I am a journalist.
I am a journalist who teaches others to do journalism.
I believe good journalism makes us all better citizens.
I say all this because I want you to know that I am not exaggerating when I say that the future of good journalism in Hawaii is in peril.
The Legislature is moving a bill that would dismantle the “shield law” that protects journalists from having to disclose their sources of information. HB 622 began as a simple housekeeping measure to repeal the “sunset” provision of the law that passed the Legislature unanimously in 2008. That law was a product of compromise between news media representatives and then Attorney General Mark Bennett and gave meaning to our state’s commitment to the free flow of information in the 21st Century by protecting “traditional” and “non-traditional” journalists who gather and report on information of public concern.
Now, state Sen. Clayton Hee, chair of the Judiciary Committee, together with the current Attorney General are proposing amendments to gut the shield law. In an Orwellian twist, they would make one of the strongest laws in the country protecting press rights into one that threatens all forms of legitimate newsgathering in this state.
Don’t worry, Hee recently told Civil Beat, you’re protected. But are you? His amendments certainly create enough doubts. And even if Civil Beat is protected, such protections that Hee offers are riddled with exceptions that make them useless.
Hee provides no justification for these draconian measures unless you believe, as he does, that the Chicago Tribune’s 1948 headline that “Dewey Defeats Truman” was an unforgiveable sin of the press. Oh, and he did once say that he had problems with “anonymous bloggers”… whoever they are? Absent relevant examples, we’re left to conclude that Hee is more interested in petty pay back against the press because of criticism he’s endured during his public life and perceived personal slights.
I remember a time when there was tough-minded reporting by the likes of Honolulu Advertiser reporter Gene Hunter who did exposes on organized crime in Hawaii. And investigative reports by the likes of Jim Dooley and Matt Levi gave meaning to “watchdog journalism.” We don’t have enough of that kind of reporting. In some ways, we’re afraid of it because it can be time-consuming, costly and may lead to litigation. But, as sociologist Paul Starr says, studies have shown “corruption flourishes where journalism does not.” Hee and Attorney General David Louie clearly aren’t interested in journalism flourishing beyond reports of traffic and weather.
They say that the shield law now goes too far by including those the Attorney General paints with a broad brush as “bloggers.” After all, they say, no other state protects “bloggers.” Even though most other state laws were written before there were such pesky technology as the Internet or social media. So Hee is embracing the Attorney General’s position that you’re only a journalist if you’re a corporate journalist. That’s shortsighted.
We need and we should encourage good journalism in all forms, recognizing that it is not only done within the four walls of a newsroom. Technology has broadened our capacity to gather and disseminate information. Each of us now has the ability to engage in what the pamphleteers and publishers did when the First Amendment was written into our Constitution two centuries ago. For those reasons, I believe it is imperative that we maintain protections for all forms of journalism that advances the goals of an informed public.
Simply stated a journalist is a person who gathers information for the purpose of disseminating it to the public.
Now does this mean that anyone who owns a computer or a video camera or sets up a social media site is a journalist? No.
It means that citizens informed about their community, their government, and their future well being can engage in civic life in a way they never could when only the owner of the printing press or a broadcast license determined what we heard, saw or read. The instinctive reaction to only treat members of the traditional news organizations as journalists while everyone else is viewed derisively as a “blogger” is wrongheaded and a denial of our First Amendment heritage. As the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals once famously said, “what makes journalism journalism is not it form but its content.”
In the final analysis, our focus on who is a journalist is misguided. The shield law is not about protecting journalists—traditional or otherwise—some of whom we may like personally or politically, others we may not. The underlying public policy of this law is to encourage sources, whistleblowers, for example, to disclose truthful information to the public so that the public will have full access to information it needs to meaningfully engage in the life of the community. The shield law is about fighting public apathy.
I’ve heard the concerns that the law is subject to abuse. Well, it’s worked for the past five years without any abuse. It’s been subject to review by the Judiciary’s Evidence Committee. The law now provides a reasonable means of reviewing all claims of privilege under the law. The courts know the relevant statutes and the original legislative intent, and, as they do in other areas of the law, they can distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate claims for protection.
I’ve been involved with journalism in Hawaii most of my life. I am convinced that we must give meaning to the idea of a free flow of information and the public’s right to know. I believe the shield law does that. It encourages sources to reveal truthful information they have of public concern and encourages the kind of aggressive journalism we need in this town.
I hope you agree with me, and I hope you will join in the fight against changes to the law and for final passage of a bill that does one simple thing — put firmly in place the shield law we already have. There’s a lot at stake for the press and the public.
In this fight, we’re all journalists.
Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many topics of community interest. It’s kind of a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-eds. This is your space to talk about important issues or interesting people who are making a difference in our world. Columns generally run about 800 words (yes, they can be shorter or longer) and we need a photo of the author and a bio. We welcome video commentary and other multimedia formats. Send to news@civilbeat.com.
