The opinions in this piece reflect personal commentary.
No, really. Why?
We needed a change in the Maui Police Department. We needed someone with the qualifications, experience, and willingness to make that change.
And we got John Pelletier.
He earned the position through an open, measurable process. He was selected for his qualifications alone. No relationships. Just skills.
His plan was to change the authoritarian system of policing we knew to community-led policing. That is what he meant when he talked about 21st-century policing. He had a plan, implemented it, used metrics to evaluate its progress, and adjusted based on what those metrics showed.
That’s the bare minimum we should expect from accountable leadership.
But we made him work for us without a hint of care.

Ideas showcases stories, opinion and analysis about Hawaiʻi, from the state’s sharpest thinkers, to stretch our collective thinking about a problem or an issue. Email news@civilbeat.org to submit an idea or an essay.
We did not care if we were dismissive, purposefully ignorant, hypercritical, or unkind because we believed he deserved it. Because he wasn’t one of us. He wasn’t from here. And he was police.
For the first few years, I refused to like him. I stayed very critical of him.
And I understand why others would, too.

Our fundamental cultural flaw here is: If I don’t know your auntie or the high school you went to, you don’t belong here.
You don’t belong here. That’s heavy.
Nā Kānaka are still reeling from the grief and loss of what once was and are picking up the broken pieces of that identity. I feel that so deeply.
I’m not kanaka. My cultural pottery may be different, but the motions of searching for the scattered pieces of who we once were and trying to put them back into something even close to what once was, under the conditions we’ve been left in, are painfully familiar.
That pain doesn’t go away just because it started generations ago. That wound heals slowly because of what we face every day.
As if I can blame anyone for not accepting change?
I understand the desire to protect yourself. To refuse to engage with a system that has given you so many reasons not to trust it.
It took me years to do anything different. To see a person behind a uniform.
The world of policing is weird.
So many rules and so much structure. Sameness. It feels unnatural. They’re not robots.
They’re people.
People who flow between the rigidity of the law and the complexity of humanity, trying not to break either one. That’s a weird world to exist in.
The thing is, we have really good people at MPD who decided to become police officers.
They could have been veterinarians or professors or pitmasters or kumu hula or chicken farmers, but for whatever reason, life led them to policing in Maui County.
Being led by some … outsider.
It is hard to lead humans. Even harder when they don’t inherently trust you.
No one in Maui County who had suffered an injustice was going to inherently trust John Pelletier. He was going to have to do the work to prove himself.
And he did.
One of the first things Chief Pelletier did was create the MPD Multicultural Advisory Counsel. I am a founding member.
Instead of closing the door on the toughest critics of MPD, John invited us in.
So, we yelled at him in his own office.
I refused to give him compliments or praise. I often reminded him in our MMAC meetings that it was not my job to praise him. It was my job to hold him accountable (fairly).
I tested him. I forced him into uncomfortable spaces to see if he could handle them.
But he was patient. He listened. He learned. He made changes.
That’s good leadership.
It took me five years to let my guard down. And these are not my stolen lands. I’ve never been incarcerated. I’ve never had a mental health crisis that required first responders. I’ve never been unhoused. I am economically stable. I am free.
It still took me five years.
We need every bit of knowledge and skill we can get.
The resistance is not lost on me.
But should we keep doing this?
We are in an environmental crisis.
We need every bit of knowledge and skill we can get.
We need to manage the resources we have. All of them. Including the people.
Chief John Pelletier is a resource. His experience, his ability to manage complex organizations during a crisis, his willingness to learn — for us.
Have we been squandering a resource?
From every book I’ve read and every story I’ve been told about Hawaiian leadership, one thing has been clear to me.
Nā Aliʻi were smart.
They knew how to manage resources. They knew how to incorporate new technologies.
They understood consequences. They knew how to be open to change and how to cleverly utilize it to benefit everyone.
Which brings me back to: Why are we doing this?
Maybe the why is that we are being taught something right now.
Maybe we are being taught that good resource management isn’t just knowing how to use a resource.
Maybe it’s having the wisdom to recognize one in the first place.
