Some 48 states nationwide have statutes in place that allow incarcerated individuals to be released from prison if they have terminal illnesses or severe medical conditions. Hawaiʻi is not one of them.

Recently, the Hawaiʻi House Public Safety Committee held an informational briefing to consider establishing a “compassionate release” policy in statute. Similar legislation has died repeatedly in Hawaiʻi, with corrections officials and other critics arguing that releasing incarcerated people early would undermine accountability for crimes committed and pose risks to the public.

But compassionate release advocates believe there are compelling reasons — financially as well as humanitarian — for Hawaiʻi to join other states that have these policies.

At the recent briefing, testifiers included Molly Crane, counsel with Families Against Mandatory Minimums, a national nonprofit advocacy group that challenges harsh sentencing laws and promotes a fairer criminal justice system. Also lobbying for compassionate release is retired Honolulu lawyer Robert Merce, a criminal justice reform advocate. This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Define in layman’s terms what compassionate release is.

Molly Crane: Compassionate release is programs created by lawmakers that allow people to be considered for release because of medical reasons. And this is particularly important when people are too cognitively impaired to be even aware of punishment, too sick to participate in rehabilitation, or too functionally compromised to pose a risk to public safety.

We know that compassionate release is important because it reduces costs and it supports staff. It provides dignity and it protects public safety. It makes sense not only for individuals and families, but for systems and staff, and for taxpayers.

Is Hawaiʻi still the only state without a law requiring release of dying inmates in some circumstances?

So just to clarify, Hawaiʻi is the only state whose compassionate release program is not governed by statute. Iowa does not have compassionate release at all, but Hawaiʻi is the only state where the program does not have a statute.

Why is it important for it to be in statute?

There are a lot of reasons. Transparency is one, consistency and durability, but also the Legislature giving guidance to the Paroling Authority and to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation about what people should be considered and how factors are weighed.

We are really grateful to have learned from local stakeholders here about the challenges that they’re facing. We feel very honored to be welcomed here, and we see a real opportunity not only for Hawaiʻi to align with best practices around the country, but really to be an example for the rest of the country.

Molly Crane of Families Against Mandatory Minimums testifying at an informational briefing on compassionate release at the Hawaiʻi Legislature Oct. 22. (Screenshot/2026)

Is there currently a bill that you know of in the works for the upcoming session?

We do have a bill, and we’re starting with a conference draft because all the legislators agreed about the language of the bill.

So you’re going to take that conference draft, the one that was already agreed upon and they were just waiting to sign off on it in conference, and that died. Who are the advocates you’re working with?

Rep. Amy Perruso is an ally for us. Rep. Della Au Belatti was an ally before. Rep. David Tarnas is a strong supporter. Sen. Carol Fukunaga, of course. But what I will say is that, across the board, we have seen great support from legislators about this measure. It’s a bipartisan effort, all the way to the top. Even Senate President Ron Kouchi is supportive of this measure.

Looking at the bill, as is common during conference, they left the dollar amount blank. But is there a dollar figure that we can estimate, or that you have in mind? And what would that money be used for?

Well, there were different drafts. The draft that we introduced and the one that we plan to introduce does not include an appropriation.

So you will not be asking for money.

We are not. No, the department asked for two FTEs, I believe.

Reps. Kim Coco Iwamoto, Della Au Belatti and Amy Perruso of the House Public Safety Committee at the briefing. (Screenshot/2026)

Full-time equivalent for staffing. Where would they work?

Their hope is to have that person work within the medical team to work on placement issues for people within the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. So that’s our understanding. Part of why it received triple (committee) referrals is because of the cost savings. We’ve estimated that in the first year alone, it could save approximately $15 million for the state if implemented.

That would seem to be a small price to pay for a great savings.

We’re certainly not against the department having the resources they need.

What do you think is different this time? Obviously, it’s going to be a new Legislature, and you are taking out the appropriation. If I understand correctly, the Legislature rejected this in 2013, 2014 and 2023. And 2019, it passed but Gov. David Ige vetoed it. The concern there was medical staff might become overburdened with requests.

I think this time we have so much support from community members all across various sectors. We have Native Hawaiian practitioners, we have survivors of crimes, we have former corrections officers, we have medical staff. We really have the support in the community, and I think what we learned last session was that this didn’t die because of a problem with the bill. It was many other factors, and we were very heartbroken for all the people who shared their testimonies last year, and all the people we know who have died because the bill didn’t pass this last year in conference.

Bob Merce, a community advocate engaged in facilitating compassionate releases, and Molly Crane, a counsel with Families Against Mandatory Minimums, in the Civil Beat offices in October. (Chad Blair/Civil Beat/2026)

This is from Tommy Johnson’s testimony last time. He said, “At present, there are 20 people in their custody serving sentences of life without possibility of parole. Twelve of them are convicted of first-degree murder, and some have lesser offenses like carrying a firearm, the commission of a felony, rape, sodomy, kidnapping, assault, and other offenses.”

Several are serving life without the possibility of parole, and then he says the remaining eight are LWOP — that’s life without the possibility of parole — serving sentences for attempted murder in the first degree. Many of these inmates have extensive criminal records, where they preyed upon the community. In some cases, their own family. His main argument is we’re letting out people who have a terrible record. And then, of course, the big fear is they might commit another crime. How would you respond to Mr. Johnson’s raising that point?

The first thing I’ll say is that the majority of parole board states treat people serving life without parole or those with unserved mandatory minimums as eligible. This is not a partisan issue. States like Alabama, Georgia, Florida, Kentucky, all the way to New Mexico, Utah, D.C. Alaska — they all agree that these people should be eligible because the purpose of compassionate release, beyond providing dignity and healing for families, is to alleviate pressure on the system, to decrease costs, and to support staff.

I think compassionate release addresses factors that have come up since sentencing, and the benefit of compassionate consideration is that it’s individualized. Right now, the Hawaii Paroling Authority, their discretion is constrained because they can’t consider these people, no matter how sick they are, no matter how much there’s a burden. Best programs give the paroling authority the authority to exercise their discretion on an individualized basis instead of having categorical exclusions.

From a presentation by Families Against Mandatory Minimums presentation at an informational briefing on compassionate release. (Screenshot/2026)

Robert Merce: If I can add just one thing, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation doesn’t have the ability to take care of people who are really sick and really old. They have an infirmary right now, and it’s got six cells with two people in a cell. There’s nothing else in the cell except a steel toilet. The beds are not modern hospital beds. They are just kind of old beds. They are about three feet apart, so there’s no privacy. There’s a little tiny window, but there’s nothing in it except two little tables and the steel toilet, and so there’s no medical equipment in there. There’s nothing to monitor blood pressure or any of those things. It is totally inappropriate to try and keep people who are really sick and terminally ill, brain tumors, Lou Gehrig’s disease, stomach cancer. We have those people in there. We have people with lymphoma, and I mean, really, really terrible diseases. They’re going to die, and they deserve to be in, No. 1, in a place that’s appropriate physically, a place where they get really good care from really good caregivers, and all the palliative medication that they can get, that are appropriate for them, so that they don’t suffer during that terrible time.

But the people we see out there today are suffering. I mean, they can’t get out of bed. They’re in a cell. Some of the cells are dark because they don’t want the lights on, and they cover their heads up with a blanket, and it’s cold, and it smells of bleach, and it’s ugly. And that is the way we treat these people. And to suggest that because you have a sentence of life of parole, this is the way they should die, is just totally inhumane and completely inappropriate for this state, which prides itself on being a state of aloha and compassion.

Crane: What I will just add, if that’s okay, is that by the time someone is granted compassionate release, the department and the paroling authority have already determined that they pose a low risk to public safety and they remain on parole supervision. But these people are functionally compromised.

I haven’t looked at the latest numbers on the number of inmates in our prisons and jails, as well as in Arizona, I want to say it’s around 3,000 or 4,000 people. How many of those people are you thinking should be let out with this program?

We’re waiting on those numbers from the department. I think that their medical director needs to go out to Saguaro (Correctional Center in Arizona) and assess where those cases stand. We have a better sense of the people who are here on island, but there are plenty at Saguaro who would qualify.

From a presentation by Families Against Mandatory Minimums presentation at an informational briefing on compassionate release. (Screenshot/2026)

This is from Pamela Ferguson Brey, the executive director at the Crime Victim Compensation, and I’m sure you’ve seen her testimony. “Criminal justice reform can not only serve the interests of the offender, but must also include meaningful protection for crime victims to avoid harmful unintended consequences.”

She testified that the bill does not provide notice to the victim that the offender is being considered for release, allowing no opportunity for the victim to be heard about the release consideration or to create a safety plan prior to that release, that this could be traumatizing, and then she goes on to mention that maybe this undermines the Hawaii Paroling Authority to consider all the relevant factors when they’re making their decisions. How would you respond to that? The impact on victims is her biggest concern?

And that’s such an important consideration. This in no way is intended to minimize the harm that people have experienced. I think the question is, do we want to create more harm? And what she said, unfortunately, I think there may be confusion because it’s not correct. We’ve put in the bill exactly what the paroling authority already does, which is that they do provide notice to victims ahead of this hearing and the opportunity to weigh in. So the bill actually says exactly what she was asking for. I don’t know if she was maybe confused, but that is incorporated in the bill.

Where would these inmates go if they are released? I’m understanding that nursing homes may have had some resistance to taking them. Some of these people don’t have families or don’t have families that want to take them back. We already have, as you all know, very overcrowded prisons and jails here. Where would they go if they didn’t have any place to go?

Merce: Can I just add one thing to what Molly was saying? I think it’s important for people to keep in the front of their mind and pay attention to is that simply because somebody is eligible and applies for a compassion relief doesn’t mean in every case 100% that it will necessarily be granted. It’s the right to be considered for compassion release if you meet the appropriate criteria, and there may be situations where someone is denied and the people who are released on parole with a parole officer, and most of them can’t get out of bed and can’t really can’t walk.

Are there facilities to take somebody in in this kind of situation? Is it a nursing home? Is it an assisted-living facility? Is there resistance on the part of these organizations? As you know, there’s great demand with our aging population. Where would they, especially on an island?

Crane: I think it’s important to remember that survivors are not a monolith. We had many survivors testify at the hearings that they do believe in compassionate release and they do support this effort. I think it’s important framing survivors —

Bob Merce testifying at the informational briefing. To his left is Tommy Johnson, director of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. (Screenshot/2026)

Survivors of the victims that were harmed by these inmates.

Survivors is just like a more empowering term for victims. So, yeah, we had victims also testify at the hearings that, you know, this position did not speak for them. They were in support of the bill.

Did you have any survivors testifying the opposite, saying no, you shouldn’t be releasing?

No. And in terms of nursing homes, I really have to commend the very impressive efforts of Corey Reincke from the Hawaii Paroling Authority in partnership with Bob. They have been working very hard to build relationships with nursing homes so that they understand this population, so that their questions are answered, so that they feel comfortable and have the support they need if they accept people. In the last year or so we’ve seen a number of people who were granted compassionate release but still sitting in prison due to lack of placement come home to nursing homes. Even in the last two weeks, I think we had two gentlemen …

Merce: One has ALS, Lou Gehrig’s disease, and can barely move. He’s in a private nursing facility here in Hawaiʻi. They accepted him. He’s intubated he’s really happy. I’ve seen him. And the other gentleman we got has metastatic prostate cancer, he’s been languishing in the infirmary for a long, long time, and this nursing home accepted him as well. Recently, we have been able to get a few people into the Lēʻahi Hospital. And only a few can be released at home, but almost never. But we’re working on that every day. As Molly said, we’re visiting nursing homes. We’re trying to get them to understand more about this population and why they would be actually in some cases an asset to their nursing home.

Crane: We’ve even managed to bring nursing home providers into the facility to meet with people directly, so they can assess them in person.

When you get someone into a nursing facility or over at Lēʻahi, certainly, assisted living and nursing homes can be very expensive. Who’s paying for that?

From a presentation by Families Against Mandatory Minimums presentation at an informational briefing on compassionate release. (Screenshot/2026)

Crane: Here’s one of the benefits of compassionate release: When people are in custody, by and large, the department and the state are responsible for 100% of that person’s medical costs. When they’re out in the community on Medicaid, the federal government covers 60 to 90% of those costs, depending on the program the person is in. So we could go from the state paying 100% of that person’s costs to as low as 10% of those costs in the community.

Are you essentially arguing that there would ultimately be a cost savings rather than the expense that it already costs to incarcerate?

Yes, absolutely. Right now, there are people who, in a five-month span, cost the department $1.5 million. So the department and the state are responsible for 100% of that $.5 million. In the community, it could be 10% of that cost. And you know, federal Medicaid spending in Hawaiʻi is about 73%.

This is not in statute, but there does exist a compassionate release program that helps influence the parole authority. Do I have that correct? So if somebody is ill, they are able to apply, or their attorney, or a family member. Could you just walk me through how the existing program works?

Merce: In some cases, the department simply recognizes that somebody is eligible based on their medical condition, and we do have a policy. The policy has the criteria, and when they see somebody, the department will just, on their own, initiate the process, and that works fairly well. The medical director writes a report. It goes up through several levels of bureaucracy to the director. The director signs off on it, and then it goes over to the parole board, and the parole board will then take a look at it. They’ll have a hearing on it, and if they agree, then the person is eligible for is granted compassionate release, pending placement.

That’s always the condition: to make sure that they’re not just going to be released on the street, but they’re going to have appropriate housing. And if they’re going, for example, to a private home, the parole board will go out there. They’ll check out the house, who lives there — you know, whether there are any criminals or any guns in the house.

And when we talk about releasing these people into the community that have committed serious crimes, very few people are life without parole. Almost all of the rest are coming back into the community — they’re out. You can walk into a nursing home and they say, “We don’t want anybody who’s got this criminal record.” Well, you look at your hospitals, your grocery stores, the post office. There are people with criminal records all around, and they’re functioning safely. We want these people to be accepted into nursing homes because they’re part of our community. They’re sick and they’re with other sick people, and that’s where they belong.

What haven’t we discussed?

Crane: I think one of the things that is important to us in this is that Native Hawaiians are disproportionately impacted by this issue.

The Office of Hawaiian Affairs testified in support.

That’s correct. (Hawaiians) are disproportionately incarcerated, and I think OHA spoke about sort of the intergenerational impacts and how people can experience culture and healing at the end of life, and how this disrupts ʻohana. So I think that’s central for us, that this is something for Native Hawaiians by Native Hawaiians. I think there are a lot of things that the bill does to improve the process — timelines, transparency. It literally codifies collaboration where it may be breaking down right now. Right now we don’t know what’s going wrong because the data is not being collected.

Elaborate on that.

Meaning how applications are being considered, how long does it take for them to be reviewed? How many people are being denied? How long is it taking to find placement for individuals?

How many people are sick?

How many people are sick? Who is benefiting from this policy?

And this is Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation — that’s the blockage there.

I didn’t say blockage, but I said right now they’re not collecting data, and that’s true for the paroling authority as well.

So they are not collecting at all. It’s just not a matter of them having the data and releasing it. They’re just simply not collecting it.

That’s my understanding. I think they have internal processes for identifying people, but they’re not monitoring these data. Like, how much are we spending on this population? How many applications are we putting forth and considering? And so that’s a big part of our process.

What I will say is, I think that absence of this statute means that people are languishing and dying in prison. I will say as well, you know. I think we’ve heard from so many staff members how much they’re struggling to provide the care that people need, how difficult it is for morale.

Staff members in the prison, the jails.

Yeah, absolutely. Hawaiʻi is also an outlier in the fact that it is the only state where the department has opposed compassionate release legislation. Every other place where the department is, in Texas and Georgia and Alabama, every other state where the department has taken a position, it’s either been neutral or in favor. And they’ve cited the reasons that staff have given us, which is that it’s difficult for staff, it’s costly for the department, there’s overcrowding, they can’t provide adequate care, and so I think you know Hawaii is an outlier in that as well.

Why is Hawai‘i an outlier, do you think?

I don’t want to speak for Hawaiʻi.

Merce: I really don’t understand it because we have a tradition of aloha. We, by and large, take it seriously, and yet on correctional issues, we seem to be very kind of a red state, and I just don’t know the reason for that. I wish I did have an answer. I really don’t understand it.

Okay.

Merce: One other thing is, we talked about the costs, and just another aspect of the cost is you put people in, you keep the people who are old and aging and get sick, and who otherwise would be released for compassionate release. They get sick, and they can’t be cared for in this minimal sort of facility, which is just an infirmary. They end up taking them in the emergency room to the emergency room at either Queens or Pali Momi, and then they get treated immediately. Then they get into an acute care bed, and then they bounce back later after they recover. And this cycle just keeps going on.

And whenever somebody is in the hospital, they have to have two guards, at least one guard with them at all times, 24 hours a day. Sometimes they chain these people to the bed, and they have to do the transportation back and forth. And maybe Molly can jump in on some of the data, but I mean, that puts such a drain on their staff that they can’t really do the rest of the things that they’re supposed to do.

Leahi Hospital. Diamond Head. 22 dec 2016
Lēʻahi Hospital, which has begun to allow some terminally ill inmates. Cory Lum/Civil Beat/2016

Crane: The Hawaii Correctional System Oversight Commission found that 60% of correction staff develop serious health conditions from job stress, and what we understand is that right now they have five patients who need dialysis off-site three times a week, and at least two officers have to escort them. And because there are so few officers, from 2 to 10 p.m. Monday, Wednesday and Friday, the facility has no movement. That means no one else can go out for medical appointments. No one’s going out to yard, and they have a backlog right now of 300 medical appointments that have not been scheduled because of these shortages.

Merce: We had one person who was admitted — I think it was on Jan. 3 of last year — and he he was in Queens for five or six months in an acute care bed with a guard with him, 24 hours a day, for month after month after month,

What happened?

Finally, he was paroled to Queens, and Queens has a facility, some part of Kuakini Hospital, and they have care beds there, and they moved him over there. He’s been granted compassionate release, and he’s getting the care that he needs over at Kuakini, courtesy, I guess, of Queens.

Crane: I think just for us, our families are so important. They’re the center of what we do. Just one example this year, we had a gentleman who passed, and the family had to ask questions like, “Was he alone when he died? Was he handcuffed to a hospital bed? Was he wearing prison clothes when he died? If he was sick for so long, why did he still die in prison?” And we have compassionate release. It’s deeply painful for families, and so we hope that this will pass this year, and we’re very eager to collaborate to get it across the finish line.

Chad Blair is the politics editor for Civil Beat.