The state’s response to a labor complaint from the Hawaii State Teachers Association is brisk, to the point, at times humorous and even gently sarcastic. And there’s substance, too.
On June 8, the union lodged a formal complaint against the state, accusing it of unilaterally imposing new employment terms on the state’s 12,500 teachers. The union said the state refused to negotiate in good faith and prematurely declared impasse. Hawaii filed its response late Thursday with the Hawaii Labor Relations Board, just before the 10-day deadline.
Among the key claims made in the state’s defense:
- HSTA President Wil Okabe reassured state negotiators he would recommend the state’s “last, best and final” offer, but later voted against it with the union’s board of directors, thus denying HSTA membership a ratification vote.
- HSTA failed to bargain in good faith and failed to exhaust all available remedies during negotiations.
- The state never implemented a statewide government “policy” of 5 percent salary cuts.
- The state acknowledges that HSTA never agreed that negotiations had reached an impasse. (The state has said that talks had reached an impasse, and HSTA has denied that.) It also states that HSTA rejected offers for mediation.
- The union’s rejection of the “last, best and final” offer meant there were no proposals left on the table. It was that offer the state imposed.
The response consists of 12 defenses, including one that says the union’s legal claims “are barred by laches, waiver, estoppel, and unclean hands.” Which, as best we can tell, means HSTA stood in the way of negotiations, deliberately overstepped statutory limitations and waived its rights by bargaining in bad faith.
“HSTA’s claims are barred by the defense of bad faith bargaining conduct,” the document says. “HSTA has engaged in a consistent pattern and practice of bad faith bargaining and litigation over the past three years, involving several collective bargaining agreements and ensuing litigation, and this pattern and practice has been repeated and reinforced in HSTA’s current negotiations.”
The response also says that HSTA failed to exhaust all available remedies (read: Didn’t bargain in good faith), and reaffirms Gov. Neil Abercrombie‘s claim that union negotiators shook hands on an agreement that was later rejected by HSTA’s board.
The document says that at the end of a June 17 meeting, state negotiator Neil Dietz told HSTA President Wil Okabe, “I am going to email the Governor to tell him we have reached an agreement that you will recommend to your Board. Is that absolutely correct?” and Okabe responded in the affirmative.
The state’s summary and 12 defenses are the most substantive portion of the document. After those, the state responds point by point to 66 of HSTA’s 96 allegations, lumping the last 30 together in a blanket denial.
They are for the most part denials of “HSTA’s characterization” of the state Constitution and various statutes. The state admits only to factual information contained in HSTA’s complaint — like the claim that Don Horner is in fact the chairman of the Hawaii State Board of Education. Occasionally the document elaborates on the state’s denials with a hint of what my grandmother calls “smart-aleck” attitude.
Respondents agree with HSTA’s tacit acknowledgement that HSTA did not bargain in “earnest” before March 31, 2011. However, Respondents deny that they were not bargaining in “earnest” before March 31, 2011 or at any other time since that date.
Incidentally, the state doesn’t deny Dietz’s momentary outburst of profanity.
Ultimately, these arguments will be aired in public at a hearing before the Labor Relations Board. No date has been set.
Read Hawaii’s entire response:
Read our related coverage:
- Abercrombie Vs. Hawaii Teachers: What’s At Stake
- HSTA President: We Just Want To Negotiate
- Gov Posts FAQ On Hawaii Teachers Contract * HSTA Files Against ‘Take-It-Or-Leave-It’ Tactics
- Details of Hawaii Teachers Contract Imposed By State
- Teachers To File Legal Challenge This Week
- Report Card on a Teachers Strike: Lessons From 2001
- No Legal Action By Hawaii Teachers — Yet
- HSTA Pay Cuts Comparable To HGEA’s
- Union Rep: Gov Failed to Bargain In ‘Good Faith’
- Could Teacher Contract Talks Affect Race To The Top?
- Gov: Union Negotiators Agreed To HSTA Contract
- ‘Last, Best, Final’ Offer For Hawaii Teachers
