This year’s election campaign, particularly the so-called debates between President Barack Obama and Gov. Mitt Romney, has not been the finest hour in American democracy.
Rather it has been negative from start to near-finish. The candidates have spent as much time and energy bashing each other with personal attacks as in telling the voters what he would do in the White House during the next four years.
In several instances, each called the other a “liar,” although without actually using that word. Each indirectly questioned the intelligence and integrity of the other. About the only accusation that would have been worse would have been “traitor.”
Moreover, the president and the governor have been guilty of old-fashioned bad manners. In the debates, they repeatedly interrupted each other while the moderators were unable to control the exchanges. For instance, in the third debate, the governor was speaking when the president interrupted:
OBAMA: Governor, the fact of the matter is —
ROMNEY: I’m still speaking.
OBAMA: Well — (chuckles) —
ROMNEY: So I want to make sure that we make — we make America more competitive
OBAMA: Yeah.
ROMNEY: — and that we do those things that make America the most attractive place in the world for entrepreneurs, innovators, businesses to grow. But your investing in companies doesn’t do that. In fact it makes it less likely for them to come here —
OBAMA: All right, Governor —
ROMNEY: — because the private sector’s not going to invest in a — in a — in a solar company if —
OBAMA: I’m happy — I’m — I’m — I’m happy to respond —
ROMNEY: — if you’re investing government money and someone else’s.
OBAMA: You’ve held the floor for a while. The — look, I think anybody out there can check the record. Governor Romney, you keep on trying to, you know, airbrush history here.
You were very clear that you would not provide government assistance to the U.S. auto companies even if they went through bankruptcy. You said that they could get it in the private marketplace. That wasn’t true. They would have gone through a —
ROMNEY: You’re wrong. You’re wrong, Mr. President.
OBAMA: I — no, I am not wrong.
ROMNEY: You’re wrong.
OBAMA: I am not wrong. And —
ROMNEY: People can look it up. You’re right.
OBAMA: People will look it up.
ROMNEY: Good.
The nasty tone has extended into the congressional races and into local elections. Competing for a U.S. Senate seat for Hawaii, former Gov. Linda Lingle, the Republican, and Rep. Mazie Hirono, the Democrat, have been at each other’s throats. So have the candidates for mayor, Ben Cayetano and Kirk Caldwell.
The third of the three presidential debates, on Monday evening, October 22, was especially unenlightening. Part of that was the fault of the election commission and the moderator, Bob Schieffer of CBS News, as most of the questions they proffered were focused on today’s news rather than basic and long term issues facing the nation.
On Asia, the president and former governor of Massachusetts debated only China policy and even there limited their comments to economic difficulties while barely touching on security issues. American relations with and interests in Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Southeast Asia and the South China Sea, India, and Australia were ignored.
The differences between the candidates on the critical long-term issue of the rise of China as a major power seemed to be in nuance. President Obama argued that China could be “both and adversary but also a potential partner.” Governor Romney contended: “We can be a partner with China. We don’t have to be an adversary.”
Even so, Xinhua, the official press agency in Beijing, criticized both for making China a “scapegoat” for American economic shortcomings. But Xinhua evidently favored President Obama for re-election.
In one dispatch, Xinhua said: “Bashing China is a much easier and more convenient foil to score political gains.” In another, the Chinese news service said President Obama “pummeled his challenger relentlessly over his inconsistencies on foreign policy.”
Perhaps the worst part of all this mean campaigning is that the antagonism won’t end with the election. Rather, it will most likely carry over into the next four years to make the division in Washington and the inability to find workable compromises even more difficult than it has been for the last four years.
