Hawaii has more than 1.3 million residents, but sometimes it can feel like a very small place.

A recent meeting of the Honolulu Zoning Board of Appeals was surely one of those times. Of the five board members asked to evaluate the merits of a controversial hotel redevelopment in Waikiki, two recused themselves after disclosing direct connections to the hotelier and a third may yet be disqualified after the Honolulu Ethics Commission weighs in.

The proposal in question would replace the existing Diamond Head Tower attached to the historic Moana Surfrider hotel. The Honolulu Department of Planning and Permitting has given Kyo-ya, owner of the Surfrider as well as the Royal Hawaiian and Sheraton Waikiki, the green light for a tower some 300 feet tall.

But the last approval has been challenged. Honolulu Planning Director David Tanoue in December granted partial approval of a zoning variance that would allow the new tower to violate the city’s shoreline height setback rule. Environmental opponents appealed the decision to the Zoning Board of Appeals, where it now sits.

At the April 21 meeting, Board Chair David Minkin disclosed that his law firm, McCorriston Miller Mukai MacKinnon LLP, represents Kyo-ya. Board member Susana Berardy also disclosed a conflict. Her husband Joe on Monday told Civil Beat that the company they run — DBI Hawaii Inc. — has provided Hawaiian quilts and other bedding to Kyo-ya.

Both recused themselves from further deliberations, according to both Tanoue and Hawaii’s Thousand Friends Executive Director Donna Wong. A voicemail left for Minkin Monday was not returned.

Even without Minkin and Berardy, the board would still have a quorum and be able to adjudicate the matter. But a third board member — Herb Chock — also raised the possibility of a conflict, and awaits an answer from the Honolulu Ethics Commission.

Chock and his associates operate a construction and engineering consulting firm that has worked with Kyo-ya in the past.

“We have done some construction management work for the Moana Hotel in their restoration and their maintenance,” Chock told Civil Beat Monday. “This was several years ago. The project is now complete. That is the extent of my relationship with Kyo-Ya, to my knowledge. And I disclosed that at the meeting.”

He said the value of the contract was “probably under $100,000” because he would have remembered more details if it was a larger deal.

He also said he doesn’t think the years-old contract would prevent him from performing his duties for the board and that he expects the Ethics Commission will agree with him.

“They might make another determination given their review of the facts and the circumstances surrounding my involvement, but my opinion is that I can be impartial and neutral,” he said. “My staff is now gathering all the factual material on that contract and any other contracts, if they exist, and we’ll forward it to Corp Counsel for presentation to the Ethics Commission.”

Chock said his firm has also done work for the City and County of Honolulu and that he’s even ruled against some clients that have come before the board.

“You have to call it like you see it,” he said.

Tanoue said the city is requesting an advisory opinion from the Ethics Commission “out of an abundance of caution.”

Ethics Commission Executive Director and Legal Counsel Charles Totto said Monday he’d yet to receive any written notifications of a conflict of interest from the Zoning Board of Appeals on the matter. He said the amount of time that’s passed since Chock and Kyo-ya did business and the financial value of their relationship would be factors in determining if there’s a conflict.

“At this point, there’s no hard and fast rule. We’d take a hard look at the cases we’ve had in the past that’s similar to that and the opinions we’ve given in the past on these issues,” he said. “It really is pretty common sense to see what type of relationship it is.”

The Ethics Commission has published what it calls “The Plain Language Guide to the City Ethics Laws.” It warns that officials “are not permitted to participate in or take any discretionary action directly affecting a business or other matter … if you were a member of a firm which rendered services directly related to the matter.”

It’s unclear whether that applies to Chock.

If Chock is found to have a conflict of interest and instructed to recuse himself from further deliberations, that would leave the board without a quorum.

Deputy Corporation Counsel Dawn Spurlin told Civil Beat that Section 3-1.2 [pdf] of the Revised Ordinances of Honolulu empowers Mayor Peter Carlisle to pick a temporary replacement to work on just this case.

Complicating matters is that both Chock and Berardy see their terms expire June 30 and both Minkin and Board Vice Chair Ronald Ogomori are already holdovers from prior terms. Carlisle could quickly shape the board in his image and has the power to stack it with enough development proponents or opponents to swing the board’s decision. (Ultimately, this matter could end up in court, no matter who prevails at the Zoning Board of Appeals.)

Tanoue told Civil Beat that the administration has already started the process of selecting replacement members.

For now, everything is on hold.

Wong — the environmentalist whose Hawaii Thousand Friends group is among four entities challenging the approval — said the April 21 meeting was supposed to decide on who could intervene, and the May 19 meeting was supposed to be the start of a contested case.

Spurlin said the board’s next meeting won’t have the Kyo-ya matter on the agenda. As of Monday, she had yet to complete he work on the request to the Ethics Commission.

Michael Levine is a former Civil Beat staff member.