Being green is not a simple yes or no.
Republican Gov. candidate John Carroll stands apart from the frontrunners. He’s been a farmer and a rancher, but admits that his Big Island home is a “disaster” for alternative energy.
Responding to Civil Beat requests to open their homes so we could compare and contrast their personal environmental practices against their professed policy platforms, former Honolulu Mayor Mufi Hannemann declined the proposal; former U.S. Rep. Neil Abercrombie answered some of our questions; and Lt. Gov. James “Duke” Aiona sat down for a face-to-face interview.
Carroll answered the same questions that were posed to the other candidates, and also agreed to a meeting, this time at Civil Beat’s Kaimuki office. He invited us to his Big Island home, though he said it might not be worth the flight, saying “it’s just that my good intentions didn’t match my actions.”
Carroll has posted his positions on some issues on his campaign website. His economy platform includes a passage on agriculture: “Agriculture and Aquaculture are vital components for Hawaii’s economy. This is a sector of our economy that must no longer be ignored. Major tracks [sic] of arable land need to be dedicated by the state for agricultural leases. State laws must protect our farmers and promote farming in Hawaii.”
On the environment, Carroll’s website states: “The stewardship of our precious environment is not a part-time job. The practice of neglecting our canals, streams and ocean with pollution, like sewage spills, has become common place. As a state legislator, I fought to preserve and protect our environment. As governor, I will not tolerate continued abuse of our canals, streams, ocean and lands.”
Carroll had just finished his decade in the Hawaii Legislature when he turned to farming in 1980.
He had three Big Island acres of cucumber and another three acres of zucchini that he farmed professionally in the few years that followed. Since then, he’s raised anywhere between three and 13 cattle at a time for local slaughter. He still eats the beef and shares it with friends; he says just one cow can provide enough beef for two and a half years.
“I intended to practice law and farm simultaneously,” Carroll said last week in an interview. He said he also owned turkeys, geese, ducks, pheasants, four or five varieties of chicken, rabbits, pigs, sheep and goats. “They used to call me Noah.”
In an effort to understand Carroll’s efforts to be green in his personal life, Civil Beat sent him an e-mail with the same questions that were posed to the other gubernatorial candidates.1
Q: What car(s) do you drive? Year, Make, Model.
A: Two cars… Both SUV’s… One a 2007 Dodge Durango 4 wheel drive, farm use primarily. The one on this island is a 2008 Chev. Equinox, it replaced a 2002 PT Cruiser which I gave to a friend. As soon as I can afford it I will buy an electric car. I currently represent (legal representation) HIEV, (Hawaii Electric Vehicles, a start up who do wind, solar and electric vehicles)
Q: Please give us copies of your electric bill from the past three months. When we visit your house, we’d like to see any special efforts you’ve made to reduce energy consumption or to produce energy, such as solar hot water, solar power, energy efficient appliances or energy efficient lighting. Do you use a clothes dryer or a clothes line? If you have installed any solar panels or energy efficient appliances at your home, please explain what they are, when they were installed and how much energy they save.
A: My home on the big island is a disaster as far as alternative energy is concerned. I started to do a wind generating system, $35,000 and couldn’t afford it. Put in a heat transfer type solar system for the swimming pool, but the electric costs for the pump, plus a hurricane destroying about half of the array wreaked havoc with that plan. I have intended to put up solar panels and just didn’t get around to it.
Q: Do you grow any of your own food? If so, what do you grow? How big is your garden?
A: I do raise my own cattle for consumption only. Usually keep about three head on the property. There are some cattle in the pasture now, but they are not mine, I’m allowing a friend of mine to utilize the pasture.
I did raise cucumbers and zucchini commercially but haven’t done much in the way of vegetable farming since the 80’s when I started raising cattle. I have raised animals such as chickens, ducks, geese, rabbits, turkeys, pheasants, sheep and goats.
Q: Please give us copies of your water bill from the past three months. Do you use any water efficient toilets or shower heads? Do you have a sprinkler system? How much lawn do you have? Do you use any drip irrigation?
A: Currently, I am on Oahu seven days a week, just go home Saturday, play soccer in the Makule league on Sunday and back here Sunday night. My electric bill has been running over $350.00 per month and my water bill about $28.00 per month. I picked Ahualoa, area above Honokaa, 2500 foot elevation, because of the rain and fog which prevails there. That is why the water bill is so low. I have no sprinklers or even irrigation mechanisms.
Q: Do you recycle? Do you compost? Do you own reusable grocery bags? Do you buy bottled water or do you use a water filter?
A: I do use cloth bags for what shopping I do. I use tap water to drink, though my office staff bring in bottled water and one partner here has provided a “water” source… 5 gallon plastic bottle which I don’t, personally use.
I don’t compost now because I’m not raising any vegetables, but would if I ever farm again. I recycle if there are centers available. Because I am on this island so much I create very little in the way of recyclable waste.
Q: Where do you buy your groceries? Are you a member of any Community Supported Agriculture enterprise? Do you frequent farmer’s markets?
A: I do go to the Farmers Market in Hilo and Waimea if I have time. Most of the time I eat at restaurants because I am not married, live alone and rarely have an inclination to cook.
When I buy groceries it is usually at the USAF Commissary on Oahu. On the Big Isle, if I can, Hilo, Honokaa or Waimea Farmers Markets.
My biggest gripe right now, and a major thrust of my campaign is to cure the economic ills that plague Hawaii’s farmers and ranchers. The absence of fresh milk and dairy products along with the absurd cost of foods, 90 percent of which are shipped in from the mainland via Matson and Horizon is totally unacceptable to me and is one of the main reasons I’m running for the governorship.
I have fought to eliminate the Jones Act restrictions on shipping which, along with labor costs have killed agriculture as a major component of Hawaii’s economy. I have represented, pro bono, Waipio Taro Farmers and have been active in Hawaii Saddle Club activities, etc.
Carroll’s biggest policy platform is his opposition to the Merchant Marine Act of 1920. The section of the act known as the Jones Act requires that all goods transported by water between U.S. ports be carried in ships that were constructed in the U.S., fly U.S. flags, and are owned, operated and crewed by U.S. citizens. Carroll says the law, today supported by unions and American shipping companies because it reduces competition, drives up the cost of goods for all Hawaii citizens.
“I would file a class action (lawsuit against the federal government) on behalf of every citizen of this state that does not opt out because we are all hurt by this law,” he said at Civil Beat’s office. He would direct the attorney general to gather evidence of the economic damage wrought because Hawaii — as well as Alaska and Guam — are geographically isolated from the mainland U.S. and have fewer options to send and receive goods.
“The whole key to my campaign is we need to have food production here,” he said. And getting rid of the Jones act would open up Asian markets to Hawaii produce like mango and papaya.
Asked if he thinks he has a chance to top Aiona in the Republican primary next month, Carroll says “absolutely” and that “I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t.” He pointed to mismanagement of the Superferry’s environmental assessment and the implementation of school furloughs instead of cutting funding for non-essential school personnel as examples of what he could fix. He’s still got plenty of energy at 81; he now spends nearly all his time on Oahu practicing law, though he flies back to the Big Island once a week to play in a soccer league.
“This kind of idiocy on the part of our leaders is what made me want to run,” he said. Carroll once believed that “fish, milk and politicians have a shelf life, and mine has clearly expired,” but he wants to keep working to make Hawaii a better place.
“If I shuffle off this mortal coil and don’t do what I was meant to do, I don’t think I could ever rest in peace.”
DISCUSSION What do you think of John Carroll’s attempts at clean energy and policy position on the Jones Act? Join the conversation and learn more about the race for Hawaii governor.
-
Each of the answers provided by Carroll were taken verbatim from e-mails, though the paragraphs were alternated and organized by Civil Beat to give clarity to readers.
↩
