Forty years ago, the U.S. withdrew from Vietnam after a long and vicious conflict that ended in bitter defeat and 58,200 Americans dead. Last week, in yet another major step in what has become a remarkable reconciliation, President Obama welcomed the president of Vietnam, Truong Tan Sang, to the White House.
“This,” Mr. Obama said after a meeting with Mr. Sang, “represents the steady progression and strengthening of the relationship between our two countries.”
With a nod toward the “extraordinarily complex history” of the U.S. and Vietnam, the president said Americans and Vietnamese have established “a degree of mutual respect and trust that has allowed us now to announce a comprehensive partnership.”
The president said “that will allow even greater cooperation on a whole range of issues from trade and commerce to military-to-military cooperation, to multilateral work on issues like disaster relief, to scientific and educational exchanges.”
In response, President Sang said “President Obama and I had a very candid, open, useful and constructive discussion.”
Thus, he asserted, “it is time now to form a comprehensive partnership” that would include “political relations, science and technology, education, defense, the legacy of the war issue, environment, the Vietnamese-American community, human rights, and the East Sea.” (East Sea is the Vietnamese name for the South China Sea.)
Earlier, Secretary of State John Kerry was host at a luncheon for President Sang and recalled that when he was in the “brown water navy” fighting in the Mekong Delta in 1969, Mr. Sang was a guerrilla leader south of Saigon. Later, Kerry said, Mr. Sang was in line to become mayor of Saigon just about the time he (Kerry) was elected to the Senate. Kerry called all that “an interesting parallel.”
The U.S. reconciliation with Vietnam has its precedent in the time after World War II when America was reconciled with Germany and Japan — with an intrinsic difference. Germany and Japanese were defeated and occupied by the U.S. and its allies. In contrast, the Vietnamese drove U.S. forces from their homeland.
In this evolving relationship, the motives on both sides today can be summed up in one word: China. Historically, little love has been lost between the Vietnamese and their increasingly aggressive neighbors to the north. For the U.S., Vietnam could be a critical element in Washington’s effort to counter China’s drive to dominance.
A serious drawback: The U.S. and Vietnam have wide differences over human rights. The government in Washington, regardless of political party, has been openly critical of the Communist government in Hanoi for its harsh treatment of dissenters, its lack of political freedom, and its tight controls on religion.
The healing between the U.S. and Vietnam began in 1991 when President George Bush the elder laid out a “roadmap.” That led to diplomatic relations in 1995 when the first U.S. ambassador to Hanoi was Douglas “Pete” Peterson, an Air Force fighter pilot who had been shot down and spent six years in a North Vietnamese prison.
Another leader in the movement to revitalize relations with Vietnam was Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), a naval aviator who was also shot down, badly injured and beaten, and spent six years in a North Vietnamese prison.
Still another advocate of renewed relations with Vietnam was former Sen. James Webb (D-Va.) who was a Marine infantryman awarded the Navy Cross, the Marine Corps second highest decoration, for bravery in Vietnam. He is perhaps best known for his novel about the war, Fields of Fire.
The same year that embassies were exchanged, Robert McNamara, the U.S. secretary of defense through much of the Vietnam war, met in Hanoi with General Vo Nguyen Giap, North Vietnam’s minister of defense. They were reported to have discussed how the war might have been avoided.
During the ensuing years, Presidents Clinton and Bush the younger have visited Vietnam. So have several secretaries of state, including Colin Powell who had served in the Vietnam as an Army major. Several secretaries of defense and four star generals and admirals have travelled to Vietnam to confer with their opposite numbers.
U.S. Navy warships have called at Vietnamese ports and the Navy and the Air force have dispatched humanitarian missions to Vietnam. The Vietnamese have opened the famed port at Cam Ranh Bay to any nation’s warships that need repairs. U.S. and Vietnamese officers have explored the possibilities of joint training exercises.
The first Vietnamese president to be welcomed to the White House was President Nguyen Minh Triet, who led a 2007 delegation of ministers mostly concerned with trade and investment. President Sang is the second. He said he invited President Obama to visit Vietnam and said Mr. Obama would try to do so during his term in office.
