But a measure in the Legislature would allow Honolulu to phase out short-term rentals over time.

The City and County of Honolulu spent countless hours battling owners of short-term vacation rentals over the city’s attempt to impose a 90-day minimum for short-term leases. Now, adding to the city’s stinging loss in federal court, where District Court Judge Derrick Watson struck down the Honolulu’s ordinance, there’s a legal bill coming due. 

The City Department of Planning and Permitting, corporation counsel, and other defendants have agreed to pay the Hawaii Legal Short-Term Rental Alliance $292,514.27 for attorneys’ fees and $619.07 costs, subject to the approval of the Honolulu City Council. 

Still, while Honolulu lost the battle, the war continues.

 A bill making its way through the Hawaii Senate would allow counties to phase out short-term vacation rentals over time: a move that could undermine the basis of Watson’s ruling, and let Honolulu go after vacation rentals again with increased legal ammunition. The measure passed out of a joint hearing by the Senate Committees on Commerce and Consumer Protection; Energy, Economic Development, and Tourism, and Public Safety and Intergovernmental and Military Affairs. Its next stop is a joint hearing of the Ways and Means and Judiciary committees.

If we don't do it, who will?

Every election has the potential to shape the future of Hawaiʻi.

Civil Beat provides the independent, in-depth reporting voters need to make informed decisions — not just campaign headlines, but rigorous reporting on candidates, policies and the issues that matter most.

Your support ensures this essential public service remains free and accessible to every voter, helping strengthen our democracy and hold those seeking power accountable.

About the Author