An Oʻahu grand jury on Tuesday indicted two-time convicted killer Jason Lee McCormick for a third murder in the beating death of transgender inmate Denise Foster at the state’s largest prison last summer.

Foster was killed at Hālawa Correctional Facility, a men’s prison, on Aug. 4 after McCormick allegedly attacked her in her cell. The indictment accuses McCormick of first-degree murder.

Foster, 55, was a non-violent minimum security inmate inmate who was serving a five-year prison term for theft and unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle. Foster’s niece Queenair Bulawan said Foster had expected to be released in September or October.

The prison system has not explained why Foster was housed in an area of the prison where she had contact with McCormick, 52, who is a maximum security inmate.

Denise Foster, 55, was reportedly beaten and strangled in a cell in Hālawa Correctional Facility on Aug. 4.
Denise Foster was reportedly beaten and strangled in a cell in Hālawa prison on Aug. 4. (Courtesy photo/2022 ) (Courtesy photo/2022)

McCormick was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole in 2013 for the murder of visiting University of Pittsburgh Professor Robert Henderson in 1996.

He also pleaded guilty to premeditated first-degree murder in Arizona in the 2015 strangulation death of his cellmate Jonathan Namauleg, 21, at the Saguaro Correctional Center. That conviction carries a life sentence without parole to be served after McCormick completes his life sentence for the Henderson murder.

The indictment gives no details about the case, but sources with ties to the state correctional system said a video camera recorded McCormick and Foster arguing outside Foster’s cell before the killing, and McCormick allegedly wrote a profane message in blood on the wall of Foster’s cell directed at Hālawa Warden Shannon Cluney.

Another Hawaiʻi Prison Death Has Family Seeking Answers

Two online petitions circulated after Foster’s death calling on the state to create safeguards for transgender and vulnerable inmates. The petitions together garnered over 300 signatures.

Jason Lee McCormick (Courtesy Hawaiʻi Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation/2026)
Jason Lee McCormick (Courtesy Hawaiʻi Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation/2026)

“No one should be beaten to death because the system refused to ask whether they were safe,” one petition reads. “Demand gender-affirming, safety-based housing policy in Hawaiʻi’s prisons before another life is lost.”

Bulawan said her family has heard nothing from the prison system about what led to Foster’s death, and was not told about the indictment before it was made public. “Ever since she passed, nobody said anything,” Bulawan said. “We don’t know.”

Bulawan said Foster will be missed during the months ahead. “It’s hard, especially coming the holiday part where she always goes to family houses,” she said. “That’s the part that everyone miss about her. She always tried to give something to everybody.”

Toni Schwartz, public information officer for the state Attorney General’s office, said in a written statement McCormick is still being held at Hālawa prison, without bail.

The first-degree murder charge carries a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Reporter Taylor Nāhulukeaokalani Cozloff contributed to this story.

Kevin Dayton is a reporter for Civil Beat.