The Trump administration auctioned off millions of dollars’ worth of leases for deep-sea mining exploration in federal waters off American Samoa, despite a judge ruling the auction was unlawful earlier this week.
The auction has given two unnamed deep-sea mining prospectors the right to conduct exploratory activities in 31 million acres of federal waters off the coast of American Samoa, where they hope to harvest metals and minerals from the seafloor. That material is prized for use in renewable energy technology and batteries, among other things.
The auction came just days after Hawaiʻi District Judge Jill Otake’s Monday ruling that the National Marine Fisheries Service “did not even consider” the potential effects of mining exploration activities on marine wildlife in the lease zones. Environmental groups fear the administration’s decision to ignore Otake’s ruling is a preview of its intent to flout the law in its bid to mine tracts of international and U.S. territorial waters in the Pacific Ocean.
Numerous countries and environmental organizations have opposed the administration’s stance on deep-sea mining, for fear of its many unknown environmental impacts. The Conservation Council for Hawaiʻi and Fa’asao Amerika Samoa are among them — Earthjustice filed a lawsuit on their behalf in August in an effort to halt Thursday’s auction.
The suit alleged that the National Marine Fisheries Service failed to adhere to the Endangered Species Act, ignoring the risk mining activities pose to several endangered migratory species of whales, turtles and sharks. Otake ultimately agreed in her Monday ruling.
“I would say I’m surprised. But I feel with this administration, it’s not surprising to see them disregard a court ruling and proceed as if nothing happened,” Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton told Civil Beat.

The lease sales, worth $3 million each, are a national first and “a historic step for America’s energy and mineral security,” U.S. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum said in a statement. “Today’s sale opens a path to learn more about the resources off the coast of American Samoa and assess whether they could contribute to a more reliable domestic supply.”
Mining companies want to essentially comb the seafloor for polymetallic nodules, grapefruit-sized orbs comprising nickel, copper, cobalt and manganese, among other elements that are especially important for modern technologies.
But the process of harvesting those nodules is seen as destructive, with the potential of stirring up sediment and disrupting the fine balance of oceanic ecosystems. The long-term effects of deep-sea mining can persist for decades, according to recent research.
Fa’asao Amerika Samoa, part of the first lawsuit, has a long list of concerns about mining of the seabed around the U.S. territory. The organization said in a 2025 letter to the Department of Interior that the islands stand to gain nothing from the mining, which will “endanger livelihoods, destroy traditions, and erode the cultural foundations that define the Samoan people.”
Conservation Council for Hawaiʻi Executive Director Jonee Peters is concerned that the largely untested mining practice will have negative effects on marine life in American Samoa and beyond, as animals migrate far beyond the territory and reach Hawaiʻi.
“We all rely on our ocean for subsistence,” Peters said. “If that is threatened, what happens to our food sources and our cultural identity, which all starts with the oceans?”
The lease areas sit between 150 and 240 miles east of Pago Pago, the capital of American Samoa, with waters up to 20,100 feet deep. The leases cover a term of 20 years but do not allow for mapping mineral or metals deposits, testing or actual mining, which is how it justified its decision to overlook the effects of mining in the lease zones. Otake disagreed.
Otake’s determination was seen as a litmus test for other mining lawsuits, of which Earthjustice has at least four, in partnership with local environmental groups. One opposes a similar exploration lease auction for U.S. territorial waters off the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, scheduled for Dec. 16. Otake will preside over that case.
Eaton is concerned the administration’s willful disregard of the ruling is setting a precedent.
