Multiple Honolulu City Council meetings, hours upon hours of impassioned public testimony, and today a press conference with Mayor Peter Carlisle.
You might think that’d be enough to figure out how the controversial ban on storing personal belongings on public spaces will be implemented.
But many questions remain unanswered. For example:
How will the city decide where and when to enforce the law?
What happens when an offender attempts to thwart the city by removing or denying posted notice, or moves their belongings?
How will the city keep track of whose stuff is whose once it’s all in storage at a Department of Facility Maintenance baseyard?
Carlisle signed Bill 54 into law Friday afternoon. It takes effect immediately, and Carlisle said enforcement will begin “as soon as practical.” City attorneys are working out the language of the notice that will be posted on abandoned or stored items in city parks and on city sidewalks.
Proponents of the measure have repeatedly said it was designed to clear public spaces so that the public at large could enjoy them. But it’s been criticized as an attack on the homeless who are the most likely to leave belongings on a sidewalk or set up camp in a park. The ban may also have the effect of forcing out the Occupy Honolulu protesters who have taken over part of Thomas Square, at the corner of Beretania and Ward.
The basic mechanics of what happens next — what Carlisle called the “nuts and bolts” — are clear enough.
City officials will need to document when they come across items that are stored or abandoned in a public place. After 24 hours, those items become illegal, and the city will post or furnish notice of the violation. After another 24 hours, the city can confiscate the belongings. And then the city would need to give at least 30 days warning before disposing of the items.
Carlisle, Council Chair Ernie Martin, and the bill’s primary sponsor, Tulsi Gabbard, said they’re hoping for “voluntary compliance.” But in the event that a homeless individual or Occupy Honolulu decides against disposing of their belongings, the city will take action.
Lori Nishimura, who testified on behalf of the Carlisle administration at City Council, had said previously that enforcement would be complaint-driven. But Carlisle said Friday the city isn’t going to wait for complaints but will be proactive and look for violations.
Asked specifically about whether the city will use the new law to crack down on the Occupy Honolulu encampment as has been done in other cities, Carlisle said, “If it fits the law, we will enforce the law against everybody, indiscriminately.”
Some other specifics are less clear.
Asked about how the city will keep the belongings separate in the event that someone wants to come collect their stuff, Carlisle said, “That’s a very good question and one that I don’t have a specific answer to, although … there’s the potential of, if we need to, taking photographs of it.” Martin said the city should bag and tag items.
Does the mayor expect the city will be sued over the law?
“Oh, I always expect a lawsuit. I wake up and I breathe and I expect a lawsuit,” Carlisle said. “Am I concerned about it? No. Do I think we have good legal founding? If Jon Van Dyke thinks that this was constitutional, I believe his talents and ability are absolutely, 100 percent spot on, so I would suspect he was accurate and correct.”
And what happens if someone takes their belongings across the street to a state-owned beach park?
“So, if they make a point of taking all of their belongings, taking it somewhere else and then coming back later … going back and forth and back and forth. So we have a very energetic person,” Carlisle said. “We’ll deal with it when we see it.”
