As President Obama embarked on a long excursion to promote a new U.S. strategy in Asia and the Pacific, his first public words here on Saturday morning were: “The United States wants to send a clear message: We are a Pacific nation and we are deeply committed to shaping the future security and prosperity of the Trans-Pacific region.”

The president has a full schedule through Sunday evening in meetings with delegations of 20 nations from China to Chile here for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum. Then he leaves Tuesday for Australia, a steadfast American ally, and for Indonesia to be the first U.S. president to take part in an East Asian Summit.

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, who arrived in Hawaii earlier to set the stage for what she called the administration’s “extensive engagement” with Asia and the Pacific, continued on Friday to expound the theme she set out at the East-West Center on Thursday.

“As the war in Iraq ends and we transition [to Afghan forces] in Afghanistan,” she said, “U.S. foreign policy is moving toward the Asia Pacific. We need to be smart and systematic about where we invest time and energy to put ourselves in the best position to sustain our leadership, secure our interests, and advance our values.”

Mr. Obama and Mrs. Clinton have thus positioned their administration squarely among the internationalists, sometimes called interventionists, who have dominated U.S. foreign and security policy ever since World War II, no matter which political party was in power in Washington.

There are, however, competing points of view, namely retreating into isolation or pulling back in retrenchment, with advocates across the political spectrum.

A prominent internationalist was President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, a Democrat, who, after two decades of isolationism, led the nation through World War II and left his imprint on U.S. foreign policy. President Ronald Reagan, a Republican, trod much the same path as he led the nation through the final stages of the Cold War in the 1980s.

At the opposite pole have been the isolationists who have a long tradition with roots that go back to George Washington and his caution that the nation not be caught in “entangling alliances.” Isolationists would have the U.S. retreat to Fortress America behind the Atlantic and Pacific moats.

Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the Republican candidate for president in 2008, has been quoted: “There’s always been an isolationist strain in the Republican Party, the Pat Buchanan wing of our party. But now it seems to have moved more center stage.” Patrick Buchanan, the conservative columnist, was a third party candidate in 2000.

Ross Baker, a political scientist at Rutgers University in New Jersey, has written that for some liberal Democrats, “any dispatch of U.S. troops into combat invites comparisons to the Vietnam War. They call for money currently devoted to the military to be applied to domestic programs.”

Relatively new on the scene are those who advocate retrenchment, cutting back on military deployments abroad while encouraging or demanding that allies in Europe and Asia pick up a greater share of the burden for the common defense.

Although Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta has not called for retrenchment in so many words, his statements suggest it is on his mind. In testimony before the House Armed Services Committee last month, he said the U.S. faces “a turning point with regard to the military.”

As the U.S. withdraws from Iraq and Afghanistan, he said, the Pentagon is “facing a new fiscal reality.” In the debt ceiling agreement reached by Congress in August, he said, “the department must find more than $450 billion in savings over the next decade.”

“We absolutely have to avoid a hollow force and maintain a military that even if smaller will be ready, agile and deployable,” he asserted. “It demands a balanced approach, and we have to look at all areas of the budget for potential savings.”

Missing from President Obama, Secretary Clinton, Secretary Panetta, and the Joint Chiefs of Staff is a call for the allies to assume more responsibility for the collective defense. Behind the scenes, however, defense officials, diplomats, and military officers privately contend that the U.S. needs to persuade allies to do more.

A favorite gauge is the percentage of gross national product, an annual measure of wealth, that each nation spends on defense. The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute says its most recent figures put the U.S. at 4.7 percent.

In Europe, the British, French, and Germans, which are allies in NATO, each spend between 1.4 percent and 2.7 percent. In Asia, the Philippines spends 0.8 percent and Japan, Thailand, Taiwan, and South Korea each spend 1 percent to 2.9 percent.

In sum, American taxpayers are subsidizing the defense of allied nations.

Two scholars, Joseph Parent of the University of Miami and Paul Macdonald of Wellesley College, wrote earlier this month: “The United States can no longer afford a world-spanning foreign policy. Retrenchment—cutting military spending, redefining foreign priorities, and shifting more of the defense burden to allies—is the only sensible course.”

“Luckily,” they argued, “that does not have to spell instability abroad. History shows that pausing to recharge national batteries can renew a dominant power’s international legitimacy.”

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...