Two academics, one American, the other Japanese, have published in the Los Angeles Times and the Honolulu Star-Advertiser an essay asserting that the newly elected Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, proposes “to build the foundation for an authoritarian and militarized Japan.”
Nonsense.
That contention overlooks nearly 70 years of Japanese constitutional government, democratic experience, vigorously exercised freedom of speech and assembly, elections of all sorts, and local, prefectural, and national decisions made by sometimes painfully slow consensus.
That opinion further overlooks the constraints imposed on Japan’s armed forces, the rigid limits on defense budgets, and the restraints on military deployments and operations with the forces of other nations, notably the U.S. Moreover, much of Japan’s foreign policy during those seven decades has been anemic and indecisive.
A former deputy secretary of state, Richard Armitage, asked to comment on the possibility that Japanese militarism would be revived, was succinct: “Overblown.”
Armitage, in Honolulu to address the Pacific Forum, a think tank, said in an interview: “Prime Minister Abe, whom I know personally, is a smart guy. He believes that it is more important to drive forward looking through the front windshield, not the back windshield.”
“Abe knows that Japan needs to rely on America in this alliance and America needs to rely on Japan as we rebalance in Asia. But both the U.S. and Japan have limitations on what they can do.” He referred to serious economic issues of national debt and budget deficits that both nations are experiencing,
Abe himself outlined his security posture last fall before his election, emphasizing Japan’s relations with other democracies. “Nothing is more important for Japan than to reinvest in its alliance with the US. In a period of US strategic rebalancing toward the Asia-Pacific region, the US needs Japan as much as Japan needs the US.”
“Immediately after Japan’s earthquake, tsunami, and nuclear disaster in 2011,” Abe wrote, “the US military provided for Japan the largest peacetime humanitarian relief operation ever mounted — powerful evidence that the 60-year bond that the treaty allies have nurtured is real.”
Beyond that, Abe wrote, “Japan is a mature maritime democracy and its choice of close partners should reflect that fact. I envisage a strategy whereby Australia, India, Japan and the US state of Hawaii form a diamond to safeguard the maritime commons stretching from the Indian Ocean region to the western Pacific.”
Abe concluded: “I am prepared to invest, to the greatest possible extent, Japan’s capabilities in this security diamond.”
The criticism of Abe’s plans was written by Bruce Ackerman of Yale University and Tokujin Matsudaira of Teikyo University. They argued that Abe had proposed “a sweeping constitutional revision proposed by Abe’s resurgent Liberal Democratic Party.” The LDP won the parliamentary election on Dec. 16 and Abe took office 10 days later.
The credentials of the scholars are questionable. Ackerman shows only one connection with Japan in a 29-page resume, attendance at a Kyoto Seminar in American Studies in the summer of 2000. Matsudaira, who has written about Japan’s constitutional issues, lectures at Yokohama City University as well as Teikyo, both lesser-known schools.
To begin executing the prime minister’s insistence on improving Japan’s relations with the U.S., Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida met Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton in Washington on Friday. They agreed that Prime Minister Abe would meet with President Obama in Washington during the third week of February.
In Singapore, Bhubhindar Singh of Nanyang Technological University noted that Mr. Abe was making his first trip abroad last week, to Vietnam, Thailand, and Indonesia. Singh wrote: “Japan’s strategy is to provide Southeast Asia with economic, political and limited security support to address the present instability caused by the maritime disputes” in the South China Sea.
An Australian strategic thinker, Rory Medcalf, has written: “it would be inaccurate and unfair to dismiss the entirety of the new Abe government’s foreign and security policy platform as needless or provocative nationalism.”
“It is both prudent and understandable,” Medcalf wrote, “that Japan appears set on a modest expansion of its maritime defense capabilities, given several years of tensions with China and worsening anxieties about North Korea.”
Similarly, from what has been seen so far, Mr. Abe’s policy has been welcomed in India. An Indian scholar, Harsh V. Pant, wrote: “It is now possible to envision an end to this drift in Delhi-Tokyo ties.”
