It is axiomatic that most wars down through the ages have been started by miscalculation.
A belligerent ruler mistakenly believes his army can beat his neighbor’s; a general mistakenly thinks a preemptive strike will force an adversary to back down; a rifleman on guard mistakenly pulls a trigger and kills an innocent bystander. In each case¸ events don’t go as planned but get out of hand and blow up.
So it is today with the Chinese and Japanese quarreling over uninhabited rocks in the East China Sea.
The Japanese accuse Chinese warships of “painting” Japanese warships and aircraft with radar beams to acquire target information in preparing to open fire. The Chinese deny it and demand that the Japanese ships withdraw.
In this confrontation, all it would take for an explosion would be for a Chinese or Japanese ship captain to decide to shoot before his ship is shot at.
American armed forces could become engaged in hostilities in a trice. The U.S. is obligated by treaty to help defend Japan in a conflict and the Obama Administration has been explicit in promising to back the Japanese in a fight. U.S. forces, moreover, are positioned to do so.
Thus Adm. Samuel Locklear, commander of U.S. forces in the Asia-Pacific region, told journalists during a visit to Indonesia that the Chinese and Japanese governments should realize the potential for miscalculation in this confrontation. He said: “We need to be very, very careful in ensuring we don’t see escalation that could lead to miscalculation that could lead to unintended consequences.”
Like several other issues in Asia, this dispute over the Senkaku (Japanese) or Diaoyu (Chinese) islets is left over from World War II. The Japanese argue the rocks were retained by Japan under the San Francisco peace treaty of 1951. The Chinese contend that they should have been stripped from Japan and returned to China, the ancient owner.
The disagreement has been compounded by new governments in Beijing and Tokyo, regimes that evidently think domestic politics prevents them from making concessions abroad. China’s General Secretatry Xi Jinping, who is also chairman of the Central Military Commission, and Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe have each staked out hardline, unyielding positions.
Decision-making in China is often murky but the evidence suggests that the People’s Liberation Army, which comprises all of China’s armed forces, is driving China’s posture in this encounter. The Ministry of National Defense web site talks opening of “war” and “the use of force” while the Xinhua, which speaks for the Communist Party, speaks of “tension” and “dialogue.”
For many months, the PLA has been acting with increasing autonomy and displaying a greater sense of nationalism than the Communist Party. Chinese political leaders from Mao Zedong to Xi Jinping have insisted that the party should control the gun but the PLA appears more and more to ignore that demand.
In Japan, Defense Minister Itsunori Onodera seemed to be floundering a bit. Pointing to the radar incident, he asserted that the Chinese had violated the United Nations charter. The Chinese action, he contended, “should be regarded as a threat of force, banned under the UN charter.”
The Japanese government, however, has floated the idea that the ultimate goal of the PLA was to take control not only of the Senkaku/Diaoyu islets but the Ryukyu island chain stretching north to include Okinawa, site of a large American base.
In this tense situation, U.S. officers will not discuss military operations but prudent commanders have quietly put their forces on alert. Intelligence efforts have become more focused, lines of command and communication have been tightened, and contingency plans have been dusted off and updated. Warning, or fragmentary, orders have been prepared.
Few ships, planes, or troops need to be moved far because one of the largest concentrations of American military power is situated in Northeast Asia, with headquarters in the Pacific Command in Hawaii and forward bases in Guam, Okinawa and elsewhere in Japan, and South Korea.
The U.S. Air Force’s largest base is at Kadena in Okinawa where airborne warning planes called AWACS are based. Another large base is Andersen on Guam where two B-2 stealth bombers are currently deployed and a major training exercise of U.S., Australian, and Japanese pilots is underway.
At sea, the aircraft carrier Nimitz and seven other ships in a strike group are in the Western Pacific. The carrier George Washington is in her home port of Yokosuka, Japan. The carrier Vinson has just completed a six month maintenance cycle and is ready for sea in the Eastern Pacific. Several submarines armed with cruise missiles are in the western Pacific.
The amphibious assault ship Bonhomme Richard is in the South China Sea with an expeditionary unit of Marines aboard. Other Marines are in Guam and Okinawa. Since Japan does not have a Marine Corps, U.S. Marines have recently trained Japanese soldiers in amphibious operations.
Question: Will all this deter a miscalculation?
