human rights.”
The State Department’s report, which was mandated by the Congress in the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 and the Trade Act in 1974, assesses the state of human rights in every country from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe. Among the most extensive reports is that on China, with most information apparently gathered from open sources.
The report said that “efforts to silence and intimidate political activists” had increased. Communist authorities resorted to enforced disappearances and house arrest.. Other tactics included extrajudicial killing, executions without due process, incommunicado detention, and prolonged detention at holding facilities known as “black jails.”
Further, the State Department charged, confessions were coerced from prisoners while harassment of lawyers, journalists, writers, and dissidents was commonplace. A lack of due process in judicial proceedings, political control of courts and judges, closed trials and administrative detention was widespread.
Nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) were subjected to intense scrutiny, State said. Women were discriminated against as were persons with disabilities. A coercive birth-limitation policy in some cases resulted in forced abortions, sometimes at advanced stages of pregnancy, or forced sterilization. Corruption remained widespread.
In Beijing, the State Council Information Office, clearly awaiting State’s report, lashed back but without, for the most part, trying to refute State’s allegations. The U.S. report, the Chinese said, was “full of carping and irresponsible remarks on the human rights situation in more than 190 countries and regions including China.”
In turn, the Chinese declared, in the U.S. “the police often abused their power, resulting in increasing complaints and charges for infringement upon civil rights. The proportion of women in the U.S. who fell victims of domestic violence and sexual assault kept increasing.”
“The U.S. has become one of the developed countries with the greatest income gap,” the Chinese report asserted. “About 16.4 million children lived in poverty and, for the first time in history, public schools reported more than one million homeless children.” Moreover, “serious sex, racial and religious discrimination” afflicted the U.S.
“The U.S. seriously infringed upon human rights of other nations,” the Chinese contended. “In 2012, U.S. military operations in Yemen, Afghanistan and Pakistan caused massive civilian casualties. U.S. soldiers had also severely blasphemed against local residents’ religion by burning copies of the Muslim holy book, the Koran.”
Finally, the Chinese, who are quick to accuse others of interfering in China’s internal affairs, appeared to insert themselves into a political debate that rages throughout America, claiming: “The U.S. is among the few developed countries without health insurance covering its whole population.”
Was that an endorsement of Obamacare?
