Tuesday might have been the Honolulu City Council‘s final opportunity to criticize the city’s handling of trash that was supposed to be shipped to the mainland. If it doesn’t get another crack at it, the Council certainly didn’t waste the chance.

A routine public infrastructure committee meeting turned into a virtual public flaying of the mayoral administrations of Mufi Hannemann and Kirk Caldwell. City councilmembers, themselves blamed publicly for the trash fiasco, lashed out at Environmental Services Director Tim Steinberger, raking him over the coals for the city’s mishandling of 20,000 tons of solid waste.

The garbage has been piling up on a West Oahu industrial lot after a deal to ship the trash to Washington state fell through. A week ago, Caldwell announced an agreement to dump the trash here in Hawaii.

The original contract called for Hawaiian Waste Systems to send up to 100,000 tons of refuse annually to Washington for three years at a cost to city taxpayers of roughly $100 per ton. Steinberger explained that the new deal — which has been agreed to in principal but not yet formally settled — would instead pay Hawaiian Waste Systems around $50 per ton to sort the trash, divert about 70 percent of it to the H-POWER waste-to-energy facility and truck the balance to the Waimanalo Gulch landfill.

The new arrangement looks to be a boon for Hawaiian Waste Systems. The fledgling company would be allowed to transform a failed business model into one that will make its Campbell Industrial Park property a de facto materials recovery facility — and the only one on the island that can shred large municipal solid waste like mattresses and couches into combustible fuel.

But councilmembers charged that the administration is essentially letting Hawaiian Waste Systems off the hook after they failed to make good on their end of the deal. And while Steinberger portrayed the new arrangement as a money-saver, those savings come with a cost: more trash in the local landfill.

The dramatic change in plans led Council Chair Todd Apo, who’s not on the infrastructure committee but attended the meeting anyway, to muse that Hawaiian Waste Systems could serve as “fuel storage” when H-POWER is down for maintenance. Rather than being sent to the landfill, the trash can be baled until the burner is back up and running.

Best of all, or worst, depending on your perspective, the company won’t have to pay the penalties it faced for failing to meet its obligations under the original contract. Asked by infrastructure committee Chair Ann Kobayashi if the penalties would be levied, Steinberger said the company is “insolvent” and there’s no point in seeking money from an entity that’s broke. This, and the fear of being mired in court, was the same reasoning that has deterred the city from filing suit against the waste hauler.

Kobayashi and others pressed Steinberger, asking if the company could pay its penalties by bartering its services. And asked why the city would enter into a contract with an insolvent company, Steinberger said he’s gotten personal assurances from the Henriques family of Rolloffs Hawaii, a company that’s an investor in Hawaiian Waste Systems.

“If they do not perform, they do not get paid,” Steinberger said, apparently referring to the proposed contract. He didn’t mention that they are set to be paid under their existing contract — despite failing to perform their services.

Because the new arrangement is merely an amendment to an existing city contract — not a cancellation and brand new contract — the council’s approval is not required, Steinberger said.

Kobayashi and Councilman Romy Cachola — another non-voting member of the committee — took turns hammering Steinberger. Cachola eventually said he hoped the public understood that it was the Hannemann and Caldwell administrations, and not the City Council, that was to blame for the situtation. Steinberger shot back, saying that the administration is trying to keep the situation out of the national and international news because associating Honolulu with piles of trash will hurt tourism.

Steinberger was also called to testify on a number of different items, as the committee deferred action on proposed legislation regarding plastic bags [pdf] and construction waste [pdf]. The committee recommended that the full council approve resolutions establishing a natural resources and quality of life policy [pdf] and a zero waste task force [pdf]. At one point he joked that if he was going to spend that much time talking to the Council, he should consider joining.

Kobayashi quipped that there was a new vacancy, nodding in the direction of Apo, who attended the meeting just hours after announcing his resignation from office to work for Disney’s Ko Olina resort — right across the highway from the landfill.


DISCUSSION Should the city charge Hawaiian Waste Systems penalties for failing to fulfill the original contract and tipping fees for disposing of the trash? Join the conversation and learn more about solid waste in Hawaii.

Michael Levine is a former Civil Beat staff member.