Possibly the safest electoral seats in Hawaii have been on the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board of Trustees.

For 20 years, voters have consistently returned the same people to the board of OHA, which is charged with improving the lives of Native Hawaiians regarding land, culture, economic self sufficiency, health, education and governance.

Saturday’s primary election to fill four seats on the board features two trustees who have served since 1996 — Colette Machado and Haunani Apoliona — and have rarely experienced a close election. Another trustee, Robert Lindsey Jr., has served since 2007.

The seats up for election include Apoliona’s at-large position, Lindsey’s Hawaii Island seat, Machado’s Molokai seat and the Kauai seat currently held by Dan Ahuna (who is unopposed).

Machado and Apoliona are past OHA chairs and Lindsey is the current chair.

Photos of the current trustees at the OHA's headquarters on North Nimitz Highway in Honolulu.
Photos of the current trustees at the OHA’s headquarters on North Nimitz Highway in Honolulu. Cory Lum/Civil Beat

Machado and Apoliona are also chair and vice chair, respectively, of OHA’s Committee on Resource Management, which has a huge kuleana (responsibility): to recommend policies for management of the OHA’s investment portfolio and other financial matters, and to develop policies for land acquisitions, dispositions, development and management. Its core operating budget was $36 million in 2015.

Generally, the current OHA board has operated with a certain steadiness, although there are continuing legal battles with trustee Rowena Akana, who is on the outs with the current board leadership.

High-Profile Issues

In recent years OHA has been embroiled in several high-profile issues:

• The actions of Kamana‘opono Crabbe, OHA’s Ka Pouhana or CEO, after Crabbe sought an opinion from U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry regarding the status of the Hawaiian Kingdom.

• The indirect financial assistance for the Nai Aupuni self-governance convention (OHA gave about $2 million to a nonprofit that gave money to Nai Aupuni).

• The fight over telescopes and cultural and environmental rights on Mauna Kea (the board rescinded its support for the Thirty Meter Telescope project).

This election, several challengers are campaigning to shake up the OHA board.

They include a former trustee and independence activist, Mililani Trask, and Kelii Akina, head of the Grassroot Institute of Hawaii. Though they have very different backgrounds, there has been speculation that they might be in cahoots because both want to reform OHA.

Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board Chair Robert Lindsey Jr. in September 2015.
Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board Chair Robert Lindsey Jr. in September 2015. Cory Lum/Civil Beat

OHA needs to be more transparent and it needs to be more accountable,” Trask said in her Civil Beat candidate questionnaire. “OHA staff and trustees are unaware of the rules and ethical standards they are required to follow as a state agency. Training for all OHA trustees and personnel should be undertaken yearly by the Office of Information Practices, state and county ethics commissions and a compliance officer retained to advise the BOT and staff on these regulations and to review office procedures and report on deficiencies and violations.”

Trask is also worried about OHA’s funding and helping Hawaiians struggling to find housing, jobs and an education. Too many Hawaiians, in her view, are incarcerated or dealing with drug addiction.

Akina took the lead role in suing to halt a scheduled Nai Aupuni election of convention delegates, forcing Nai Aupuni to cancel the election last fall. He believes the self-governance process is unconstitutional.

In his candidate questionnaire, Akina said there are two ways he would change OHA:

First, I will work to stop OHA from continuing to waste tens of millions of dollars on creating a divisive, race-based sovereign nation. Instead, I will insist that those funds be spent on meeting real needs of Hawaiians, such as solving the problem of homelessness, and providing for education, housing, job opportunity and health care. 

Secondly, I will work for term limits so that the same trustees do not remain in office for decades, continuing to pursue failed policies.

Akina believes that OHA should work to unite people rather than divide them.

“That’s the Hawaiian way, which recognizes that we are all boats in the same harbor,” he said.

Past Runners-Up

Trask and Akina finished fourth and fifth, respectively, in the OHA at-large trustee race in 2014. The top three finishers, including Akana, were incumbents who each were returned to office that year.

Lindsey easily won his Hawaii Island trustee contest in 2012 while Kauai Island trustee Ahuna defeated 10 other candidates.

In addition to Akina, Apoliona also faces five other challengers for the at-large seat: Daniel Anthony, Douglass Crum, Leona Mapuana Kalima, Paul Ledwith Mossman and Kealii Makekau.

OHA Trustee Haunani Apoliona listens to testimony during an April 2015 meeting.
OHA Trustee Haunani Apoliona listens to testimony during an April 2015 meeting. Nathan Eagle/Civil Beat

In her candidate questionnaire, Apoliona said OHA “is performing its mandate, but not enough is being done due to internal and external barriers.”

Those barriers include limited OHA resources, costs of “threatened and actual” litigation, weak support from Congress for Native Hawaiian issues and a need for “improved communication methods and means for disseminating accurate information and facts to leaders and the public,” she said

Apoliona is also concerned about the high incarceration rates of Hawaiians.

As well, she would like the elected leaders of a Native Hawaiian governing entity (such as one that could come from the Nai Aupuni convention process that was held in February) to “renegotiate or litigate” over ceded lands revenues for all Hawaiians. The lands are 1.8 million acres that belonged to the Hawaiian monarchy prior to the 1893 overthrow.

Calls For An Audit

Makekau, meanwhile, wants “a complete, independent fiscal forensic audit of all holdings and resources followed by a review of the Board of Trustees policy handbook and master plan by a committee of the whole.”

According to his candidate questionnaire, Makekau (who lost to Apoliona in 2012, a race Akina also lost) wants term limits for OHA trustees. He does not believe the agency is fulfilling its mandate. He argues that the focus on the formation of a government entity or tribe similar to Native Americans came “at a failed cost of $33 million plus.”

OHA Trustee Colette Machado makes a point during an April 2015 meeting.
OHA Trustee Colette Machado makes a point during an April 2015 meeting. Nathan Eagle/Civil Beat

Meanwhile, he said, OHA “let economic opportunities like a medical marijuana dispensary and the development of the Kakaako Makai properties remain sidelined without a master plan either due to incompetence or instructions that the new tribal entity will have the first shot at that and more.”

Machado, who was unchallenged for her Molokai trustee seat four years ago, faces challengers Jerry (Manuwa) Flowers and Alapai Hanapi this year.

OHA elections are open to all registered voters in Hawaii. If no candidate receives a majority of the vote, the top two finishers will face off in the November general election.

“If you care about our host culture and the future of Hawaii, you should take the time to educate yourself about the candidates and vote in the OHA races this election year,” Crabbe said.

Not a subscription

Civil Beat is a small nonprofit newsroom, and we’re committed to a paywall-free website and subscription-free content because we believe in journalism as a public service. That’s why donations from readers like you are essential to our continued existence.

Make a gift to Civil Beat today and help keep our journalism free for all readers. And if you’re able, consider a sustaining monthly gift to support our work all year-round.



About the Author