Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton has published a forthright appeal that should gladden the hearts of those, Americans and Asians alike, who believe that a sustained U.S. commitment to Asia is essential to the security and prosperity of both sides of the Pacific.
Testing Clinton’s vision began here last week with a gathering of senior military officers from 27 Asia-Pacific nations and will continue next month during the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum hosted by President Barack Obama. Another test will come later when the president attends an East Asia summit in Indonesia.
With the U.S. drawing down in Iraq and Afghanistan and with serious economic challenges at home, some Americans “seek a downsizing of our foreign engagement,” Clinton said in a comprehensive essay in Foreign Policy magazine. “These impulses are understandable, but they are misguided.”
“Those who say that we can no longer afford to engage with the world have it exactly backward — we cannot afford not to,” she asserted. “Our work abroad holds the key to our prosperity and security at home. For more than six decades, the United States has resisted the gravitational pull of these “come home” debates.”
“We must do so again,” she said.
“In Asia, they ask whether we are really there to stay, whether we are likely to be distracted again by events elsewhere, whether we can make — and keep — credible economic and strategic commitments, and whether we can back those commitments with action,” she wrote in the November issue.
“The answer is: We can, and we will.”
Clinton’s stance immediately raised questions at home and in Asia. Even while applauding Clinton’s thoughts, several commentators wondered whether President Obama agreed, whether the U.S. was willing to spend what was needed to sustain the commitment, and whether Americans had the necessary political will.
The editors of Foreign Policy asked several commentators for their thoughts.
Daniel Twining, formerly with the State Department’s policy planning staff, said a hard question “is whether the Obama administration is committed to maintaining a favorable balance of power in the Asia-Pacific — without which Clinton’s many laudable objectives will be impossible to meet.”
Richard McGregor, Washington bureau chief of Britain’s Financial Times, asked: “Can the United States afford to make a substantially greater commitment to Asia at a time of ballooning deficits?”
Minxin Pei, a China-born scholar at Claremont McKenna College, cautioned: “With the American political establishment becoming more inward-looking, the political capital needed for bold foreign-policy initiatives is in short supply.”
In China, the People’s Daily published by the ruling Communist Party, brushed off Clinton’s appeal as lacking something new. The paper asserted that the U.S. “should learn to get along with China” and “may extort more money from Asian countries in the name of protection and even stir up trouble by playing dirty tricks.”
From Taiwan, the self-governing island claimed by China, came a plaintive note that Clinton had not mentioned Taiwan. The Taipei Times, an English language newspaper, said “most other Asian countries are named at some point,” with special attention to hot-spots such as the South China Sea and to economic issues.
In Honolulu, the U.S. commitment to security in Asia was reflected in a four-day meeting of the chiefs of defense staffs in this region. Admiral Robert Willard, who commands U.S. forces in the Pacific and Asia, said the topic was maritime security and a vast majority agreed that was best considered in a multilateral forum.
The roster of those who showed up and those who didn’t underscored how far the U.S. must go to reach Clinton’s goals. A senior officer from Vietnam evinced the cautious reconciliation between the U.S. and Vietnam. A senior Russian officer showed a continuing building of working relations with the U.S.
China, considered by many Asians and Americans to be a potential adversary, did not send a delegation — but a Chinese admiral came as an individual speaker. Nor did India, with which U.S. relations blow hot and cold, send a delegation — but a retired admiral came as an individual speaker.
The APEC meeting here next month will be a test for President Obama. Delegations from 20 nations will scrutinize his every move to see whether he has any interest in foreign policy, whether for Asia or anywhere else. Skeptics maintain that he is overly concerned with the economy — and his re-election in 2012.
Perhaps Secretary Clinton had that in mind when she wrote: “There should be no doubt that America has the capacity to secure and sustain our global leadership in this century as we did in the last.”
