How green are the governor candidates?
Civil Beat asked the three leading hopefuls for the state’s top job to open their homes so we could compare and contrast their personal environmental practices against their professed policy platforms. Mufi Hannemann, formerly mayor of Honolulu, declined the proposal in its entirety. His Democratic rival, former U.S. Rep. Neil Abercrombie, said no to the request to visit his residence but did answer some of our questions.
Lt. Gov. James “Duke” Aiona went one step further, though not all the way. Last week he agreed to sit down and talk face-to-face. When we met Wednesday, he said he would not let Civil Beat into his home, citing privacy for his family as the reason. Instead, campaign spokesman Travis Taylor showed me some pictures he took of Aiona’s potted plants and water filter with his smartphone. Not quite the same as seeing it for yourself.
Aiona has posted his positions on some sustainability questions on his campaign website. He also has a petition to support clean energy.
His clean energy platform promises that he “is committed to realizing the promise of a clean energy future, and he will ensure we do so in an environmentally-friendly way that makes economic sense and moves our state toward greater self-sufficiency.”
When Aiona spoke to Civil Beat this week at his Nimitz Highway campaign headquarters, he wove a story about balancing the needs of a family of seven and the desire to attain personal sustainability.
“I’m probably gonna be buried in a van,” he said.
Aiona is and always will be a “Volkswagen guy.” His wife once owned a VW bug, and he had a 1977 VW van for years. He’s never owned a new car and the only gas-guzzler he’s ever had was a smooth-riding Cadillac that he sold after just six months, he said.
Until recently he would ride his 12-speed Fuji bike 26 miles from Kapolei to the office once each week, he said. As lieutenant governor, Aiona is entitled by law to a security detail that includes a government-issued Sport Utility Vehicle for government business and public appearances, his campaign confirmed. Now that’s how he generally gets around.
But his primary personal vehicle for the last two decades has been a grey 1987 Volkswagen Vanagon Wolfsburg edition, with captain’s chairs up front and backward-facing bucket seats for his four children. He picked it up lightly used in 1990 and put more than 250,000 miles on it until its transmission finally gave out last November.
The van was a favorite of Aiona’s two sons; they could put their surfboards right inside. It was there for days at the beach, camping trips and a slew of other family events with them and his two daughters.
In the eight months since the van gave out, a 1993 Toyota Corolla has been the family’s main transport. (This means two of the three candidates drive 1993 Toyotas. Abercrombie drives a Tercel.)
But Aiona’s not giving up yet on his favorite ride. He’s purchasing a white 1990 Vanagon with a busted engine and is going to take parts from both the 1987 model and his new van to create a “robo-van” that can ferry the seven-member Aiona household — Aiona, his wife, four children and 92-year old mother — around for years to come.
Aiona said the van’s manual transmission yielded 18 or 19 miles to the gallon — not bad for a vehicle of its size and age. The official government source for fuel efficiency information, fueleconomy.gov, says a 1987 Vanagon could get as much as 15 mpg in the city and as much as 17 mpg on the highway and would generate about 12 tons of greenhouse gas emissions per year.
While the family car is an old-timer, the Aionas have taken steps into the future of conservation.
Aiona said he first got a solar water heater in the 1980s, “back when nobody was doing it.” He learned along the way about energy-efficient lightbulbs, and now the majority of fixtures in his home have compact fluorescent lights. All of the appliances, with the exception of the clothes dryer, are Energy Star, though the Aionas have a clothesline in their garage because the homeowners association in their Kapolei neighborhood doesn’t allow lines outside, he said.
“Kapolei is perfect for a PV system” but the association is tough on solar systems, Aiona said. “I’d love to be net metered. I guess that would be my goal.” (Net metered means a house that produces more power than it uses can sell the excess power back to the utility.)
The Aiona family’s use of electricity is monitored by the lieutenant governor’s eldest adult daughter, who gives everyone an earful when the monthly bill tops $300, Aiona said. It normally fluctuates between $200 and $300, depending on which children are home and if there are any houseguests.
Appliances that consume energy at the Aiona home are an air ventilator for Aiona’s mother, fans that are usually but not always used in lieu of a split air conditioning system, and the filter for a backyard pool that runs about five hours per day.
The pool also requires water, especially during the summer when higher temperatures and drier conditions lead to more evaporation. One of the family’s two showers is low-flow, though the toilets have not been upgraded to use less water. The sprinkler and irrigation systems run for between five and 15 minutes three days each week, and Aiona said he is in charge of the lawn and yard work and tries to use plants that don’t require much water. The water bill fluctuates, but the most recent one of around $300 was “outrageous,” Aiona said.
The Aionas grow green onions, alfalfa and basil in a small herbal garden, and Aiona’s wife does some of the family’s grocery shopping — with reusable bags — at the Waipahu Festival Market Place, formerly the old Big Way, which Aiona said has good fresh local produce. The Aionas also get food at Costco and Safeway, and cook three meals each day throughout the week, occasionally going out to a restaurant on weekends.
In addition to the reusable bags, the Aionas have recycled since the 1980s but don’t cash in their cans or bottles for HI-5, instead bringing them to bins at a nearby school, Aiona said. Curbside recycling just started recently, and green waste goes to a station in Kapolei. The family does not compost, he said.
“We just try to conserve as best we can. We try to turn the lights off and not waste water. Everyone’s conscious of that at home,” Aiona said. “More and more people now are conscious of being conservationists in regards to energy use and water use. They understand how limited we are with these resources and how pristine (Hawaii) is.
“We want to do our part too,” he said. “We’re all trying to lead by example.”
Civil Beat will take further steps to determine the kind of example the candidates are setting when it comes to water use and fuel-efficient, non-polluting vehicles. We will file requests with the Honolulu Board of Water Supply and Hawaii Department of Transportation to obtain the water usage records and registered vehicles at the primary residences of Abercrombie, Aiona and Hannemann.
DISCUSSION Do James “Duke” Aiona‘s personal sustainability choices set a good example for his fellow Hawaii residents? Join the conversation and learn more about the race for governor.
