This week at Civil Beat I noticed that elections stir up a lot of discussion. Lines are drawn in the sand, statements are made and questioned and people choose sides. Sometimes people even jump over lines they’ve drawn and choose a different side. Sometimes they may even jump back.

That is why our Fact Checks are so critical. The conversations and debates that are happening on Civil Beat are the beginnings of what we hoped for when we started — civil discussions about the critical topics affecting Hawaii today. Fact Checks allow for an even playing field, and they provide transparency so that our audience can make intelligent decisions about a candidate or an issue. They also help to develop further conversation around those issues, like when Honolulu mayoral candidate Kirk Caldwell stated that the Hawaii Constitution Bans Nuclear Power.

Civil Beat’s Robert Brown investigated the statement, stamped it ‘False’ and invited the Hawaii community to chime in:

Nuclear Power in Hawaii

“It’s effectively a ban because the nearly impossible hurdle of a supermajority reflects the opinion of the people, which lacking evidence to the contrary, is decidedly against nuclear power. Putting Caldwell’s statement in context, he appears to be anti-nuke; his mayoral race opponent Panos Prevedouros is decidedly pro-nuke and therefore out of step with popular opinion again.”

“I hope everyone realizes that Prevedorous will likely achieve nothing more than drawing Hawai’i into the ‘Nuclear Free and Independent Pacific’ campaign. I note that the ‘Pacific Concerns and Resource Centre’ in Fiji is currently studying the ‘State of Militarization’ in the Pacific.”

Read the complete comment.

“It’s hardly a ban on nuclear power generation when we have well over 20 submarine reactors humming away at Pearl Harbor, not to mention visiting carriers, cruisers, and other nuclear-powered ships. A campaign to create a nuclear-free Hawaii would immediately run into a U.S. naval blockade.”

Hawaii Governor’s Race – Policy Papers

When gubernatorial candidate Neil Abercrombie introduced what he calls a comprehensive plan to solve Hawaii’s problems, Civil Beat members discussed the issues that he and his opposing candidates outlined.

“I appreciate it when candidates come out with policy papers. In the 70’s even into the 80’s these were big factors in elections. So I was glad that Abercrombie’s was so detailed, and also that Aiona’s piece was clear as well. Mufi’s however was pretty light. If Hannemann loses this primary with the enormous advantage in $ it will (be) because of things like this – he is running a content free campaign.”

“I agree with Andrew regarding the value of policy papers, and for the benefit of voters, I’ve attempted to compare Mufi’s one-page economic action plan with Neil’s 43-page comprehensive plan. Both want economic diversification, job creation, and better schools. But Abercrombie’s plans for high-tech and educational improvements resulted in endorsements from the Hawaii Venture Capital Association as well as the teachers and professors unions.”

“Both support rail, infrastructure improvements, and reconsidering the Superferry. But Abercrombie has more detailed plans to reduce our dependence on imported energy and food, and is stronger on environmental protection, resulting in the Sierra Club endorsement. Both support tourism, but Abercrombie emphasizes “sustainable” tourism and also has a plan for small business development.

Read the complete comment.

  • Alah Sarhan chimed in with his thoughts. It would appear that he wants to hear more from all the candidates before he chooses a side:

“…I don’t see anything from any of the candidates that promises anything but business as usual. Duke is congratulating himself on what Lingle has done to shelter the homeless (for which she does deserve a lot of credit) and has some vague idea that better education and less government (along with some unspecified thing about crime?) will someday bring wages in line with housing costs.

“Mufi takes a hit for clearing the homeless out of the parks, ironically from those who complain about the homeless being in the parks. (Neil would let them stay in the parks?)”

“That leaves Neil, who will do a lot of “sitting down with…” about the problem, and do something through public-private partnerships. We already have more people than you can shake a stick at sitting down about the problem. How about tripling funding to the Rental Housing Trust Fund and Dwelling Unit Revolving Fund, to get those imagined public-private partnerships off the ground?”

  • Civil Beat Reporter-Host Chad Blair appreciated the feedback, but speculated on the number of voters who were taking notice:

“What I am wondering, from both you, Andrew, Joannie and others, is if many voters will take the time to read the position papers. You appear to have done just that, of course, which bodes well for democracy.”

I believe the continued analysis and discussion of who the candidates are and what they stand for bodes well for democracy, and for Hawaii. The more in touch we are with what is happening on our islands, the more we can be a part of the change that we deem necessary.