UPDATED 9/8/2011 4:40 p.m.

Editor’s Note: Civil Beat is in the midst of Fact Checking seven claims made by well-known opponents of rail in an opinion piece in the Aug. 21 edition of the Honolulu Star-Advertiser. One week later, rail proponents authored a response in those pages. This Fact Check stems from that story.

Honolulu’s traffic problems are cited as one of the main reasons to support the proposed rail project. Proponents say it will reduce future congestion versus the alternative of not doing anything, and they say that rail will provide an alternative for those who wish to avoid the roads altogether.

But did rail proponents — including Honolulu Mayor Peter Carlisle — overstate the current problems in a recent opinion piece in the pages of the Honolulu Star-Advertiser?

That piece was authored by Carlisle; retired banker Walter Dods; past Oahu president of Face Action for Community Equity Rev. Bob Nakata; Hawaii Carpenters Union executive Ron Taketa; GoRailGo! President Maeda Timson; and Pacific Resource Partnership chief John White. On the matter of today’s traffic levels, it makes the following claim:

(Rail opponents) failed to acknowledge the severity of Honolulu’s traffic congestion, which national studies show is among the worst in the nation. The 2010 INRIX Travel Time Tax study ranks Honolulu as the second-most congested city in the United States. Only Los Angeles fared worse.

The Hawaii Reporter quickly raised questions, spurred on by a letter from a reader and input from anti-rail mayoral candidate Panos Prevedouros. The issue was brought to Civil Beat’s attention by anti-rail leader Cliff Slater.

Hawaii Reporter reader Brian Barbata astutely pointed out that INRIX, a Washington state-based traffic services company, last year ranked Honolulu No. 37 in the country in its national congestion rank, not No. 2. So what do these numbers mean?

INRIX says that the number the proponents used is the better measure of congestion, because it describes driver experience and not just the total congestion in a region.

Asked which metric would be more appropriate for government officials to use when discussing the need for mass transit alternatives, INRIX spokesman Jim Bak said in a phone interview: “I think, honestly, they want to look at Travel Time Tax, because at the end of the day, their constituents, the driving public, that is a reflection of what they feel every day when they’re out on the roads.”

In an earlier email, Bak wrote that “Travel Time Tax equalizes all regions by dividing out the difference in the size of each region’s road network – giving a more driver centric view of congestion.”

The “National Congestion Rank” is a function of total congestion — meaning larger metro areas with higher populations and larger road networks tend to rank higher just by virtue of sheer volume.

For example, Los Angeles is the second largest metro area in the U.S. with nearly 13 million residents, and earns the No. 1 congestion slot. New York is the nation’s largest metro area, and ranks No. 2 by this metric. Chicago is both the third largest metro area and third worst in terms of total congestion. Honolulu, with 908,000 residents accounted for, was listed as the nation’s 55th largest metropolitan area.

The metric the city references, “Travel Time Tax,” is a function of how much time traffic delays add to normal travel. It’s a different way of describing which residents experience the worst traffic at peak hours, not just which city has the most people or most roads. By this metric, Los Angeles is still worst, but Honolulu comes in No. 2, with New York at No. 5 and Chicago at No. 10.

“A good analogy is power consumption – the amount of power consumed in each home is similar to the Travel Time Tax, while the amount of total power consumed in a region is similar to overall congestion,” Bak wrote. “Both measures – power used in each home (T3) and power used overall in the region (overall congestion) – are relevant and thus measured just one looks at it from a individual level, the other looks at it from a system level.”

In its methodology section, INRIX describes Travel Time Index as “the ratio of peak period travel time to free flow travel time.”

The TTI expresses the average amount of extra time it takes to travel in the peak relative to free-flow travel. A TTI of 1.3, for example, indicates a 20-minute free-flow trip will take 26 minutes during the peak travel time periods, 6-minute (30 percent) travel time tax (T3). For each road segment, a TTI is calculated for each hour of the week, using the formula TTI = RS/HS.

Highlighting the difference between the methodologies, Inrix also ranks the 100 most congested travel corridors and has separate columns for total minutes of delay and for Travel Time Tax. Honolulu’s H1 freeway — in particular, the 3.9-mile stretch from Nimitz Highway to Vineyard/Ward — ranks 61st worst in the country by the former metric, but 5th worst by the latter.

Barbata, the Hawaii Reporter reader, claims the city chose Travel Time Tax “apparently because it sounded dramatically more supportive.”

But there is no evidence to support that claim.

INRIX itself says Travel Time Tax is the superior metric to describe driver experience.

“The Travel Time Tax is a direct measure of what people experience every day on the roads,” company spokesman Jim Bak told Civil Beat. He said it’s “a better barometer of what people feel when they’re out there everyday.”

Los Angeles and Honolulu have nearly the same Travel Time Tax, Bak wrote. “This implies that an average commuter in both cities faces similar delays. However, Los Angeles has almost 15 times more people and 20 times more road miles of major highways. So at a system level, LA has much more overall congestion while individuals in both regions each experience similar congestion levels on the road.

“By that metric, Honolulu and Los Angeles are essentially the same, even though Los Angeles has 10 times as many residents and far more roads.”

“If you live in L.A. or you live in Honolulu, the amount of delay you experience is pretty much the same,” Bak said. “When you have government officials who are equating Honolulu to L.A., they’re looking at it from a driver’s point of view.”

INRIX’s rankings come not from projections or even from posted speed limits but instead from actual data produced by 30 million drivers nationwide. In Honolulu, that’s GPS-carrying commercial vehicles like taxis, airport shuttles and delivery trucks that provide “a true measure of the experience,” Bak said.

One of Barbata’s other criticisms of the proponents’ claim is that INRIX data shows Honolulu’s Travel Time Tax dropped from 38.9 percent in 2006 to 32.8 percent in 2010, a drop of 16 percent, meaning congestion has decreased in the last five years. (UPDATE: INRIX provided more information on this decline in traffic.1)

That’s for the city as a whole. The Travel Time Tax for the worst corridor of H1 is still 244 percent during the average afternoon rush hour (16 minutes versus five minutes during free-flow conditions.) During the worst hour of the week, between 5 p.m. and 6 p.m. on Thursdays, that same 3.9 miles takes drivers an average of 21 minutes — a Travel Time Tax of 356 percent. Though Barbata’s point — that traffic conditions are improving in Honolulu — might well still be valid.

Barbata’s complaints were buttressed by Prevedouros, who pointed to other metrics that he said undermine the claim that Honolulu’s traffic problem is particularly troublesome.

The Texas Transportation Institute’s congestion data for Honolulu shows that, as of 2009, our fair city ranked 49th nationally in terms of total person-hours of delay and 31st in delay per peak-hour commuter. Honolulu also ranked 25th in both Travel Time Index and Commuter Stress Index, according to that data. (UPDATE: INRIX provided more information on the difference between its study and the Texas Transportation Institute.2)

Bottom Line: The rail proponents cited a study that ranks Honolulu second-worst in the United States. The company that produced that study says the metric the proponents used is the best one to describe driver experience — better than an alternate figure that factors in the size of a city and ranks Honolulu 37th.

Opponents’ attack on the proponents’ use of the No. 2 ranking was unfounded.

However, opponents brought up other findings, both in the INRIX report and reports produced by other entities, that raise questions about the level of congestion in Honolulu. While the total person-hours measure isn’t relevant, for the same reason as the National Congestion rank, the other measures may have validity.

By at least two key metrics, Honolulu’s traffic is among the worst in the country. Other metrics from another company rank it lower. Therefore, we find the claim that Honolulu’s traffic is among the worst in the nation to be Mostly True.


Here are the related Fact Checks from the opponents’ piece:


1. The day after this story originally published, INRIX spokesman Jim Bak explained the decline in traffic in an email to Civil Beat:

Regarding opponents arguments that traffic has gotten better the last few years according to the report, that is true. However, I would like to point out that this shift is based on the entire country seeing a 30 percent drop in traffic congestion during this period due to the Great Recession. As people lost their jobs, there were less people going to work. Also, people also had less disposable income and were in turn spending less and taking less expensive vacations (i.e. not traveling to locales like Hawaii) also contributing to this drop.

In talking about the change, we advised transportation agencies that they were experiencing a traffic holiday that as the economy started to recover and people returned to work, we would see traffic congestion go back on the rise. While it’s too soon to tell how 2011 will fare, we did see a slight uptick in 2010 – the first since the precipitous drop in 2008 when the economy collapsed as a result of the real estate crisis.

↩

2. The day after this story originally published, INRIX spokesman Jim Bak explained the difference between his company’s study and the Texas Transportation Institute:

We know Texas Transportation Institute very well. Those guys have been doing this research for 20+ years now and recently started using our data for their report. They’re great guys. Two things to consider when looking at TTI’s Urban Mobility Report:

1) The data is a year old. Their most recent report was for 2009 traffic, our most recent is for 2010 (what the Mayor was referencing). When TTI publishes their next urban mobility report (heads up: its scheduled for mid October so you can expect another news cycle on the traffic in Honolulu debate J), they will be looking at 2010.

2) However, despite the timeframe differences between our two reports, you might ask, “How can they still be different given they use INRIX data too? A fair question. Well, TTI adds one other factor into the mix when they do analysis – volumes. They get volume data from the FHWA that they use to weight their rankings. Thus, what you see from them in their rankings is much more aligned with our “Congestion” rankings vs. our Travel Time Tax rankings.

Net: Our INRIX Scorecard is most focused on providing insights that highlights the pure driver experience when they’re on the roads vs. TTI that focuses more on the societal costs around traffic in a given city factoring in traffic volumes on roads in their analysis as well as traffic flow (speed of travel) that they get using INRIX data. This allows them to analyze traffic from the pov of amount of fuel wasted in traffic, amount of carbon emitted as a result of traffic, etc.

From our pov, once a road reaches maximum capacity (supporting all the volume it can handle at a given time), volume weighting becomes less relevant as the situation doesn’t change much for drivers. At a certain point, gridlock is gridlock regardless of how many vehicles are trying to travel the road network. Thus, traffic congestion is still just as intense to drivers in L.A. as it is in Honolulu regardless of how big the road network is and how much traffic volume it can support.

↩

Michael Levine is a former Civil Beat staff member.