Ever since the “Dear Leader” of North Korea, Kim Jong-il, went to meet his ancestors on Dec. 17, what a South Korean scholar called a “torrent of commentary” has flowed from Seoul, Washington, and Honolulu — and just about every place else connected with Korea.
In this cacophony have been calls for the U.S. to talk with the new rulers in Kimdom led by Kim Jong Un, Kim Jong Il’s son — and calls to ignore them; calls to resume the so-called Six-Party Talks on denuclearizing North Korea — and calls to forget it; calls to send food aid to starving North Koreans — and calls to let them eat leftover kimchi.
In the midst of the tumult, three voices of calm have floated above the din, one in Honolulu, another in Washington, and a third from Seoul. Taken together, they advise everyone to “hold it” until the turbulence in secretive Pyongyang recedes and the uncertain images become a tad more clear.
The scholar pointing to the “torrent of commentary” was Paik Nak-chung of Seoul National University, who wrote that the death of Kim Jong Il had generated wide speculation “on how events would proceed in the ‘post-Kim Jong-il era.’ Everyone is naturally curious to see what shape the Kim Jong-un era will take.”
In Honolulu, a caution from the president of the Pacific Forum think tank, Ralph Cossa, was pertinent: “When it comes to North Korea, we’re all guessing. The problem with watching events unfold behind such an opaque screen is that every event is subject to numerous interpretations.”
From Washington came sage advice from Victor Cha, a Korean-American scholar at Georgetown University who is an acknowledged authority on North Korea. He advised the U.S., China, and South Korea on “what not to do.”
Cha, who served in the White House on the National Security Council’s staff as director of Asian affairs 2004-2007, chided the Obama administration for “not treating the situation seriously and was distracted by other issues, such as the budget battle, the withdrawal from Iraq, and starting Christmas vacations.”
Curiously, President Obama ignored North Korea’s nuclear ambitions in his State of the Union address even as he pointed to Iran’s nuclear program: “America is determined to prevent Iran from getting a nuclear weapon and I will take no options off the table to achieve that goal.” Does not the same apply to North Korea?
On China, Cha asserted that Beijing “should not dismiss dialogue with South Korea and the U.S. about the evolving situation in the North. Thus far, China has reacted with typical closed-mindedness.” China, Cha contended, “should not allow itself to be seen as an advocate of keeping the peninsula divided.”
“Finally,” Cha argued, “South Korea must avoid the temptation to act unilaterally. This is hard for Koreans to hear. After all, this is their peninsula, and while political flux in North Korea is a foreign policy issue for China and the U.S., it is about life and death for Koreans.”
Even so, Cha warned, war games have shown that “the spark for major-power conflict in Korea has been South Korean unilateral actions that spark an action-reaction spiral between the United States and China. This must be avoided at all costs.”
A South Korean official who asked not to be named suggested that his government was taking a “wait and see” stance toward the North. He said Kim Jong Un, who is only 27 or 28 years old, was being advised on consolidating his position by an uncle-in-law who is married to Kim Jong Il’s sister, and by seven other older loyalists.
Two critical dates are coming up in Kimdom: Kim Jong Il’s birthday in February and, more important, the 100th anniversary in April of the birth of Kim Il Sung, the founder and “Eternal President” of North Korea. The first will be celebrated but that for Kim Il Sung will be cause for an eruption of national joy.
The South Korean official said his government would refrain from taking initiatives toward North Korea until after the April holiday. He also said his government doubted that North Korea would mount a provocation, like the sinking of the South Korea warship Cheonam in 2010, until after April.
