Once again, the North Koreans have signaled that they might be willing to resume negotiations over relations with South Korea and the world, this coming in a New Year’s address by their leader, Kim Jong Un.

Once again, optimists in South Korea, Japan, and the U.S. have allowed, in a paraphrase of Samuel Johnson, hope to triumph over experience and suggested that the North Koreans are ready to shed their nuclear weapons and make peace.

And once again, realists in Seoul, Tokyo, and Washington have muttered darkly “forget it, just forget it” because the North Koreans will never give up their nuclear arms, the missiles they are developing to deliver them, and the threat of violence.

All three nations, plus China and Russia, have driven around this racetrack many times before only to come to a smoldering halt. Six rounds of the so-called Six Party Talks took place from 2003 to 2007, then were discontinued in 2009 and have been lifeless ever since.

What’s new is the fluid situation among the six parties, where all but one — ironically North Korea — have new governments.

In Washington, the second administration of President Barack Obama is being formed with new secretaries of state, defense, and treasury, plus a new director of central intelligence. In Tokyo, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has been in office only since last month and is still groping his way along.

In Seoul, President-elect Park Geun Hye, who will be the first woman to be president of South Korea, will not take office until Feb. 25. In Beijing, President Xi Jinping is still gathering the reins of power. In Moscow, President Vladimir Putin began his second term only last May.

In Pyongyang, Kim Jong Un, who took over in December 2011 after his father, Kim Jong Il, died, has consolidated his control of the government, the ruling Communist Party, and most importantly, the Korean Peoples Army. Kim has established what an experienced observer calls “a dynamically stable regime.”

Alexandre Mansourov, a former Russian diplomat who once studied in a North Korean university, wrote that North Korea’s satellite launch in December will “further boost Kim Jong Un’s domestic legitimacy, increase his political capital, undermine potential critics, help him silence military discontent, and increase his international stature.”

In particular, Mansourov wrote from a Washington think tank, Kim has brought “the military’s senior leadership under unquestionable party control, repeatedly purging and publicly subduing it, and dramatically curtailing the military’s policymaking influence.”

It may be that when Kim wrote his New Year’s speech, he figured North Korea could take advantage of these new governments. In contrast to earlier blasts erupting from Pyongyang, anti-South Korean, anti-Japanese, and anti-American invective was missing.

Kim said only: “The moves of the imperialists to interfere in the internal affairs of other sovereign states and their acts of military aggression pose a serious threat to peace and security of mankind. The Asia-Pacific region, the Korean Peninsula in particular, has become the hottest spot in the world.”

Compared with Pyongyang’s usual belligerent rhetoric, that was practically a warm handshake.

Instead, Kim focused on economic problems, exhorting the North Korean people to work harder, especially in agriculture, light industry, mining, and electric power. “All units of the national economy,” Kim said, “should launch a vigorous general offensive to boost production in hearty response to the Party’s militant slogan.”

Indirectly admitting that North Korea’s economy was in deep trouble, Kim asserted: “All economic undertakings for this year should be geared to effecting a radical increase in production and stabilizing and improving the people’s living standards.”

Two visiting Americans, former Gov. Bill Richardson of New Mexico, and Eric Schmidt, chief executive officer of Google, experienced North Korea’s deprivation first hand last week. Even when inside modern buildings, they and their North Korean hosts remained bundled up in heavy winter overcoats to ward off the lack of heating.

As his neighbors in China have insisted for themselves, Kim demanded an end to corruption. “To effect a radical change in this year’s campaign to build a thriving socialist country,” he said, “officials should make a fundamental turnabout in their ideological viewpoint, work style and attitude.”

Evans Revere, a retired senior State Department official and onetime second in charge of the U.S. Embassy in Seoul, noted the flurry of speculation that Kim Jong Un’s speech was a sign that North Korea would change tactics.

“Prepare to be disappointed,” Revere wrote. “Experience tells us that a healthy dose of skepticism is in order when we see hints of possible change in the DPRK [Democratic Peoples Republic of Korea]. We have been down this road many times before and we are best served by taking such pronouncements from Pyongyang with a large grain of salt.”

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...