The Japanese report on Chinese military power goes immediately to the heart of the matter with an opening question: “Is the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) under civilian control?”

In guarded language, analysts at the National Institute for Defense Studies, an agency of the Ministry of Defense in Tokyo, conclude that considerable concern has been expressed in China and elsewhere that the Communist Party and government in Beijing no longer exercise control over the PLA.

The Japanese appear to have been cautious in their assessment to avoid angering Chinese leaders, who have often been trigger quick to take offense openly whenever outsiders comment on an issue they consider to be a Chinese internal affair.

In some contrast to the Japanese findings, American defense officials with access to intelligence on China say privately that the PLA, which comprises all of China’s military forces, has clearly become more independent of party and government control in recent years.

In this assessment, PLA leaders are not so much defying the authority of the Communist Party as they are ignoring the policies set by the Politburo in national security and foreign policy. It is as if the PLA has become a separate, autonomous center of power and policy in Beijing.

Whatever the case, these assessments mean that the U.S., Japan, and everyone else must take the PLA’s posture and position into account when fashioning a foreign or security policy concerning China. PLA leaders have often shown themselves to be more assertive and nationalistic than civilian political or economic leaders.

Moreover, a miscalculation on the part of PLA generals or admirals can have more deadly consequences than a miscalculation by the foreign ministry or a ministry concerned with economic issues.

According to doctrine set by China’s revolutionary leader, Mao Zedong, the PLA is the military arm of the Communist Party and must demonstrate loyalty to the Party, not to the government or the nation. Individually, PLA officers swear allegiance to the Party. In contrast, U.S. officers swear to defend the Constitution.

The authority to guide the PLA rests with the Central Military Commission (CMC), which commands the Ministry of Defense, the Army, Navy, Air Force and the Second Artillery, plus four staff departments. The Second Artillery has charge of China’s nuclear weapons.

The newly named CMC is chaired by Xi Jinping, general secretary of the party and president of the government. The two vice-chairmen and the other eight members are all uniformed military officers. While Xi Jinping is China’s political leader and was a vice-chairman of the CMC under Chairman Hu Jintao, his is the CMC’s sole civilian voice.

This fresh CMC is part of the transition from the regime led by Hu Jintao to that led by Xi Jinping, who has had little contact with the PLA as he has risen though the party ranks. One new vice-chairman is Army General Fan Changiong, who was commander of the Jinan Military Region on the shores of the Yellow Sea opposite the Korean peninsula.

The other new vice chairman is Air Force General Xu Qiliang, the first air force officer to be named to that post. His promotion reflects the increasing importance of air power in China’s military modernization. There have been rumors that the new premier, Li Keqiang, may be named to the CMC, adding a civilian voice to its deliberations.

Perhaps the most intriguing new member of the CMC and a sign of the times is the appointment of Air Force General Ma Xiaotian, commander of the Air Force. He is an outspoken nationalist who, as a deputy chief of the general staff, has travelled all over Asia and to other countries in conducting the PLA’s foreign policy.

When China and the Philippines clashed over the Scarborough Shoal/Huangyan Island in the South China Sea, he told a TV interviewer that the “issue is none of the United States’ business” but a dispute between China and the Philippines. The U.S. has called for protecting the freedom of navigation through the South China Sea.

At the 20120 Shangri-La conference in Singapore, Ma tangled with Adm. Robert Willard, then chief of the U.S. Pacific Command, demanding that the U.S. cease naval and air surveillance in the East and South China Seas. He also reiterated in forceful terms Beijing’s standard demand that the U.S. stop selling arms to Taiwan.

More recently, Ma met Adm. Samuel Locklear, the current Pacific Command leader, when Locklear visited Beijing last year. According to the PLA Daily newspaper, Ma repeated the demand that the U.S. stop its naval and aerial reconnaissance of China. Presumably, Locklear demurred.

Richard Halloran, who writes the weekly column called “The Rising East,” contributes articles on Asia and US relations with Asia to publications in America and Asia. His career can be divided into thirds: One third studying and reporting on Asia, another third writing about national security, and...