Medicare turns 50 this week and with all the talk of eventual insolvency, it seems like a good time to think about what America’s health care system might look like if Medicare didn’t exist.
After all, prior to 1965, it didn’t.
President Lyndon B Johnson signed the Medicare system into law on July 30, 1965. The goal was to provide health insurance to those 65 and older, regardless of income or medical history. At the time, approximately 50 percent of Americans in that age range had coverage, but the rest could not afford to because older adults paid three times as much as the younger generation. Nearly 30 percent were below the poverty line.

When Medicare was established, everyone 65 and over had health insurance. Part A covered hospital expenses, Part B physician office charges.
In 1972 Medicare added coverage for those with end stage kidney disease on dialysis, and those who are disabled. In 2003, health maintenance organizations came into being, also referred to as medicare advantage plans, and were called Part C. In 2006, coverage expanded for medications, creating Part D.
What if Medicare just didn’t exist at all?
First, seniors would have to buy their own insurance at a time when their health generally represents the greater risk.
This is not cheap. Prior to the Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as Obamacare, purchasing health insurance privately was extremely expensive, and didn’t cover certain pre-existing conditions. Even now, the cost of a health insurance plan for anyone in their early 60s not qualifying for a subsidy can exceed $1,000 a month.
Imagine if Medicare never kicked in. Would people just work until they died?
But people 65 and older would not be the only ones paying more for health insurance. Their premiums would probably not fully reflect the cost of coverage, so rates would be increased for younger people.
Sure, companies could charge the older folks more, but at some point, the difference in cost would be too large to make the model feasible. It would be similar to auto insurance, in which to some extent good drivers help pay for insuring bad drivers.
Even healthy seniors in their 70s and 80s would have to pay more for their insurance because of others who were not in good health but were also in their same age cohort for determining coverage costs.
If insurance costs more, then many people might go without. That would inevitably lead to a greater number of visits to the emergency room for conditions that might otherwise have been prevented or treated in a more timely fashion at a lower cost.
Who pays for those who go to the ER and don’t have health insurance? We all do as taxpayers, either directly with state and government payments to the hospitals, or to offset tax credits or non-profit status that enable hospitals and heath corporations to use their charity care as a way to lower taxable profits.
So taxes would go up.
In addition, older people without insurance would have less control over their costs when they went to see the doctor. Medicare sets a fee schedule that is based on its calculations of what value to place on services. Doctors are not allowed to charge Medicare patients any more than the government has already decided will be paid, and the rates are non-negotiable.
Without Medicare controls, the costs would be whatever the doctor or medical center deemed appropriate. If doctors wanted to charge older people more for their care, they could, and no Medicare rules would stop them.
With the increased costs for seniors, either to buy their own insurance or to pay for their medical bills, would children still inherit their parent’s house? It would probably have to be sold to pay for medical care bills.
Retirement savings would be at risk too. For those with a lot of money, a change in the system might not matter. For those with nothing at all, Medicaid could pick up the costs. But for those who worked their whole lives to have something left when they retired, that whole plan would be subject to the uncertainty of future health care costs.
Ask anyone who is 62 and wants to retire, what’s one of the main reasons they don’t? Health insurance coverage, because they are not eligible for Medicare until 65.
Imagine if it never kicked in. Would people just work until they died?
As much as people, including patients, doctors, politicians and society at large, complain about having a socialist system for health care as we age, the plain and simple fact is that we all hope to be 65 someday, and live long healthy lives. But if we took away the very system that guarantees control over at least one aspect of the cost of retirement — our medical bills — then we would all be in a much worse position than we might think.
Medicare turns 50 this week. I hope when I turn 65, it’s there for me.
