A recent I Mua Rail commercial titled “Local Jobs” suggests that the Honolulu rail project has generated a wealth of local jobs. The commercial touts the rail as benefitting Honolulu because it employs “many” University of Hawaii graduates.
“Rail has given many UH graduates like myself the opportunity to stay home and work,” says one man featured in the spot, an engineer who’s identified as Brandon Silva.
Civil Beat has previously reported about the number of local jobs created by the rail project. But how many of them are UH grads?
I Mua Rail is a campaign of the Pacific Resource Partnership (PRP) designed to promote the Honolulu rail project. PRP is a pro-rail union group associated with the Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters union.
We first got in touch with the Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transit (HART), which already tallies the number of local jobs generated by rail. As of late April, that number was roughly 300, or about 60 percent of all the employees working on rail.
But to get a count of how many rail employees graduated from UH, Jeanne Mariani-Belding, a HART spokesperson, said we’d have to contact each contractor and sub-contractor directly.
There are at least 15 companies currently contracted with the city to construct the rail, including Kiewit, AECOM and PB Americas, Inc..
We reached out to about seven of the companies. Only two responded.
One was Ansaldo Honolulu, the project’s main contractor. Out of the 13 local employees Ansaldo currently employs for the rail project, only one is a UH graduate, according to company spokesperson Malia Jansson. The employee is an accountant who majored in math. (The company also employs one Hawaii Pacific University graduate.)
The other contractor that we heard back from was Kiewit. In late April, the company employed nearly 250 workers for the rail. Kiewit currently employs 30 UH grads, including its Senior Vice President Lance Wilhelm, according to a company spokesperson. That number doesn’t include employees working for Kiewit subcontractors, said the spokesperson.
Given that the man featured in the commercial is an engineer, we also decided to give UH’s College of Engineering a call.
But the college doesn’t track graduates’ employment, according to spokesperson Eric Matsunaga.
He did, however, note that potential rail contractors have participated in college career fairs seeking graduates for employment.
When we asked those at I Mua Rail how they know that the rail has given “many” UH graduates employment, it took a few days for them to come up with an answer.
Here’s what Cindy McMillan, Project Manager for Strategic Initiatives at PRP, had to say:
“The statement in our TV ad is a summation of factual information,” she wrote. “While we don’t have actual data, it is highly likely, given our population base, that a large percentage of people working on all facets of the rail project, including engineeering, are UH graduates or graduates of a UH system school.”
BOTTOM LINE: An I Mua Rail “Local Jobs” commercial states that the rail project has given “many” UH grads jobs. HART does not track this statistic. Neither do the individual contractors, save for ad hoc head counts. A spokesperson for I Mua Rail acknowledged that the statement isn’t derived from “actual data,” but rather an assumption based on hypothetical circumstances. Civil Beat’s cursory research shows just 31 out of 300 local rail jobs are held by UH grads. We find PRP’s claim to be MOSTLY FALSE.
